I don’t know what you’re rambling about. Lin Biao was a complete ambitionist and con artist. Your so-called “dialectical materialism” saying that even though he defected abroad, he still had good qualities, is actually just a vulgar dichotomy that ignores the main aspects of things, people, and contradictions. Saying “there are good and bad” is essentially exaggerating some trivial “good” of people whose main aspect is bad in order to whitewash them. Moreover, your claim that Lin Biao was a “military genius,” “outstanding politician,” and “propagandist of Mao Zedong Thought” is completely untrue. His battles during the Liberation War were actually quite ordinary, especially the battles like the Battle of Tashan, which reflect that he did not treat the lives of PLA soldiers as precious, just like past bourgeois military leaders, stacking weapons and soldiers. The widely circulated phrase “I don’t care about casualties, I only want Tashan!” is clear evidence of this. He was engaged in a military white-terror route. As for being a politician and propagandist of Mao Zedong Thought, that is even more absurd. During the Cultural Revolution, he was completely a “left” extreme right, essentially not learning or understanding Marxism-Leninism. Most of his “propaganda” of Mao Zedong Thought was more about establishing a counter-revolutionary authority for himself to seize power.
When you say “military genius,” do you mean that during Jinggangshan he heavily promoted defeatism and wanted to become bandits and warlords, during the Fourth and Fifth Anti-“Encirclement and Suppression” campaigns he advocated the so-called “short, sharp assaults” and supported Wang Ming’s reactionary military line, opposed Chairman Mao’s revolutionary military line, conspired with Peng Dehuai during the Long March to seize Chairman Mao’s military power, during the Anti-Japanese War praised Chiang Kai-shek as the “supreme commander,” opposed Chairman Mao’s guerrilla warfare ideas and fought the Japanese head-on at Pingxingguan causing unnecessary casualties, during the Liberation War to turn Northeast into his own independent kingdom he opposed, treating the Fourth Field Army as his private army and refused to follow Mao’s orders to attack Jinzhou, during the Korean War he was extremely fearful of U.S. imperialism and refused to command the Volunteer Army to fight in Korea, frantically promoted the idealist and metaphysical “Six Tactical Principles,” right? When you say “outstanding politician” and “propagandist of Mao Zedong Thought,” do you mean someone who consistently promoted defeatism, exaggerated the strength of the Kuomintang, praised Chiang Kai-shek during the Anti-Japanese War, exaggerated U.S. imperialist strength during the Korean War, sought to align with the Soviet Union during the Cultural Revolution as a puppet emperor, secretly wrote black notes to insult Chairman Mao, talked about “regime change” at the start of the Cultural Revolution, formed factions within the military, gathered loyalists, pieced together “united fleets” of counterrevolutionaries, and at the Ninth Congress conspired with Chen Boda to draft revisionist reports on productivity theory, and at the Lushan Conference of the Ninth Plenary Session, under the guise of calling himself a genius and establishing a state chairman, conspired to launch a coup, usurped the highest party and state power, and finally, in a desperate attempt, planned an armed counterrevolutionary coup to harm Chairman Mao, which was exposed, leading him to flee and crash in Wutun’erhan? Or does it refer to his poison of the entire party and the nation—Confucian and Mencian doctrines, the so-called “Four Greats” with ulterior motives, promoting feudal loyalist ideas of “Three Loyalties and Four Unlimitings,” the slave ideology of “one sentence top ten thousand sentences,” “understand and execute, not understand but also execute,” the so-called “great tree” of “absolute authority,” falsely claiming to oppose Mao Zedong under Mao’s banner to establish his personal counterrevolutionary authority, vulgarizing Marxism by only reading the “Old Three Articles,” slandering the uselessness of Capital, and claiming that Marx, Engels, Lenin, and Stalin’s works are all useless?
He compiled the quotations, claiming that one of Chairman Mao’s words is worth ten thousand sentences, but in reality, he was simply using this to praise himself. The so-called “popularization” of Mao Zedong Thought is just a disguise. Chairman Mao directly evaluated him as follows: What is called “greatly establishing a tree”—the name says “tree I,” but it does not know who it is actually a tree of; in essence, it is a tree of himself (“Notes on the conversations between Chairman Mao and responsible comrades from various places along the route during his inspection tour outside the city, mid-August to September 12, 1971”)
So your sentence still doesn’t really answer anything. The errors in formal logic and your logical mistakes, as well as language errors, don’t matter. This is similar to your idol Lin Biao, who was also unskilled and talked about the uselessness of language.
Regarding what you said about being a military genius, someone has already refuted you on that. The so-called military genius—military is an extension of politics. I have never seen a reactionary and decayed class in politics demonstrate any genius in the military field.
According to your vulgar dialectical method, I could also say that although Xi Jinping is a fascist, he has also implemented “comprehensive poverty alleviation” to reduce farmers’ burdens. He has also vigorously promoted infrastructure construction, earning China the title of “infrastructure maniac.” One cannot deny that Xi Jinping is very skilled at economic development and construction, after all, we must view things dialectically.
Lin Biao is a military genius of the P type, but Lin Biao fundamentally doesn’t know how to fight, and what kind of genius are you talking about? Just like the Lin faction. To promote Lin Biao’s crazy opposition to the epistemology of dialectical materialism. Chairman Mao said, “The correctness of the line determines everything,” and Lin Biao’s line is a reactionary and regressive line. Not valuing soldiers’ lives will lead to the San Meng tactics, resulting in many deaths at Tashan. Is this called equipment? Your military genius?
Refer to the Soviet Union.
Just like a coin, two sides of the same body. Lin’s positive side: a military genius, one of the ten marshals, an outstanding politician and Maoist propagandaist; negative side: a deep schemer with a hidden agenda. Overall evaluation: outwardly left, actually right (Mao’s words), and his later years were not well preserved.
Lenin once evaluated revisionism as “replacing revolutionary dialectics with vulgar sophistry,” and Chairman Mao once said, “War is the continuation of politics.” If a person is politically reactionary, how can they fight a good war, especially a war to liberate the people? Secondly, regarding the so-called Mao Zedong Thought propagandists, Chairman Mao directly evaluated Lin Biao’s behavior of excessively praising Chairman Mao, calling it “claiming to be a tree, but actually planting himself,” and “one sentence cannot top ten thousand sentences, not half a sentence.” These have already exposed Lin Biao’s true face of “shouting ‘Long live’ face to face, but secretly plotting harm behind the scenes.” Moreover, what kind of “outstanding politician” can a schemer be? And this politician is also someone who does not need to be a class-conscious politician. In fact, your set of arguments seems to use dialectics, but in reality, it is just sophistry defending Lin Biao, replacing the vulgar two-point theory of “two sides of a coin” with the focus theory—doesn’t a person have a main aspect? In fact, this is just giving Lin Biao a whitewash, praising him as a military genius, an outstanding politician, etc., which is just this set of arguments.
Furthermore, your sophistry is factually untenable. Comrade Luanma used Lin Biao’s crimes to question you, so why are you afraid to reply? It is nothing but seeing that the debate is at an impasse, already shattered by facts, so you simply talk nonsense, engage in subjective idealism, and say Lin Biao was a military genius, etc.—just this set of arguments. I advise you not to peddle sophistry and subjective idealism here. Instead, explain why you are so eager to exonerate Lin Biao.
Why do you insist on quoting content from some modern books?
Having read the so-called “official documents,” the evaluation of Firefly Flame is: saying one thing and doing another, self-centered reform, greed for power and scheming, with the left hand appearing to be on the right. Whether it’s called the “Proletarian Liberation Struggle Association” or the “Firefly Flame Dynasty,” it doesn’t matter. From this, it can be inferred that this association is unlikely to achieve great things and has limited influence.
A typical petty bourgeoisie, anarchist view of authority, claiming to oppose dictatorship, is actually slandering opposition to the dictatorship of the proletariat, waving the red flag to attack the red flag, very reactionary.
If you want to debate, then come and try to debate. Spouting nonsense here, does anyone believe it? You make a conclusion without any logic or evidence, do you still want to persuade others to believe your words? Don’t be funny. You are wildly whitewashing Lin Biao, citing大量引用复辟之后出的书和修正主义分子说的话, using AI to deceive others in self-introduction, replacing dialectics with sophistry, isn’t that proof that you actually know nothing about revolution or Marxism, and are even using your reactionary bourgeois思想 to distort Marxism and dialectics? To justify your revisionist theories for Lin Biao, Prabhandra, and others, serving your unspeakable purposes. Isn’t this what all revisionists, all leftists, and anarchists love to do? Especially the帽子你给烽火扣上的, and only dare to pull out some trash but dare not debate at all, it’s exactly what these three reactionary groups love to do and have been doing. You’re just that much.
I can only say: very funny
Fomentar la iniciativa de las masas no se logra solo confiando en la propaganda de políticas económicas correctas. La propiedad final se realiza a través del poder de gestión. La economía socialista de propiedad pública solo puede ser correctamente implementada cuando la clase proletaria toma el control de la superestructura, cuando el pensamiento proletario domina el pensamiento. Por lo tanto, no se trata solo de promover políticas económicas, sino de centrarse en criticar en el ámbito político la línea burguesa, criticar la ideología burguesa y eliminar todos los derechos legales de la burguesía. Decir solo que se promueven políticas económicas reduce esto a un determinismo educativo de la escuela ilustrada, lo cual es vulgarización.