{ “content”: “Preface\nToday we discuss a brief history of the Chinese Communist Party, specifically the preface to the lectures on the history of the two-line struggle, which is timely as we are discussing this book. This is important for our deeper understanding of Marxism, especially the understanding of class struggle and line struggle.\nAs you may have seen, a summary of the first part of the conference report was posted on the forum a few days ago. Going forward, I will try to post on this forum the parts that are not related to organizational secrets or security concerns, for everyone’s reference. Some theoretical issues are also discussed here.\nNow, discussing these party histories is also to relearn the experiences of the two-line and two-class struggles in history, to serve our current class struggle.\nBack then, the proletarian revolutionary mentor Lenin led the October Socialist Revolution of 1917 in Russia, which brought Marxism-Leninism to the Chinese people. The fusion of Marxism-Leninism with the Chinese revolutionary movement produced the Chinese Communist Party, the vanguard of the Chinese proletariat. Since its founding on July 1, 1921, the CCP has been more than 50 years. For more than five decades, under the guidance of Marxism-Leninism, Mao Zedong Thought as the theoretical basis, the CCP has led the Chinese people in armed struggle to seize power and in consolidating the dictatorship of the proletariat, fighting bravely. After a long and arduous struggle, it overthrew the “three mountains” of imperialism, feudalism, and bureaucratic capitalism, and achieved the great victory of the new-democratic revolution.\nChairman Mao pointed out: “A party built according to the revolutionary theory and revolutionary style of Marxism-Leninism; a party-led army; and a united front led by such a party, these three are the important weapons for seizing power and consolidating power.” This is what we commonly refer to as the “Three Great Treasures,” corresponding to the three central issues of party building, armed struggle, and united front. The central issue of the proletarian revolution was the Chinese revolution’s development along this path. After the founding of the PRC, under Chairman Mao’s correct line, the CCP adhered to the theory and practice of continuing revolution under the dictatorship of the proletariat, achieving great victories in socialist revolution and socialist construction.\nIn fact, what we need now is to strengthen organizational construction, to strive for the establishment of a nationwide political party. This also means continuing along the line Mao Zedong pointed out, making full use of the Three Great Treasures. First of all, there must be a Communist Party with revolutionary theory and revolutionary style; this is the meaning of the ideological struggle and theoretical struggle we are now carrying out. How did Chairman Mao’s revolutionary theory and revolutionary style come about? It is brought about through ideological struggle, which is also called theoretical struggle. Only a Communist Party that has been tempered by fierce class struggle, and the proletariat and intellectuals it produces, can be regarded as a true Communist Party. A petty-bourgeois who has no experience of class struggle can never be regarded as part of the Communist Party, nor can they be trusted to undertake the duty of building the party.\nIn fact, history has shown many petty-bourgeois elements infiltrating the CCP, and some even seized power at one point. Why? Because the party at that time was not mature enough and could not test Marxism’s truth through practical experience, allowing certain fake-Marxists and some intellectuals to deceive for a long time. Mao said: “I urge comrades to read more, to avoid being deceived by intellectuals.” In the past, the CCP was deceived by intellectuals for a long time, for 14 years, causing huge losses.\nThe first to deceive was Chen Duxiu. From the founding of the CCP, there was no test by revolutionary practice or the actual results to elect a general secretary or form a class force. Instead they elected Chen Duxiu, a man with a famous name who had been caught by police for brothels and fights at Peking University, as general secretary. Chen Duxiu did not participate in founding or organizing the CCP, and did not attend the CCP’s first congress, yet he was exalted by a group of intellectuals to be CCP secretary-general. Later Chen Duxiu, riding on the prestige of intellectuals, established his personal authority within the party, playing factionalism, and used party-led revolution to serve his own career. Thus Chen Duxiu continuously undermined the CCP’s leadership of the proletarian revolution. He had no knowledge, no revolutionary theory, and no revolutionary experience, but only a name and vanity, and he used these as capital to direct other comrades and the entire proletarian revolutionary force, ultimately leading to a rightist capitulation line and handing over the leadership of the army to the Kuomintang, enabling the Kuomintang to launch a massacre and push the CCP to the brink of extinction.\nLater, the “August 7” Meeting in 1927 ended Chen Duxiu’s leadership in the CCP. Yet at that time the CCP was still immature. Where was its immaturity? It lay in two aspects of subjectivism criticized by Chairman Mao: empiricism and dogmatism. But empiricists always submit to dogmatists, always bow to dogmatists, and accept their command, so dogmatists again seized leadership, i.e., Qu Qiubai came to the fore.\nWhy was the party so immature at that time? Because the CCP was formed by the alliance of workers, peasants, and vast numbers of petty-bourgeois intellectuals. The working class had no deep experience in class struggle and did not grasp Marxist theory deeply enough to use it as a weapon for struggle. The peasant class had strong small producer traits and petty-bourgeois tendencies, with loose and free behaviors, not only unreceptive to Marxist theory but resistant to it. The petty-bourgeois intellectuals were more detached from class struggle and clung to private ownership ideas. Among these three groups, some lacked revolutionary experience and understanding of revolutionary theory, often making “left” or “right” errors; and some petty-bourgeois intellectuals or even bourgeois intellectuals used the name of revolution to get into the Party and turn the CCP into a tool for their own interests. Thus, without genuine revolutionary practice and training, the CCP was formed and had to be taught a lesson. Chen Duxiu’s failure thus taught the CCP a lesson.\nThen the CCP shifted from right opportunism to “left” opportunism, with Qu Qiubai coming to power. Qu was also an intellectual, and because intellectuals held power in the party and dogmatism suppressed empiricism, Qu came to power. Qu was from the same era and same place as Chen Duxiu. It is said that Ding Ling once pursued Qu Qiubai, but Qu did not form a couple with her.\nAfter Qu Qiubai came to power, he continued to use his petty-bourgeois intellectuals to turn the party into a tool for personal ambition, and aggressively promoted factionalism, attacking comrades who maintained the correct line, such as Chairman Mao. After the attack, he advocated immediate nationwide revolution, arguing that the Nationalist reactionaries’ creation of the “April 12” and “July 15” counterrevolutions did not mean a downturn in the revolution. Rather, these revolutions exposed their reactionary faces, presenting the nationwide revolution as the climax. Thus, under the threat of Wang Jingwei and Chiang Kai-shek’s joint suppression, and with Chen Duxiu having long since betrayed the CCP’s leadership in the National Revolutionary Army, he launched a nationwide armed uprising, ordering branches in all cities to rise in armed revolt. The result exposed all CCP strength in the cities; 99% of CCP forces in the white region and in the cities were crushed by the Nationalist reactionaries, resulting in bloody massacres. Under Qu Qiubai’s command, the CCP suffered a second great blow, and the party was on the edge of extinction.\nWhat was Qu Qiubai doing then? After his “left” adventurism failed, Qu Qiubai fled. While in Fujian, he was captured by the enemy. Upon capture, the enemy did not recognize him at first, and imprisoned him in a dark prison. Discontent with the conditions, Qu publicly confessed to the jailer, “I am a high-ranking CCP official, arrange me a luxurious private room.” Thus Qu moved from the dark dungeon to a luxurious private room. From then on, CCP leaders and staff of various ranks, etc., interacted daily with Qu. Qu acted as a traitor, selling large portions of CCP secrets to the enemy. He even wrote a “Excess Words” as a confession, claiming he did not have great ability, did not firmly believe in communism, and somehow became CCP general secretary.\nIn fact, this self-confession was a pledge of surrender to the enemy. He cut himself off from the revolution and claimed to be someone who entered the revolution by mistake, and in “Excess Words” leaked the internal struggles within the party, becoming a complete turncoat. After Qu Qiubai betrayed all the secrets he knew and wrote the confession, the Nationalists still did not spare him. To betray the secrets, Qu Qiubai used lavish tobacco and wine, and initially even disliked rural coarse wine, but later the Nationalist generals found him fine wine and good liquor. With such pampered treatment, Qu’s value was exhausted, and he was shot by the Nationalists.\nAfter Qu Qiubai’s death, he turned to the right again, thus opening the path for Luo Zhanglong’s right opportunism, followed by Li Lisan’s “left” opportunism. In short, the CCP was continually oscillating between left and right opportunism, but those who held real power were always the opportunists, who were very good at deception. Either they used the prestige of intellectuals, or they used the identity of veteran revolutionaries and workers to deceive. In fact, they were all dogmatists. Among the later, the CCP’s greatest dogmatist and opportunist—Wang Ming—defeated other opportunists and held party power for several years, four or five years.\nUnder Wang Ming’s control, the CCP was completely emptied. He crazily promoted his own scheming confidants, expelled opponents, and pushed Mao Zedong’s status down again and again, eroding Mao’s position and power. At the eve of the Long March, Wang Ming used various insidious methods, first adopting the left-leaning, rightward opportunist line that did not cooperate with the Fujian people’s government (referring to the Fujian Incident), did not cooperate with Cai Tingkai’s 19th Route Army, and did not join with Cai Tingkai to resist, and the fifth anti-“encirclement” campaign failed again. In this situation, Wang Ming still prioritized his own personal power and ambition, and even downgraded a frontline organizer of great importance like Mao Zedong, a military talent, and installed him in a position with no real power. At this time, the CCP Central Soviet Region’s fifth counter-encirclement campaign failed, the enemy launched a major invasion, the Red Army and party members were reduced in number, and the party faced extinction. Mao’s own military and party power were taken away, and his wife Yang Kaihui was killed by the Nationalist reactionaries. Mao’s life seemed at an impasse, yet he did not give up. For the party’s interests and the revolution, he continued to insist on line struggle, persuading other comrades. Thus he finally took the road of the Long March.\nIn this 14-year period of opportunist struggle within the CCP, the vast number of party members and masses realized the harms of opportunism, and finally, at the Zunyi Conference in January 1935, established Mao’s leadership within the Party.\nHence, Mao’s leadership within the CCP was the result of a long process, filled with many lessons learned (and experienced). If the CCP had not developed in a semi-colonial and semi-feudal society, if Chinese workers did not possess such advanced nature, and if Chinese peasants did not have such revolutionary basis, then how could the CCP bear 14 years of experiments? How did the CCP develop in those 14 years? It was built on a solid worker-peasant alliance, under a very powerful working class, and a peasant class that expelled the landowners in the countryside, establishing rural revolutionary bases, thus allowing the 14-year loss to be borne and for intellectuals to be misled. In an imperialist country, allowing opportunists to run such a 14-year program would have meant the party’s extinction.\nTherefore the CCP’s success was by no means the result of two individuals’ greatness alone. We cannot deny Mao’s role in China’s revolutionary history, but the CCP’s success was because China was a country with concentrated and acute social contradictions, with highly advanced and revolutionary working class and peasantry, and with a strong revolutionary and combative character. The stability of this worker-peasant alliance, the revolutionary progress of workers and peasants, and the concentration and sharpness of social contradictions, drove revolutionary forces and needs to combine, producing a revolutionary party.\nSimilarly, the Bolsheviks had such advantages. But the Bolsheviks’ advantages included intellectuals of higher quality than those of the CCP, who, after being tempered by Lenin’s leadership in the “Association for the Liberation of the Working Class,” had already undergone theoretical struggle before founding the party, defeated all opportunists, and thus established a purer Bolshevik party. Therefore, within three years after founding the Bolshevik party, they led the nationwide armed uprising (1905 Revolution); by the 15th year after founding, they led the October Revolution, overthrowing the tsarist regime and establishing Soviet Russia.\nThus, the correctness of ideological and political line determines everything. The Russian revolution progressed rapidly because the Bolshevik line led by Lenin was correct, and the CCP’s later success after 1935, including resisting Chiang Kai-shek, uniting the nation against Japan, and winning the war of liberation, was inseparable from Mao’s correct leadership and the guidance of this correct line. Therefore, the correctness of the line in thought and politics determines everything.\nIn many other countries in the past there were revolutionary crises as well. Germany experienced several revolutionary crises. When World War I was ending in 1918, Germany saw the November Revolution, Kiel sailors began the uprising, and the militarist government collapsed. The result was that there was no Communist party in Germany at that time; the Communist party was not established until January 1919, and at that time the party was very immature, lacking leadership and mass base, with little national influence, so the November 1918 revolution quickly failed. Later the Hungarian Communist Party led the 1919 Hungarian Revolution, but the party—the Hungarian Communist Party with 15,000 members and the Hungarian Social Democratic Party with 750,000 members—merged with the latter, dissolving the Communist party; this was another example of failure in the 1919 revolution. This was also because the Hungarian Communist Party was immature, inexperienced, or naive, betrayed by social-democratic traitors.\nAfterwards, Italy also experienced several revolutionary crises. During WWI, northern Italy saw workers taking over factories. In the 1920s’ economic crisis, similar events occurred. In 1923, Germany’s Ruhr occupation by France led to passive resistance and rampant inflation, merging German national and economic crises. At that time, Germany also formed a revolutionary situation; in Saxony, a workers’ government was formed led by the Communist Party and the German Social Democratic Party. But the Communist Party at that time was not mature, leadership was in the hands of opportunists like Brandler, who betrayed the German revolution, despite a favorable revolutionary situation. They even planned a nationwide armed uprising in October 1923, but Brandler’s rightist capitulationism led to the cancellation of the uprising; Hamburg ventured to rise up without notice and without cancellation, and was crushed.\nThus, the correctness of ideological and political line is decisive. Without the right line, no matter how mature the objective conditions or how strong the revolutionary forces, failure is almost certain. There are many examples, including after WWII when the French Communist guerrillas controlled most of liberated zones, or Italy’s Communist forces controlled much of the guerrilla forces; under such conditions, De Gaulle and Togliatti happily replaced, etc., leading to capitulations and handing over military and political power. Many countries experienced similar outcomes; Tito in Yugoslavia, too. Yugoslavia was among the first to resist Nazi Germany in Southeast Europe, liberated early, but later, under the leadership of ambitious opportunists within party control and their factional groups, drifted toward revisionism and finally betrayed the achievements of WWII for personal gain.\nSo the correctness of the ideological and political line is decisive.\nThe historical experience of the Chinese Communist Party and the historical experience of the international Communist movement since Marx prove this to be a timeless truth. A party’s success or failure depends on whether its line is correct. If the line is not correct, even with control over central leadership, regional leadership, and the army, it will still collapse; if the line is correct, there may be no army or no power, but power will exist. The CCP’s leadership of the Chinese people’s revolution was a victory of Mao Zedong’s proletarian revolutionary line. Mao’s correct line did not arise naturally or peacefully; it existed because it contrasted with mistakes and grew through struggle. Mao insisted on combining the universal truth of Marxism-Leninism with China’s specific practice, and established the correct line, principles, and policies for the Party, guiding comrades to overcome left and right opportunism within the Party, and leading the entire people to defeat strong enemies at home and abroad. The CCP is a Marxist-Leninist party that grew and matured through the struggles of two lines within the Party and the fights against domestic and international enemies.\nWe have now reached a stage where revolutionary conditions are increasingly mature. We are still in the era of imperialism and the era of proletarian revolution; what we are doing now is to accumulate strength for revolution. Why did the CCP fail so severely at that time while the Bolsheviks did not fail? It seems hard to understand, but in fact, it is clear: the CCP was very naive, though founded under revolutionary necessity. Marxism was transmitted to China around 1919 and the CCP was founded in 1921. In this context, Marxism was supplied to China by petty-bourgeois intellectuals, who then monopolized the interpretation of Marxism. They had not been tempered in revolution, and thus capitalized on China’s extremely concentrated and sharp social contradictions, and the very strong power of workers and peasants, to easily establish the CCP. Under the objective needs and forces in China, the CCP was formed easily and subsequently easily failed, as the old saying goes, “What is easily gained is easily lost.”\nSo how was the Bolshevik party established? In Russia, before revolution matured, Marxism began to develop gradually there. Lenin explained how the Bolshevik party came about. Marxism arrived in Russia after half a century of exploration, attempts, failures, tests, and sacrifice by Russian revolutionaries, who, before leading workers in armed uprising, allowed intellectuals to engage in revolution, benefiting from a long period of adjustment and sacrifice. From the founding of the “Labor Liberation Society” to the establishment of the Bolshevik Party, twenty years passed. Lenin himself was exposed to Marxism from a young age and gained revolutionary experience through class struggle. He was not a god who descended from the heavens; he did not suddenly appear as a revolutionary in 1903 and organize a revolutionary party. In 1903 Lenin was 33 years old, but he had already begun to engage with revolution at 17, leading student movements, mastering Marxism. He had 16 years of revolutionary experience and 16 years of study in Marxism by then. He did not appear as a “parachuted strongman” to unify the Russian revolution.\nWhen Lenin was 17, he was still in school, a student. When his first leadership of student movements was suppressed by the police, the police chief said to Lenin, “You know what you are facing? A wall.” Lenin replied, “It’s only a rotten wall; give it a shove and it will fall.” This shows Lenin’s firm revolutionary will, since he had already lived in Russia’s intense political struggle before the age of 17 and was familiar with political struggle. His whole family participated in revolution; his brother was a narodnik who participated in assassination attempts on the Tsar and was executed. Lenin said, “This road we must not walk; this road is not the road for us.” He was early inducted into revolution and tempered by revolution.\nWhen Lenin studied at Kazan University, he used his schooling to form the first Marxist group in Samara. He was not yet 20. He formed a Marxist group in Kazan and brought together Marxist groups in the city and student organizations, began attempting to combine with workers, and using his law studies—though he did not graduate—to assist peasants in suing landlords. Local landlords, hearing that Vladimir Ilyich would defend them in court, trembled but agreed to the peasants’ requests. Lenin did not finish Kazan University—does that degree matter?\nLater Lenin moved to Saint Petersburg, where he deepened his engagement with the working class. In 1894 he began to organize all of Petersburg’s Marxist groups into one, to unify with the working class, to write and distribute pamphlets, and to organize workers to go on strike. This was Russia’s first attempt to combine Marxism with the working class. In October 1895 Lenin established Russia’s first Marxist organization, the Petersburg Committee for the Liberation of the Working Class, truly leading the working class. However, only three months after its establishment, in December 1895, Lenin and most of his comrades were betrayed by the tsarist regime and jailed. After more than a year, in March 1897 they were exiled to Siberia. Lenin completed hard labor in 1900, was exiled for nearly three years, and after completing his sentence, decided to continue pushing Russia’s revolution. He went into exile in Europe to establish “Iskra,” set up a vast underground network, and create Russia’s political organs in exile.\nSo how did Lenin mature? He matured under such arduous conditions and through years of revolutionary struggle. In Gorky’s Reminiscences, Lenin wrote that he knew little of Russia, only Simbirsk, Samara, and Petersburg, and a bit of Siberia. He had only been in a few places in Russia: Simbirsk his hometown, Samara where he studied, Petersburg where he organized the workers’ movement, and Siberia as exile—yet in each place he connected with the local working people, learned of their suffering, and maintained class struggle. He continued to practice Marxism in each place. Even in prison he did not abandon class struggle; there is a famous story of Lenin writing with bread and milk as ink and paper, consuming the bread when a jailer discovered it.\nLenin matured this way. In this maturation, he also identified many opportunists. Before founding the party, he had already undergone much struggle. Lenin previously made mistakes, such as not recognizing the essence of people like Plekhanov who worshipped knowledge as capital and compromised with opportunism to maintain collaboration with him. Lenin argued that the party must criticize and oppose Plekhanov’s misuses of Marxism; he insisted on a principled critique even when cooperating. This struggle is recorded in Lenin’s articles on how the Iskra editorial board almost collapsed due to Plekhanov’s manipulation.\nThus Lenin engaged in struggles with opportunists even before the party’s founding. He was opposing legal Marxists and later defending against populists in his early writings, such as “What Is to Be Done?” which condemned populism and economism. This work cleared the minds of revolutionary intellectuals in Russia of conspiratorial and economistic thought, establishing Marxism-Leninism as the mainstream among Russian intellectuals and forming the basis for the Bolshevik Party.\nWhy am I telling so much? Because it shows two scenarios. One: in China, when revolutionary momentum was high but subjective revolutionary conditions were lacking and the party was not equipped with revolutionary theory and experience, it incurred a 14-year loss and suffered great sacrifice, but eventually found the right path. The other: intellectuals led workers and peasants to sacrifice and, after decades of struggle, defeated opportunism, forged a party with revolutionary theory and revolutionary methods, and accelerated the Russian revolution’s victory. So there are two paths. A party with immature revolutionary theory and construction must bear the costs in revolution.\nSo at which stage are we now? We are like the Peterburg Workers’ Liberation Society, or the Labor Liberation Society, in the stage of revolution preparation. If we advance one more step in class struggle, gain more revolutionary experience and capabilities, and understand more revolutionary theory, we can avoid sacrificing thousands or tens of thousands in future revolutionary practice. This is the difference between the Russian and Chinese lines. If in the preparation stage a party lacks revolutionary experience and theory, it will, like the Chinese Communist Party, sacrifice thousands, tens of thousands, or hundreds of thousands of communists and workers and peasants during its 14-year formation.\nThus, the correctness of the line in thoughts and policies determines everything. The historical role of communists is thus to, according to the role communists play in social and historical progress, reduce losses, ease suffering, and accelerate the historical transformation. This is the role of the Communist Party and its members. In our revolutionary organization today, class struggle issues that are not yet resolved will certainly develop into bigger problems in future revolutionary practice, with greater costs. As we have repeatedly said, we must prevent revisionism, decisively tackle bureaucratism, eliminate bourgeois ideas from our organization, solve individualism and liberalism, and deal with formalism; solving these issues now is a precondition for our future stronger and more urgent revolutionary actions.\nInside the CCP, the two-line struggle reflects the social class contradictions and the old-new things in the party. If the party lacks contradictions and struggles to resolve them, its life ceases. We should all deeply feel this truth. If our association had not conducted class struggle and ideological struggle for all these years since its founding, it would have collapsed long ago. We indeed conduct struggles in all aspects, right? Our association is completely different from other groups that call themselves Marxist organizations. All members of our association are real workers, proud of their proletarianization, pragmatic and practical in standard, a revolutionary organization rooted in action rather than empty talk. Therefore we have long carried out class struggle, and it is the earliest and most frequent. At the same time, in building and strengthening party organization, we conduct continuous ideological and theoretical struggles, and use the outcomes of class and ideological struggles to serve our political struggles, i.e., in our concrete writing and propaganda activities, spreading and promoting Marxism. This is the full scope of what class struggle can accomplish in our current stage. Therefore our association truly upholds the revolutionary cause of class struggle. Only by advancing class struggle now can we avoid paying higher costs later.\nFor those “leftist circle” organizations, I won’t name them; naming them would be too low-level, as they do not deserve to provoke us. Those leftist groups that secretly smear or publicly denigrate the association, have they achieved our level in economic struggle, theoretical struggle, or political struggle? None. They cannot even figure out economic struggle; they don’t even have many who have worked; they only spread rumors. Their slanders and all online activities are only to comfort their own comfortable life and to float in the bourgeois spiritual opium of the sea, so they keep blasting us to soothe their own consciences; this is their sole purpose.\nSo today’s class struggle is to prepare for future revolutionary actions. We need not engage in online battles with these leftist and opportunist organizations; there is no need to show off. They can spread rumors to their heart’s content, but will not step forward in real actions. Yet our constant progress in practical actions, ongoing revolutionary practice, and the courage to confront, admit, expose, and criticize ourselves will push each comrade forward, and will also advance our revolutionary organization, laying a foundation for future revolution.\nThus, in the process of exposing and resolving contradictions, our association will continue to advance and progress. Those leftist circles lack such glorious traditions; they do not understand class struggle or ideological struggle. Even the robber nests formed by traitors who fled from our association will not engage in true ideological struggle, using mere slogans to boast and to dismantle opponents, then hanging a “drag on the tiger’s tail” flag, writing articles to cover their own comforts and pleasures.\nThe CCP has undergone more than fifty years of history and ten major line struggles. In the period of New Democratic Revolution, Chairman Mao applied Marxism-Leninism on the theory of violent revolution, insisted on seizing power by force, and formulated the party’s new-democratic revolutionary line led by the proletariat, guiding the party and the broad revolutionary masses in class struggle against imperialism, feudalism, and bureaucratic capitalism at home and abroad. This is reflected in the party’s internal and external line. There were six major line struggles within the Party. Under Chairman Mao’s Marxist-Leninist line, the Party defeated Chen Duxiu, Qu Qiubai, Li Lisan, Luo Zhanglong, Wang Ming, Zhang Guotao, and other leaders of left and right opportunism; it upheld the proletarian leadership of the revolution, built and developed revolutionary armed force, organized and consolidated the revolutionary united front, carried out rural-based revolution to encircle the city, achieved city-based power and armed seizure of national power; after 28 years of struggle, established the people’s democratic dictatorship and the proletarian dictatorship to guarantee.\nDuring the socialist revolution and socialist construction, Chairman Mao inherited, defended, and developed Marxism-Leninism’s theory of continuing revolution under the dictatorship of the proletariat, formulating the basic line for the entire socialist historical stage. He led the whole Party, the whole army, and the people of all ethnic groups to wage a large-scale struggle against the bourgeoisie and all exploiters, fought resolutely against revisionism during the international scenes, and in the Party, around persisting with the basic line of the Party, and through the suppression of the Gong’s, Rao’s, and Peng Dehuai anti-Party cliques, Mao personally initiated and led the proletarian cultural revolution, overthrowing Liu Shaoqi and Lin Biao’s two bourgeois command centers, defeating enemies, mobilizing the masses, educating cadres, boosting the development of productive forces, guiding the country along Mao Zedong’s revolution line, and achieving the great victory of safeguarding the dictatorship of the proletariat and preventing a capitalist restoration. This was a heavy blow to all reactionary forces at home and abroad. A few domestic enemies attacked the proletarian Cultural Revolution from the opposite side, telling us that this revolution was entirely necessary and timely.\nLenin stated: “Revisionism is an international phenomenon.” It is an international bourgeois trend. In our Party, some revisionist leaders pop up to perform, and they have international backgrounds. They want to perform revisionism in China, inevitably colluding with imperialists, social-imperialists, and world imperialists to invade and subvert us. The revisionists’ agents in our Party are the tools to be brought in or pushed out. As long as we remain in the era of imperialism and proletarian revolution, revisionism remains the main threat. Upholding Marxism and opposing revisionism are our long-term battle tasks and a necessity to fulfill the great historical mission of the proletariat.\nMarxism-Leninism holds that the liberation of the proletariat and revolutionary people has a bright future, though the path is winding. Moving from chaos to governance is the objective law of class struggle and the general trend of history. Our Party’s history shows that the great, glorious, and correct Chinese Communist Party, guided by the correct line represented by Mao Zedong, fought long and hard against class enemies inside and outside the Party, and did not split or be crushed. On the contrary, Mao’s Marxist-Leninist line developed further, and our Party grew stronger. History convinces us that our Party has hope.\nOur study of the history of China’s two-line struggle must follow Chairman Mao’s teachings: study hard, learn Marxism to understand it; we must adopt the method of unifying theory and practice; and we must uphold the line struggle as the main thread. These are the three requirements for rectifying all problems we currently face: one: study hard, master Marxism; two: unify theory and practice so that Marxism does not become empty talk or dogma but guides our actions; three: keep line struggle as the main thread, centering all activities on advancing class struggle. By studying Chairman Mao’s works and combining with Marx, Engels, and Lenin’s works, we must use the basic theories of Marxism to arm ourselves, understand the history of the struggle between Marxism and the new and old revisionism and various opportunisms, understand how Chairman Mao integrated Marxism-Leninism’s universal truth with revolutionary practice, inherit, defend, and develop Marxism-Leninism. We must implement the principle of unifying theory and practice, correctly understand the relationship between domestic class struggle and international class struggle, and between social class struggle and internal party struggle, and we must persist with line struggle as the main thread.\nDeeply grasp Chairman Mao’s principle: “To promote Marxism, not revisionism; to unite, not split; to be open and upright, not engage in scheming.” Continue to advance the anti-Lin, anti-Right,批,批,批, and continue to criticize revisionist and孔思想的反动思想,批判资产阶级世界观. Learn from two-line struggles within the Party, especially the experiences of the tenth line struggle, further understanding the characteristics and laws of class struggle and the two-line struggle during socialist revolution, improve awareness of class struggle, two-line struggle, and continuing revolution, and strengthen the ability to distinguish true Marxism from false. Distinguish what is Chairman Mao’s Marxism-Leninism line, from opportunist revisionist lines. According to Chairman Mao’s theory and practice of two-line struggle, develop revolutionary spirit that dares to oppose the current trend, actively and correctly conduct inner-Party struggle, uphold the Party’s basic line and policies throughout the entire socialist history, uphold continuing revolution under the dictatorship of the proletariat, unite for greater victory.\n
”,“target_locale”:“en” }Summary of RedGPT on 【Preface】:
1. The main purpose of this speech: Study Party history to serve the current ideological struggle
- You emphasized that the preface of the “History of the Two-Line Struggle of the Chinese Communist Party” is not for “memorizing history,” but to deeper understand Marxism, class struggle, and line struggle.
- You said you have already posted the first part of the conference report (an overview and theoretical issues not involving secrets) on the forum, and will try to publicly share theoretical summaries not involving security for comrades’ reference in the future.
- You clearly pointed out: The significance of studying Party history lies in relearning the experiences of the two-line struggles and class struggles in history, to serve our current class struggle and organizational building.
2. The first core conclusion: Party, army, united front — “Three Magic Weapons” are the tools to seize and consolidate power
- You returned to Chairman Mao’s basic judgment:
- A Communist Party built on Marxist-Leninist revolutionary theory and revolutionary style
- An army led by such a party
- A united front led by such a party
These three are crucial weapons for seizing and consolidating power.
- You pointed out that the “Three Magic Weapons” correspond to three central issues:
- Party building
- Armed struggle
- United front
- You directly applied this to today: To build organizations and strive to establish a national party, we must follow this route and utilize the three magic weapons.
- Especially the first: Must have a party with revolutionary theory and revolutionary style. This underscores the importance of ideological struggle and theoretical struggle: Without theoretical armament and struggle training, there can be no true proletarian vanguard.
3. The second core conclusion: Where do revolutionary theory and revolutionary style come from? From ideological struggle
- You emphasized “ideological struggle” very firmly: It is theory struggle, forged in the tumult of class struggle.
- You pointed out: Only a party formed in struggle, only a proletarian force formed in struggle and truly united with the people, can be considered a genuine Communist Party.
- You criticized a dangerous illusion:
- The petty bourgeoisie without class struggle experience cannot bear the responsibility of building the Communist Party;
- Relying solely on “self-perceived revolutionary” or “reading a few books” to self-declare as Communist is politically untenable.
4. The third core conclusion: Why was the early CCP repeatedly controlled by opportunists? Rooted in “immaturity” and “subjectivism”
You used early Party line struggles to illustrate: The Party’s immaturity in its early stages allowed opportunists to infiltrate, rise, and cause great damage.
1) Where does “immaturity” manifest?
You focused on Mao’s critique of subjectivism:
- Empiricism: Some practical experience but lacking theoretical weapons, unable to elevate to the level of line struggle;
- Dogmatism: Reciting textbook phrases, posing as “orthodox,” detached from reality, suppressing correct lines.
You emphasized:
Empiricism ultimately tends to succumb to dogmatism.
Without theoretical weapons, it’s impossible to resist those intimidating with books, making it easy to be led by the nose.
2) Difficulties caused by complex internal composition
You explained that the Party at that time was composed of workers, peasants, and a large number of petty bourgeois intellectuals:
- Workers lacked sufficient struggle experience and deep theoretical understanding, prone to losses in struggle;
- Peasants were dispersed small producers, prone to laxity and resistant to systematic theory;
- Petty bourgeois intellectuals were more detached from labor and masses, with strong private ownership ideas, personal reputation concerns, prone to “left” or “right” errors; some even used revolution as a tool for personal future.
This inevitably meant the Party had to pay tuition and learn lessons in its early days.
5. According to your narrative: Major line lessons during the New Democratic Revolution period
You clearly outlined each step of “wrong line — consequences — lessons learned” as you explained.
1) Chen Duxiu: Rightist capitulation line pushed the revolution to the brink of life and death
- You pointed out that Chen Duxiu relied on “reputation” and intellectual circles to rise to power from the beginning, not on revolutionary practice or struggle.
- He used personal authority to create factions, turning the Party’s accumulated prestige into personal capital.
- He repeatedly undermined the Party’s leadership of the proletarian revolution, ultimately adopting a rightist capitulation: handing over Party leadership and control of the army to the Kuomintang, leading to the KMT’s slaughter of Communists and workers, pushing the Party to the brink of extinction.
- You emphasized: This is not “personal mistake,” but a line problem: capitulating to the bourgeoisie, abandoning independent proletarian leadership.
2) After the August 7th Meeting: Although defeating rightist tendencies, the Party remained immature
- You pointed out that the end of Chen Duxiu’s leadership at the August 7th Meeting was a necessary turning point.
- But the Party was still immature, with subjectivism still present, especially dogmatism still overpowering empiricism, so the wrong line was not eradicated.
3) Qu Qiubai: “Left” in appearance, right in essence reckless adventurism, causing a second major blow
- You explained that Qu Qiubai’s rise was also the result of petty bourgeois intellectual dominance within the Party.
- He continued factionalism, attacking comrades who upheld the correct line (you cited Mao’s example).
- Under severe enemy slaughter and White Terror, he promoted a “revolutionary climax” nationwide, ordering urban branches to launch open armed uprisings.
- The result: The Party’s urban strength was exposed, brutally suppressed by reactionaries, most of the White Area and urban forces were wiped out, and the Party was again pushed to the brink of extinction.
- You emphasized: Adventurism “left” in name is essentially “right” — it disregards preserving revolutionary strength, ignores mass conditions, treats revolution as a gamble, and in effect helps the enemy eliminate revolution.
(You also mentioned Qu Qiubai’s defection in prison and his “Extra Words” as a confession of treachery. These details illustrate that once such people go astray, they often harm the Party and masses, and may betray completely at personal moments.)
4) Subsequent oscillations: alternating right and “left” tendencies, opportunists repeatedly coming to power
You pointed out that within the Party, right and “left” opportunist lines kept recurring, shaking the Party repeatedly; these opportunists are skilled at deception, sometimes relying on “intellectual reputation,” other times on “old revolutionaries and workers,” but fundamentally still dogmatists and opportunists.
5) Wang Ming: The greatest dogmatist in control, causing the crisis before the Long March
- You emphasized Wang Ming’s control of the Central Committee for many years, promoting cronies, excluding dissenters, repeatedly weakening Mao’s position.
- He pursued a “left” in appearance but right in essence line, making major mistakes on key political and military issues, leading to the failure of the fifth anti-“encirclement” campaign and the near destruction of the Central Soviet Area.
- Even as the Red Army shrank and crisis loomed, he prioritized personal power, disregarding revolutionary interests, continuing to attack correct line representatives.
- You highlighted Mao’s role: Mao, even in extreme hardship and personal peril, persisted in line struggle for revolutionary interests, ultimately leading the Party onto the Long March.
- The Zunyi Conference’s affirmation of Mao’s leadership marked a crucial turning point in recognizing the correct line and maturing the Party.
6) The political conclusion from the “14-year lessons”
You stressed that Mao’s consolidation of leadership in the Party was gained through many lessons and great sacrifices. Further, you pointed out:
- China could endure 14 years of repeated failures because of sharp social contradictions, strong revolutionary tendencies among workers and peasants, and rural bases supporting the Party’s survival and struggle;
- In imperialist countries, opportunists in power for 14 years would have already eliminated the Party;
- Therefore, the Party’s success was not due to “a few geniuses,” but the result of the revolutionary nature of the masses and workers, combined with correct lines in struggle.
6. Key comparison you made: Why did the Bolsheviks suffer fewer losses than the CCP?
You used Russian experience not to praise foreign systems, but to illustrate the decisive importance of the “revolution preparation stage.”
1) The difference between two lines
- China: Marxism was introduced relatively late, the Party was quickly established, but lacked theoretical struggle and screening, paying heavy sacrifices in practice.
- Russia: Experienced long exploration and theoretical struggle before the Party’s founding; Lenin forged the team and eliminated opportunism through struggle, leading to faster, more stable revolution.
2) How Lenin was forged (your main line)
You emphasized Lenin was not an “air-dropped hero,” but was forged through long-term struggle:
- Participated early in revolution, resisted Tsar repression with firm will in youth;
- Organized Marxist groups, united scattered forces;
- Deeply engaged with the working class, distributed leaflets, led strikes, integrating Marxism with the workers’ movement;
- Organized the “Saint Petersburg Workers’ Liberation Struggle Society” (also noting its connection to our organizational name);
- Persisted in revolutionary work during arrests, prisons, exile; later established “Mars” newspaper and built underground networks across Russia;
- Most critically, before founding the Party, fought against opportunist and liberal distortions of Marxism, clarifying true Marxism, forging a new type of Party.
You used these examples to demonstrate:
Revolutionary leaders and revolutionary parties are forged in long-term class and line struggles, not by degrees, reputation, or rhetoric.
7. From international experience to general law: Wrong line, even with good circumstances, leads to failure; correct line, even without troops, can still win
You used examples from Germany, Hungary, Italy, and post-WWII France and Italy to emphasize the same principle:
- Objective conditions for revolution may be ripe, but without the correct line, opportunists will betray;
- Opportunists can cancel uprisings, surrender arms, hand over power, giving away years of mass struggle;
- Conversely, with the correct line, revolutionary forces grow and strengthen in struggle: even without troops, there will be troops; even without power, there will be power.
8. Applying Party history experience directly to today: Why we must resolutely fight ideological struggle, anti-revisionism, and fight against bureaucratism
You pointed out several clear current directives:
- We are now in the preparation stage of revolution, and must, like early Russia, solidify theoretical and line struggle, or future revolutionary actions will cost many sacrifices.
- The issues we need to address today—anti-revisionism, fighting bureaucratism, combating individualism and liberalism, opposing formalism—are to prevent larger disasters later.
- You emphasized that the internal struggle of two-line conflict reflects class contradictions within the Party:
- Without contradictions and struggle, the Party’s life ceases;
- Our organizational growth depends on daring to expose problems, struggle, and self-criticism, not on “harmony.”
9. Your characterization of the “Left Circle”: They attack us to justify their petty bourgeois lifestyle and personal ambitions
You explicitly exposed this faction at the end:
- They are unqualified to criticize proletarian organizational building because they lack real achievements in economic, theoretical, and political struggles, and most lack practical labor experience.
- They spread rumors and attack Marxists, not because of “misunderstanding,” but because they stand for comfort and personal interests: using the “Marxist banner” to justify personal individualism, low-level pleasures, and even personal ambitions.
- We need not get involved in online fights: no matter how they stir, they won’t advance real struggle; we should focus on actual training, organization, and propaganda.
10. Your learning requirements: Three “musts” and three basic principles
You clarified the discipline of “how to learn and what to do with learning” at the end:
Three “musts”
- Must carefully read and understand Marxist theory, improve theoretical level;
- Must adhere to the unity of theory and practice, not treat Marxism as dogma or empty talk;
- Must focus on line struggle, testing all activities within class struggle and organizational building.
Three basic principles
You emphasized deeply understanding Mao’s three principles:
- Engage in Marxism, oppose revisionism;
- Unity, oppose division;
- Openness and honesty, oppose conspiracy and intrigue.
Applying these today means improving the ability to distinguish true and false Marxism during rectification, anti-revisionism, and the fight against bourgeois worldviews, daring to oppose currents, and continuing revolution under proletarian dictatorship.
11. One-sentence summary (for those who did not participate)
You repeatedly proved through Party and international history:
Victory in revolution does not rely on luck, reputation, or rhetoric, but on the proletarian line forming and defeating opportunism in struggle; our current focus on ideological and line struggle is to train the team to be mature before the revolution, reducing countless sacrifices in the future.
These three places are misspelled.
【Chapter One · Section One · Part One】
Chapter One: The founding of the Communist Party of China and the struggle between Chairman Mao’s revolutionary line and Chen Duxiu’s Right-deviationist opportunist line.
Since the Communist Party of China was founded on July 1, 1921, there has continuously existed within the Party a struggle between the Marxist-Leninist line represented by Chairman Mao and the Right- and Left-deviationist opportunist lines. During the period when the Party was being founded, the focus of the struggle was whether a Party should be founded and what kind of Party should be established. During the First Revolutionary Civil War, the struggle between the two lines was the struggle between Chairman Mao’s proletarian revolutionary line and Chen Duxiu’s Right-deviationist capitulationist line. The focus of the struggle was whether to uphold the leadership of the proletariat in the revolution. During the early and middle periods of this stage, the Party’s line was correct, and Chairman Mao’s works, such as Analysis of the Classes in Chinese Society and Report on an Investigation of the Peasant Movement in Hunan, represented the Party’s correct line. During the later period, because Chen Duxiu’s Right-deviationist opportunist line had gained a dominant position within the Party, it was completely unprepared psychologically for the sudden counterrevolutionary attack. When Chiang Kai-shek and Wang Jingwei successively betrayed the revolution and massacred the workers and peasants, the broad masses were unarmed, causing the magnificent Great Revolution to end in failure.
Section One: Chairman Mao’s struggle to found the Communist Party of China and the founding of the Communist Party of China.
To carry out a revolution, there must be a revolutionary party.
In the historical era of imperialism and proletarian revolution, the proletariat must have its own Marxist-Leninist political party in order to lead the revolutionary masses in defeating imperialism and its lackeys, overthrowing the reactionary rule of the exploiting classes, establishing the dictatorship of the proletariat, and advancing toward socialism and communism. Marx and Engels pointed out long ago: “In its struggle against the collective power of the propertied classes, the working class can act as a class only by constituting itself as a political party distinct from, and opposed to, all old parties formed by the propertied classes. This organization of the proletariat into a political party is necessary in order to ensure the victory of the social revolution and the attainment of its ultimate aim—the abolition of classes.”
When explaining the importance of founding a party, Lenin also pointed out: “Give us an organization of revolutionaries, and we will overturn Russia.” Chairman Mao likewise pointed out during his leadership of the great struggle of the Chinese people’s democratic revolution: “To carry out a revolution, there must be a revolutionary party. Without a revolutionary party, without a revolutionary party established according to Marxist-Leninist revolutionary theory and revolutionary style, it would be impossible to lead the working class and the broad masses of the people in defeating imperialism and its lackeys.” Looking back at the history of the Chinese revolution and the history of the struggle between the two lines within the Party further proves that this is a universal truth of Marxism-Leninism.
Explanation: Yesterday, when we were discussing the preface, we already mentioned that the conditions for revolution are both objective and subjective. Objective conditions are produced by the laws of social history. Subjective conditions, of course, cannot be separated from the laws of social history either, but the laws of social history operate through people’s practical activities. In many cases, even when the objective conditions for revolution exist, revolutions fall into failure because the subjective conditions are insufficient, because there is no correct party to lead them, or because a correct line has not been adopted. There have been countless revolutions of this kind.
To understand the importance and necessity of establishing a proletarian revolutionary party in China, one must first understand the nature of Chinese society, because this is the basic basis for understanding every revolutionary question.
Explanation: Therefore, to clarify the nature of the revolution and to clarify its aims, targets, direction, prospects, and all these matters, one must first clarify the nature of society. If one cannot clarify the nature of a society and cannot correctly determine what its principal contradiction is, or which two classes or groups composed of which classes are engaged in the struggle, then it is impossible to make a correct judgment regarding the nature, aims, targets, prospects, or forms of the revolution.
In his essay The Chinese Revolution and the Chinese Communist Party, Chairman Mao pointed out: Chinese feudal society lasted for approximately 3,000 years. After the Opium War of 1840, the imperialist powers invaded China. On the one hand, this hastened the disintegration of Chinese feudal society and promoted the emergence of capitalist factors in China, turning a feudal society into a semi-feudal society; but on the other hand, they also brutally ruled China, turning an independent China into a semi-colonial and colonial China. The characteristics of semi-feudal, semi-colonial Chinese society were these: although the natural economic foundation of the feudal era had been damaged, the foundation of the feudal system of exploitation still existed; although national capitalism had developed to some extent, it had not become the principal component of China’s social economy, its strength was very weak, and most of it had varying degrees of connection with foreign imperialism and domestic feudalism. The autocratic regimes of the emperors and nobles had been overthrown, but they were replaced first by the rule of the warlords and bureaucrats of the landlord class, and then by the dictatorship of the alliance between the landlord class and the big bourgeoisie. Imperialism not only controlled China’s financial and economic lifelines, but also controlled China’s political and military power. Because China was under the rule or semi-rule of numerous imperialist countries, and because China remained divided for a long time, China’s economic, political, and cultural development was characterized by extreme unevenness. Because of the dual oppression of imperialism and feudalism, the poverty and lack of freedom suffered by the broad masses of the Chinese people, especially the poor peasants, were rarely seen anywhere else in the world.
Explanation: “The foundation still existed” refers to the feudal economic foundation; it means that the feudal economic foundation still existed and that feudal land ownership still existed. The entire set of feudal relations of production based on this feudal land ownership still existed. Ownership is the first aspect of the relations of production. Since feudal land ownership had not fundamentally been shaken, the entire feudal relations of production remained the foundation of the feudal economy. On the basis of feudal land ownership, landlords continued to exploit peasants, and rich peasants and landlords exploited peasants, while the peasants continued to undergo polarization.
It was precisely on the basis of correctly analyzing the nature of Chinese society that Chairman Mao put forward the strategic guideline of armed independent regimes of workers and peasants and proposed the revolutionary form of encircling the cities from the countryside and seizing political power through armed force. It was precisely because China was a semi-feudal, semi-colonial country, because political and economic development was extremely uneven from place to place, because the feudal economic foundation still existed extensively, and because foreign imperialism ruled China, that these conditions inevitably caused China to split into a civil war among different warlords controlling different spheres of influence. This provided the precondition for armed independent regimes of workers and peasants. Feudal economic relations inevitably create political fragmentation, because a feudal economy is self-sufficient and therefore opposes the capitalist market, producing regional division. Imperialism, in turn, established different spheres of influence in different parts of China and supported its own agents within each sphere. Thus, under the support of international imperialism and on the foundation of China’s feudal economy, one warlord regime after another emerged. The continual wars among the different warlords, together with the extreme unevenness of political and economic development in different parts of China, meant that under these conditions the armed forces of the worker-peasant alliance, the working class, and the peasant class could take advantage of the mutual weakening caused by warlord warfare in areas where counterrevolutionary forces were relatively weak and establish armed independent political power.
Therefore, “the contradictions between imperialism and the Chinese nation, and between feudalism and the broad masses of the people—these are the principal contradictions in modern Chinese society.” “The acute intensification of these contradictions cannot but give rise to an increasingly developing revolutionary movement. The great modern and contemporary Chinese revolution arose and developed on the basis of these fundamental contradictions.”
Explanation: Therefore, China’s principal contradictions were the contradiction between imperialism and the Chinese nation and the contradiction between feudalism and the broad masses of the people. In essence, these two contradictions were one contradiction, because China’s big landlords and big comprador bourgeoisie were made up of the same people: they were both landlords and compradores, and they sought both to preserve feudalism and to preserve imperialist rule. These landlord compradores were simultaneously imperialism’s lackeys. China’s biggest warlord, Chiang Kai-shek, was a lackey of Anglo-American imperialism. At the same time, he represented the interests of the financial cliques of Jiangsu and Zhejiang and the interests of the big landlord classes in the various localities. Therefore, to overthrow imperialist forces in China necessarily meant overthrowing China’s feudal landlord class and the rule of the comprador bourgeoisie. Thus, eliminating feudalism was consistent with eliminating imperialism and bureaucratic capitalism—this was the meaning of the “Three Great Mountains.”
From the Opium War of 1840 to the May Fourth Movement of 1919, the Chinese people waged more than 70 years of indomitable and heroic struggle. This included the peasant revolution of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom led by Hong Xiuquan and the bourgeois Xinhai Revolution led by Sun Yat-sen. Although both dealt heavy blows to the rule of imperialism and feudalism, these struggles failed because they lacked the leadership of the proletariat and its party.
Explanation: We have already seen the concrete process and the profound reasons for the failure in The Biography of Hong Rengan.
Why did the peasant revolution, despite being so progressive, ultimately fail? It was because it lacked the leadership of the Communist Party, lacked a scientific worldview, and lacked a form of revolution carried out under the leadership of the Communist Party and upheld as a thorough revolution.
Chinese peasants were the main force opposing imperialism and feudalism, but because they were restricted by backward modes of production and lacked the correct leadership of a proletarian political party, they could not put forward a thoroughgoing democratic revolutionary program. Therefore, peasant revolutions always fell into failure and could not achieve the final victory of the revolution. Although the Chinese national bourgeoisie could participate in the revolution during certain periods and to a certain degree, because of its economic and political weakness and its countless ties with imperialism and feudalism, its class position determined that it lacked the courage to oppose imperialism and feudalism thoroughly and could not lead the revolution to victory. Thus, the historical burden of leading the Chinese democratic revolution to complete victory fell upon the Chinese proletariat and its party.
Explanation: Here the reasons for the failure of the peasant revolution and the national bourgeois revolution are summarized. The peasant revolution failed because it was restricted by backward modes of production, lacked a scientific worldview and the leadership of a correct party, and could not persist in continuing the revolution or in the struggle. The national bourgeoisie, because it was an exploiting class, was determined by its class position to be incapable of opposing imperialism and feudalism thoroughly. The national bourgeoisie also included many people from the feudal landlord and comprador classes. It had deep ties with international imperialism and deep ties with the feudal landlord class. It could not carry the democratic revolution through to the end and would inevitably fear the increasingly growing strength of the workers and peasants during the democratic revolution. Given this, it could not mobilize the broadest masses of workers and peasants to participate in the struggle and could not achieve victory in the democratic revolution.
Therefore, after 1848, after the Revolution of 1848, the bourgeoisie was no longer capable of leading a democratic revolution to victory. At that point, the task of leading the democratic revolution should have passed to the proletariat, which had already appeared in world history and had already stepped onto the political stage of world history. Thus, after the Revolution of 1848, Marx and Engels, in many writings summarizing the experience of the Revolution of 1848—for example, The Class Struggles in France, 1848–1850, The Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany, and The German Peasant War—put forward the idea of establishing a worker-peasant alliance and having the proletariat lead the democratic revolution. Later, during the revolution personally led by Lenin and the Bolsheviks, Lenin clearly pointed out the path of a worker-peasant alliance and proletarian leadership of the democratic revolution. Later, Chairman Mao called the path of proletarian leadership, mobilizing the broad peasantry to participate, carrying out a democratic revolution, overthrowing feudal rule, and eliminating feudal remnants the path of the New Democratic Revolution.
The difference between the New Democratic Revolution and the Old Democratic Revolution lies in the different leading classes, and therefore in their different degrees of thoroughness. The Old Democratic Revolution was a democratic revolution led by the bourgeoisie; the New Democratic Revolution was a democratic revolution led by the proletariat. Thus, everyone may have studied for more than ten years under Chinese revisionism without necessarily knowing the difference between the New Democratic Revolution and the Old Democratic Revolution. Ultimately, only Marxism can provide a correct explanation of it.
Ultimately, the Old Democratic Revolution was limited by the fact that it arose under the leadership of the bourgeoisie, the exploiting class, and therefore could not be thorough. The most successful Old Democratic Revolution in the past was no more than the French Revolution of 1789, whose highest point was merely the seizure of power by the petty-bourgeois democratic faction, the Jacobins, who represented the far-left wing of the bourgeoisie. The regime collapsed after only a year. Finally, the Thermidorians launched a coup and removed the Jacobins completely. This was followed by the Directory and then by Napoleon’s military dictatorship. The New Democratic Revolution, by contrast, was a revolution led by the proletariat; it was a revolution that thoroughly completed the tasks of the democratic revolution. The Russian Revolution led by Lenin had both the character of a New Democratic Revolution and the character of a socialist revolution. The February Revolution led by Lenin first involved the proletariat joining with the bourgeoisie to overthrow the tsarist government and sweep away Russia’s feudal remnants. Then, during the eight-month transitional period, it struggled against the bourgeois provisional government that had come to power, exposed the anti-people and counterrevolutionary nature of the bourgeois provisional government, challenged the Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries who had betrayed the people’s revolution, and ultimately united the broad masses under Bolshevik leadership, achieving the great victory of the October Socialist Revolution.
Chairman Mao likewise, from the beginning of the Agrarian Revolutionary War and the beginning of the First Great Revolution, upheld the theory of the New Democratic Revolution and the line of proletarian leadership of the democratic revolution. He ultimately led the Communist Party of China through every difficulty to victory. In 1949, the War of Liberation achieved complete victory, the Kuomintang was driven from the mainland, China was unified, a people’s democratic state was established in China, and the feudal system was completely abolished. During the Agrarian Revolutionary War, partial land reform had already begun; during the War of Liberation, the scale of land reform continued to expand; and in the second year after victory in the War of Liberation, nationwide land reform began, completely burying feudal land ownership and abolishing all feudal relations on Chinese soil.
So what is a democratic revolution? What is meant by a democratic revolution? Let us return to the concept of democratic revolution. We now understand the New Democratic Revolution and the Old Democratic Revolution, but what exactly is a democratic revolution? A democratic revolution is actually very simple: it is a revolution that abolishes the feudal system and feudal relations. The nature of a democratic revolution is anti-feudal; the aim of a democratic revolution is to completely abolish feudal relations of production. This is why the bourgeoisie can lead a democratic revolution and the proletariat can also lead a democratic revolution. In terms of their aim, the bourgeoisie seeks to abolish feudal relations of production, and the proletariat also seeks to abolish feudal relations of production. Abolishing feudal relations of production is the precondition for the proletariat to begin the socialist revolution. If feudal relations of production are not abolished, then there can be no question of abolishing capitalist relations of production and establishing socialist relations of production.
The bourgeoisie also seeks to abolish feudal relations of production, but the problem is that the bourgeoisie is, after all, an exploiting class. Its conflict and struggle with the feudal landlord class are temporary and relative; its opposition to and conflict with the broad revolutionary people are absolute and eternal. Therefore, when the democratic revolution is in the hands of the bourgeoisie, it can never reach the level of thorough completion, whereas only in the hands of the proletariat can it develop into the most thorough democratic revolution.
“Huaji” and “luanma” understand two different meanings here. Huaji thinks that a democratic revolution is a bourgeois revolution; luanma says that a democratic revolution is a bourgeois revolution. In fact, these are two concepts. They are both one concept and two concepts. “Both one concept” means that bourgeois revolutions are all democratic revolutions, but democratic revolutions are not necessarily bourgeois revolutions. Generally speaking, bourgeois revolutions are bourgeois-democratic revolutions. Secondly, a democratic revolution need not be a bourgeois revolution. A democratic revolution can be led not only by the bourgeoisie and not only by the proletariat, but also by the peasant class. The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom Revolution was a democratic revolution led by the peasant class, whose aim was to abolish feudal ownership.
Therefore, we say that the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom Revolution reached the height of utopian communism. Why? It did not struggle within the institutions of the old system or within the confines of the old mode of production, as ordinary peasant revolutions did. The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom put forward the goal of abolishing private ownership and abolishing landlord land ownership. The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom spoke of achieving a society in which “food is shared by all, money is used by all, land is tilled by all, clothing is worn by all, and everywhere there is adequate food and warmth and everywhere there is equality.”
And why do we say that only the proletariat can realize the democratic revolution thoroughly? Because the proletariat is a class without any private property; it is the most selfless class, the class with the greatest capacity for unity, and the class best able to persist in thorough revolution. The proletariat can ultimately liberate itself only by eliminating all oppression and exploitation. For such a class, the end point of its revolution is the abolition of the entire class society and the entire system of oppression and exploitation, reaching communism. Only then can its mission be completed, and only then will the proletariat itself disappear. Therefore, the proletariat will never abandon the democratic revolution halfway; it is the class capable of carrying the democratic revolution through to the end. This is the meaning of “I liberate myself by liberating humanity.” This is the class essence of the proletariat.
Chinese proletarians grew up in the struggle against imperialism, feudalism, and the bourgeoisie. Their emergence and development not only accompanied the emergence and development of the Chinese national bourgeoisie, but also accompanied the direct establishment of enterprises in China by imperialism. “Therefore, a large part of China’s proletariat is older and more experienced than the Chinese bourgeoisie, and consequently its social strength and social foundation are also broader.” From the Opium War to the May Fourth Movement, China’s modern industrial workers had grown to approximately two million. In addition to possessing the basic merits of the proletariat in general—being connected with the most advanced form of economy, possessing organization and discipline, and lacking privately owned means of production—they also had special merits: because they suffered extremely brutal exploitation and oppression by imperialism, the bourgeoisie, and feudal forces, their struggle was the most resolute and thorough; because there was no economic foundation for social reformism, the entire class, except for a very small number of labor traitors, was revolutionary. As soon as it stepped onto the political stage, it became the most politically conscious class in Chinese society under the leadership of its own class party. Because a considerable number of workers came from ruined peasants and had a natural connection with the broad peasantry, it was easy for them to form a firm alliance with the peasants. The class character of the proletariat determined that it would inevitably “become an independent class playing a leading role in history, and ultimately seize political power and become the ruling class.”
Explanation: This is the class superiority of the Chinese proletariat. Thus, a very simple truth of historical materialism often requires many practical struggles before it can be understood: Why is the proletariat the principal driving force of social and historical development, the hope of humanity’s future, and the principal class for realizing communism? Because the proletariat has no private property whatsoever. What does this “private property” mean? We must understand it deeply. Only by deeply understanding the definition and judgment that “the proletariat has no private property” through a systematic and profound understanding of the private-property system and the concept of private property can we know where the proletariat’s advanced nature comes from. What is private property? Private property is not an object, nor is it any particular thing. It is not a house or a car, nor is it a computer or a watch. What is private property? It is a relationship between people; it is a relationship in which an individual can appropriate social labor. The expression of private property is that it allows an individual, under a private name, to appropriate social labor.
The proletariat’s lack of private property means that the proletariat never appropriates social labor in an individual capacity and cannot appropriate social labor in an individual capacity. As long as, within social relations, the proletariat occupies a position in which it does not appropriate social labor but contributes labor to society, the proletariat will retain its revolutionary and militant character forever, until all oppression and exploitation are abolished. What is the basis of all oppression and exploitation? The basis of all oppression and exploitation is economic oppression and exploitation. The basis of all economic oppression and exploitation lies in the private-property system—in the recognition of the right of individuals to appropriate social labor and social wealth. This is private ownership. The idea that recognizes this right of individuals to appropriate social labor is called the concept of private property. Because the proletariat never appropriates social labor in an individual capacity and does not accept the idea of appropriating social labor and social wealth in an individual capacity, the proletariat is called “selflessly devoted to the public,” has no concept of private property, has no private property, and is a class capable of carrying out thorough revolution.
Therefore, one cannot judge a class while separating it from economic relations, but one also cannot adopt “economism.” Many petty bourgeois, after going bankrupt, have entered the ranks of the proletariat, but ideologically and politically they are still not proletarians at all. Many students are like this. Some Chinese students have long been subjected to bourgeois education, bourgeois education and enslavement, and during more than a decade of parasitic and exploitative life have developed the habits of the exploiting class. Such students have already come to regard appropriating the labor of others as normal. They stretch out their hands for clothes and open their mouths for food; they eat what their parents provide, live in what their parents provide, and use what their parents provide. Their parents’ labor is either created by themselves or appropriated from others—in any case, it is not their own, does not rely on their own labor, and they do not consume what they themselves have produced. Students who have lived this kind of parasitic and exploitative life for more than a decade are, in essence and by their nature, members of the exploiting class. Therefore, during their student lives, these students inevitably develop the habits of the exploiting class, acquire the character of the exploiting class, and adopt the entire way of life of the exploiting class.
However, up to the university stage, and until they have been liberated from secondary school, students who are not aristocrats, children of a labor aristocracy, bureaucratic capitalists, or big capitalists are, to some degree, subjected to oppression from their families, society, and schools before completing secondary school. Although they occupy a parasitic and exploitative position, they are still oppressed. That is why they possess a certain rebellious character, and that is why students are said to be petty bourgeois. Student life at school is also isolated, dispersed, and individualistic. On the one hand, students depend on the labor of others for their livelihood; on the other hand, they are oppressed and believe that this life based on the labor of others is unreliable and unstable, and that sooner or later they will face the problem of employment. So what is a student often like? Students often constitute a group representing the petty bourgeoisie. Moreover, the more capitalism develops and the more difficult the situation of the petty bourgeoisie becomes, the more closely the position of students approaches that of the bankrupt petty bourgeoisie. Students are a part of the petty bourgeoisie in the real economy and the forerunners of the petty bourgeoisie that will enter society in the future.
Whatever the position of the petty bourgeoisie in reality, students will believe that their own future will be like that. Most students regard their future as being part of the petty bourgeoisie, not the proletariat. If the position of the petty bourgeoisie in a society becomes more difficult, they will increasingly believe that they have no future, that they will go bankrupt and eventually become bankrupt petty bourgeois, and that they should become proletarians. This is why students are both reactionary and revolutionary. Their reactionary aspect lies in the fact that they have long been supported by the labor of others and have become accustomed to the way of life of the exploiting class; their revolutionary aspect lies in the fact that they are oppressed and their petty-bourgeois life is unstable. This is what Marx said in The Communist Manifesto: “The lower middle class, the small manufacturer, the shopkeeper, the artisan, the peasant, all fight against the bourgeoisie, to save from extinction their existence as fractions of the middle class. They are therefore not revolutionary, but conservative. Nay more, they are reactionary, for they try to roll back the wheel of history. If by chance they are revolutionary, they are so only in view of their impending transfer into the proletariat.”
Second, it must be noted that not everyone among students regards themselves as bankrupt petty bourgeois. Among students there is a group that seeks to advance through so-called “personal struggle”—which in reality means controlling capital; the so-called acquisition of knowledge is in reality the acquisition of capital. This group possesses a strong concept of private property, dreams of controlling capital, serving the bourgeoisie and its future interests, betraying its class origins, and becoming lackeys of the bourgeoisie. This is the worst and most reactionary part of the students. They hope that after completing their studies and graduating, they can leap into the wealthy stratum of the petty bourgeoisie, or even become bourgeois themselves, serving the bourgeoisie. These people are what Lu Xun called the “worn-out lackeys of the bourgeoisie.” Thus, this group is the right wing of the petty bourgeoisie. People often asked before: Where is the right wing of the petty bourgeoisie? Isn’t it right here? If you are carrying out a proletarian revolution but do not know where the petty-bourgeois right wing is, it is right inside the student population, right inside the schools.
Therefore, the students who choose the most popular majors at university and want to take the highest-paying jobs have the mentality and position of the petty-bourgeois right wing. In the future, they will become the class base of fascism. After graduating, such people will become programmers, and programmers will practice fascism. Especially once students enter the university stage—that is, the stage of entertainment and free flight—their oppression is removed, and their reactionary nature as members of the exploiting class is exposed even more strongly. Thus, for the children of workers and peasants, attending school is less a matter of receiving an education than of being enslaved by the bourgeoisie.
However, as Lenin said, the intelligentsia can also split. As they enter society, differentiation also takes place among the most politically conscious people and among intellectuals. Knowledge and broad experience are also the strengths of intellectuals. Intellectuals—petty-bourgeois intellectuals—are, after all, not yet members of the exploiting class. Many petty-bourgeois intellectuals, while occupying an oppressed position within class society, can come into contact to some extent with oppressed people. In this process, they can adopt a position and transform themselves to the position of the broad masses of working people, moving from the camp of the old society and the camp of intellectuals who support and serve it into the camp of revolutionary intellectuals who serve the workers and peasants.
Therefore, Chairman Mao said that the final dividing line between revolutionary, non-revolutionary, and counterrevolutionary intellectuals lies in whether they are willing to unite with the broad masses of workers and peasants and actually do so. Those students who stubbornly insist on turning knowledge into capital, burrowing into the bourgeois camp, becoming the worn-out lackeys of the bourgeoisie, serving the bourgeoisie, seeking high-paying jobs, doing less work while taking more money and exploiting others, will certainly, as Chairman Mao said, become counterrevolutionary intellectuals.
This is what “proletarianization” means. Proletarianization means completely breaking with traditional ownership relations and breaking with all traditional ideas. It means breaking with private ownership and the concept of private property, refusing to accept any act of appropriating social labor in an individual capacity, refusing to accept any relation of appropriating social labor in an individual capacity, and opposing the idea of appropriating social labor in an individual capacity. Therefore, everyone should now understand what bourgeois right is. To understand what bourgeois right is and what the hierarchical system is, and why the core of bourgeois-right thinking is the idea of hierarchy, one must understand that bourgeois right is the legal expression of capital’s relations of production. What kind of relation are capital’s relations of production? They are the relation in which capital extracts the labor of wage laborers—formally equal but actually unequal. What is its foundation? Its foundation is the recognition of individual and private appropriation of social labor.
Therefore, all the distinctions in this society, all class distinctions, all the relations of production produced by these distinctions, all the social relations corresponding to the relations of production, and all the ideologies produced by social relations will nourish bourgeois right and become the soil for capitalist restoration. For example, within our revolutionary organization there are all kinds of distinctions of this sort; in essence, all these distinctions are also class distinctions. Do not think that there are no class distinctions within a revolutionary organization; there are class distinctions within a revolutionary organization as well. Some people do less work and take more money, sitting in an air-conditioned room at a desk, eating snacks and drinking coffee, writing a little code, tapping on a keyboard, working two or three hours a day, and then idling away another five or six hours, spending the day comfortably. Then they go home to a prepared meal, while comrades wash their clothes, cook, and do the housework. Isn’t this appropriating the labor of others? Isn’t this living a life of appropriating the labor of others, appropriating social labor and social wealth in an individual capacity? Anyone living such a life will certainly become alienated from the broad masses of comrades and working people.
As for those students who dream of earning 20,000 or 30,000 yuan a month, entering some major tech company, making statements such as “If there’s a goose, choose the goose; if there’s no goose, delay graduation” (the goose refers to Tencent), and frantically want to become programmers who exploit people, they will inevitably embark on the extremely shameful and reactionary road of counterrevolutionary intellectuals. Because, to put it plainly, all these statements mean only this: I want to appropriate the labor of others, and the more I appropriate, the better.
So how is the revolutionary spirit of the proletariat developed? The revolutionary spirit of the proletariat can be developed only within the collective. Why can it be developed only within the collective? Because individual life in capitalist society is spontaneous and nourishes capitalist relations of production. Individual life under capitalism is life for the individual; life for the individual means harming others for one’s own benefit. Harming others for one’s own benefit inevitably means appropriating the labor of others, inevitably means recognizing private ownership, inevitably means recognizing the concept of private property, and inevitably develops into becoming bourgeois or spiritually bourgeois. Only within the collective can individual life be transformed into collective life. A person who maintains an individual life within the collective is seeking to break apart the revolutionary collective. Living a collective life within the collective does not simply mean that a person is geographically located within a revolutionary organization or revolutionary collective. The meaning of collective life is, as just stated, refusing to recognize any life that appropriates social labor and social wealth in an individual capacity. Collective life means that each contributes according to their ability and receives according to their needs. Within the revolutionary organization, we have established communism, military communism: each must contribute according to their ability and receive according to their needs. Only within collective life, by thinking not about appropriating social labor but about contributing labor to society, can one train oneself into a genuine proletarian. This is the entire meaning of proletarianization. One must cultivate oneself into a person who does not appropriate social labor but contributes labor to society. First of all, one should not appropriate the labor and wealth of the revolutionary organization, but should contribute labor and wealth to the revolutionary organization.
From the day of its emergence, the Chinese proletariat has continuously carried out revolutionary struggles against exploitation and oppression. Taking strikes as an example, according to incomplete statistics, there were 11 in 1913, 23 in 1917, and this number increased to 30 in 1918. However, the struggles in the early period were all spontaneous economic struggles, and spontaneous struggles cannot produce a communist system of ideas. Communist ideas can only be introduced from outside.
Explanation: Why? This was already discussed in What Is to Be Done?, the famous work Lenin published in 1902, which crushed Economism and laid the theoretical foundation for the founding of the Bolshevik Party. In What Is to Be Done?, a book that the Chinese leftist circles have been unable to understand even a single word of for decades, it explains why communist ideas can only be introduced from outside. This is because the spontaneous struggle of the proletariat can reach no higher than the level of trade unionism. The proletariat’s struggle is an economic struggle; the spontaneous struggle of the proletariat is an economic struggle. It can only unfold within the narrow scope of economic relations and within the narrow confines of the factory. In such a struggle, the proletariat cannot become conscious of its complete political opposition to the bourgeoisie. Unless such an economic struggle is raised to the level of political struggle, making the proletariat the representative of the entire people and the democratic representative of all oppressed classes in society, the proletariat cannot awaken and cannot overthrow the bourgeoisie as a system. It will only, under the influence of trade unionism and Economism, be satisfied with minor repairs and reforms that touch upon wages and the system of wage labor, and with reforms that do not touch the capitalist system. This is reformism: reformism means not changing the capitalist system, but only changing one’s position within the capitalist system.
Therefore, communist ideas must be introduced into the proletariat in order to make the proletariat a conscious class and enable it to organize itself as a class.
Only by introducing the scientific ideas of Marxism into the proletariat can the struggle of the proletariat be transformed from a spontaneous struggle into a conscious struggle.
Explanation: Otherwise, the proletariat cannot carry out a conscious struggle as a class, and it cannot raise itself to the level of a conscious class and lead the proletarian revolution. Without Marxist theory, proletarian revolution is impossible; “without revolutionary theory there can be no revolutionary movement.” Therefore, political struggle is very important. How can Marxist ideas be introduced into the ranks of the proletariat from outside? Political exposure is necessary. At the same time as proletarianizing ourselves, we must integrate ourselves into the broad masses of workers and peasants, and then learn to master Marxist philosophy, political economy, and scientific socialism. We must learn to identify all ugly phenomena in capitalist society, clearly expose the economic and class relations among the various classes behind every ugly phenomenon, and completely expose the political opposition between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. Only in this way can the proletariat awaken into a conscious class, recognize the political struggle among the various classes in society, and make proletarian revolution possible.
As the struggle developed, the proletariat gradually came to understand more deeply that it urgently needed a scientific revolutionary theory for guidance and urgently needed a revolutionary party of its own class to lead it.
The May Fourth Movement and the spread of Marxism-Leninism in China.
“The October Revolution brought us Marxism-Leninism with the sound of its guns.” It awakened the Chinese people as never before. A group of intellectuals with rudimentary communist ideas emerged, and the spread of Marxism-Leninism in China began. During this process, Chairman Mao represented the correct direction of integrating Marxism-Leninism with the practice of the Chinese revolution.
On December 26, 1893, Chairman Mao was born into a peasant family in Shaoshan Chong, Xiangtan County, Hunan. From the time he began participating in revolutionary activities, Chairman Mao diligently studied Marxism-Leninism, went deeply into actual struggles, and learned from the workers and peasants. In the summer of 1917, Chairman Mao conducted social investigations in the extensive countryside of Hunan. Later that year, he founded a workers’ night school in Changsha, personally taught classes, and spread revolutionary ideas. Through his practice of contact with workers and peasants, Chairman Mao drew inexhaustible wisdom and strength from the working people. In April 1918, Chairman Mao organized the revolutionary group the New People’s Study Society, whose aim was “to transform China and the world.” It carried out revolutionary activities in Hunan and elsewhere and trained a group of outstanding cadres for the Party, including He Shuheng, Cai Hesen, and Xiang Jingyu. In September of the same year, Chairman Mao came to Beijing for the first time in order to organize revolutionary young people to go to France for work-study. He systematically studied Marxism-Leninism and the Russian October Revolution, visited the Changxindian Locomotive and Rolling Stock Factory to learn about the hardships of the workers, and propagated revolutionary truths among them. In early 1919, Chairman Mao spread Marxism-Leninism in Beijing, Shanghai, Changsha, and other places and carried out propaganda and organizational work against imperialism and feudalism.
During this period, the broad ranks of intellectuals with rudimentary communist ideas also engaged in spreading Marxism-Leninism. Comrade Li Dazhao published articles such as The Victory of the Common People and The Victory of Bolshevism, praising the October Revolution and propagating Marxism-Leninism.
Explanation: (Someone asked whether the group that went to France to study included Deng Xiaoping and Zhou Enlai.) Of course, they were among them; they were part of that group. At the time, Chairman Mao and Yang Kaihui were in love and preparing to marry, but Chairman Mao did not hold a wedding ceremony. After they married, they simply invited a few close comrades to eat a meal at home, and then went north to Peking University to ask Hu Shi for money and organize this group going to France to study. As a result, they obtained 4,000 silver dollars, all of which was given to these students studying in France. Deng Xiaoping openly said that he had had a very hard time in France, and that after his monthly expenses he could only have a little over 200 francs left—more than 200 francs. Then he said that he had no money to get through the winter in France, so afterward he took several hundred francs in relief funds from this group studying in France and “barely” made it through a winter, “barely” living a life of eating steak and croissants, drinking coffee, and watching football matches in restaurants. As for that classic photograph of Deng Xiaoping, the one taken while he was studying in France shows Deng Xiaoping standing inside the Louvre Museum. Deng Xiaoping is wearing a suit and leather shoes, a high-end suit and overcoat, and a hat, standing in front of the Louvre. That is exactly how the student who dreams of becoming a programmer dresses. Deng the dog was very good at acting as a labor traitor; he engaged in plenty of scheming.
Under the influence of the October Revolution and following Lenin’s call, the epoch-making May Fourth Movement broke out in China in 1919. The basic cause of the May Fourth Movement was the national crisis created by imperialism’s intensified aggression against China and the Northern Warlord government’s brutal oppression at home and compromise and capitulation abroad. Its immediate trigger was China’s diplomatic failure at the Paris Peace Conference in January 1919. Under the control of British, American, and French imperialism, the Paris Peace Conference not only arrogantly rejected the just demands of the Chinese people to defend the country’s territorial sovereignty, but instead decided that Japan would take over Germany’s various privileges in Shandong, China. Faced with such a so-called peace treaty that humiliated the country and surrendered its rights, China’s traitorous Northern Warlord government was actually preparing to sign and recognize it. When the news arrived, the masses were furious. On May 4, students in Beijing first held rallies and demonstrations to protest imperialist aggression and the warlord government’s betrayal of the country.
Explanation: Thus, we can actually see that students also want revolution. One cannot say that students are not revolutionary; students must also be analyzed concretely, right? Students must also be analyzed concretely. There are different strata among students, including a left wing and a right wing. Students who eat from their parents, live with their parents, wear clothes bought by their parents, depend on their parents’ money—or on money their parents have stripped from others—to maintain a wealthy life, and later dream of becoming lackeys of the bourgeoisie are, of course, students who will take the counterrevolutionary road. But not all students are necessarily like this.
Why were Chinese students so revolutionary in the past? Because Chinese students either came from poor families and attended school through work-study and self-reliance instead of depending on their parents, or they were supported by their parents but still cared about the country and society, while also economizing and taking on some work to help support the household. Thus, Chinese people in the past, and students in the past, had a very strong sense of independence. What they studied at school was all modern learning, not the teachings of Confucius and Mencius, and they were not studying in order to become officials. Most students who studied this modern learning wanted to serve their country and change society. Most importantly, students at that time had connections with the workers and peasants. This is what Chairman Mao meant by the dividing line between revolutionary, non-revolutionary, and counterrevolutionary intellectuals. Most students were connected with the workers and peasants. Only a small number of children of bureaucratic compradores and children of rich peasants and landlords had no connection with the workers and peasants. Take Deng Xiaoping, for example: Deng Xiaoping was the son of a big landlord. Therefore, he had no connection with the broad masses of workers and peasants, and of course he was a counterrevolutionary. Ding Ling was the same. Ding Ling’s family owned an unknown amount of land and was, in any case, a big landlord family. The protagonist of her Diary of Miss Sophia was actually based on herself. She would simply parasitize in the school dormitory every day, never go out, warm milk for amusement, and then pour it away without even drinking it.
Shouting the slogan “Fight for national sovereignty abroad and punish the national traitors at home,” they demanded the punishment of the pro-Japanese traitors Cao Rulin, Lu Zongyu, and Zhang Zongxiang. Students throughout the country responded, but the students’ patriotic movement was brutally suppressed by the reactionary warlord government. At this critical moment, the Chinese proletariat stepped forward and stood at the forefront of the struggle. Beginning on June 3, workers in Shanghai first launched an anti-imperialist political general strike, and workers in various localities responded one after another. This was the first time that the Chinese working class independently stepped onto the political stage, and it played a decisive role in the victory of the struggle, displaying the tremendous political power and leadership of the working class. Under the leadership of the working class, the movement rapidly spread throughout the country, forming an unprecedented upsurge of anti-imperialist and patriotic strikes, school boycotts, and merchant strikes. This threatened the rule of the warlord government and forced it to release the arrested students, dismiss the three traitors Cao, Lu, and Zhang, and declare that it would refuse to sign the Treaty of Versailles. This anti-imperialist, anti-feudal patriotic movement finally achieved a major victory.
Explanation: Thus, those who advocate the theory that “the masses are backward” will fail once again. The working class stepped onto the historical stage through political strikes and even armed uprisings. This was true in Britain, France, and Germany, and it was also true in China. From the moment the working class stepped onto the historical stage, it engaged in political struggle and began political strikes. The working class is absolutely not made up of people who care only about their own interests, only about their own lives, and only about a few petty gains. Such people are petty bourgeois, absolutely not members of the working class.
The May Fourth Movement was not only an unprecedented anti-imperialist and patriotic movement, but also a thorough movement against feudal culture. “At that time, opposing the old morality and advocating the new morality, and opposing the old literature and advocating the new literature, were the two banners of the Cultural Revolution, and they accomplished great deeds.” For the first time, it openly launched a fierce attack against the feudal ideology that had maintained the rule of the landlord class for several thousand years, loudly put forward the slogan “Down with the Confucian shop,” advocated democracy and science, opposed the cannibalistic feudal rites, and developed revolutionary theory, giving rise to a vigorous New Culture Movement. After the May Fourth Movement began, a nationwide upsurge of propaganda for Marxism-Leninism and the Russian October Revolution arose, becoming the mainstream of the New Culture Movement.
The great leader Chairman Mao gave the May Fourth Movement an extremely high evaluation. “The outstanding historical significance of the May Fourth Movement lies in the fact that it adopted a posture that the Xinhai Revolution had not yet adopted: thorough and uncompromising opposition to imperialism and thorough and uncompromising opposition to feudalism.” “The May Fourth Movement was part of the proletarian world revolution of that time.” It marked the beginning of the New Democratic Revolution led by the Chinese proletariat.
During the May Fourth Movement, communist intellectuals recognized the strength of the proletariat and recognized the necessity of uniting with the workers and peasants. They resolved to go among the workers and peasants to carry out propaganda and organizational work for Marxism-Leninism.
Explanation: Thus, the communist intellectuals of that time did not burrow into offices, enter the office buildings of major tech companies, or sit in air-conditioned rooms to become highly educated professionals or programmers. Instead, they went to workers’ districts, workers’ residential areas, and factories to become part of the working class.
Thus, the May Fourth Movement promoted the spread of Marxism-Leninism in China and promoted the integration of Marxism-Leninism with the Chinese revolutionary movement, making ideological and cadre preparations for the founding of the Communist Party of China.
Explanation: How can students become great? Students can become great only through proletarianization. The Communist Manifesto says that the petty bourgeoisie is conservative and even reactionary because it seeks to turn the wheel of history backward. If it is revolutionary, it is because it is about to enter the ranks of the proletariat.
After the outbreak of the May Fourth Movement, Chairman Mao immediately entered the struggle, organized and led progressive groups such as the Hunan Students’ Federation and the Hunan Federation of All Circles, launched a general strike by students in Changsha, initiated a large-scale movement to boycott Japanese goods, and actively guided revolutionary intellectuals onto the path of uniting with the workers and peasants.
Explanation: Therefore, statements such as “only by separating oneself from physical labor can one develop and write” are extremely reactionary. If one separates oneself from physical labor and then writes, for which class is one writing? One can only be writing for the bourgeoisie.
In July 1919, Chairman Mao founded the famous revolutionary publication Xiang River Review in Changsha and stated in the founding declaration he personally wrote: “What force is the strongest? The force of the united people is the strongest. What should we not fear? We should fear neither Heaven, nor ghosts, nor the dead, nor bureaucrats, nor warlords, nor capitalists.” Using the Marxist-Leninist viewpoint of class struggle and the thoroughly anti-imperialist and anti-feudal revolutionary spirit, he exposed the crimes of imperialism and feudal forces and praised the great victory of the October Revolution. In the second, third, and fourth issues of Xiang River Review, Chairman Mao successively published essays titled The Great Union of the People, vigorously propagating the October Revolution and Marxism-Leninism and, in connection with China’s actual conditions, pointing out the direction of struggle for the revolutionary people. This greatly promoted the anti-imperialist and anti-feudal revolutionary movement in Hunan and throughout the country at that time. In the winter of the same year, Chairman Mao came to Beijing for the second time. This time, he arduously studied the classic works of Marxism-Leninism and the historical experience of the Russian October Revolution and carried out tremendous work to integrate Marxism-Leninism with the Chinese revolutionary movement.
Explanation: Even “Feng Li” understands that without close ties to the workers and peasants, what one writes will become divorced from reality and move toward opposition to the workers and peasants. If one does not maintain ties with the workers and peasants, does not maintain ties with the masses, and does not even care about comrades, what one writes will be empty and boring. It is like certain people who spend several months writing without producing anything useful. This is because their minds are occupied either with high-paying jobs, a comfortable and pleasant life, or parasitism and appropriating the labor of others.
After the May Fourth Movement, a magnificent ideological movement centered on the dissemination of Marxism-Leninism and socialism arose in Chinese society. Societies and publications propagating Marxism-Leninism sprang up like bamboo shoots after a spring rain. Comrade Zhou Enlai organized the Awakening Society in Tianjin and published Awakening; Comrade Yun Daiying organized the Mutual Aid Society in Wuhan and published Mutual Aid. According to incomplete statistics, more than 200 newly published newspapers and periodicals throughout the country had, to some extent, a tendency to propagate socialism.
The spread of Marxism-Leninism in China aroused the extreme hatred and fear of the class enemy. Right-wing intellectuals represented by Hu Shi attacked Marxism as unsuitable for China’s national conditions, advocated intellectual-class reformism, and opposed using Marxism-Leninism to guide the Chinese revolution. Subsequently, certain representatives of the landlord and comprador classes, under the disguise of supporting socialism, propagated such reformist fallacies as labor-capital cooperation and parliamentarianism and opposed the Marxist theory of violent revolution. Some anarchists advocated absolute freedom, denied all authority, and opposed the Marxist theory of the dictatorship of the proletariat. The communists represented by Chairman Mao engaged in a resolute struggle against these anti-Marxist trends of thought. Chairman Mao believed that only Marxism-Leninism could solve the problem of China’s future. He pointed out: “An ‘ism’ is like a banner; once the banner is raised, everyone has hope and knows what to follow.” Chairman Mao also pointed out: “Throughout history, no reactionary ruling class has ever willingly stepped down before being overthrown by others. To hope that they will change their hearts and become good is an illusion. Only by following the Russian road of violent revolution can Chinese society be thoroughly transformed.” Following the path of the Russians—this was the conclusion. Reformism, parliamentarianism, anarchism, and the like were all fundamentally unworkable. Through this struggle, the offensive of the class enemy was crushed, the broad spread of Marxism-Leninism in China was promoted, and the conditions for founding the Communist Party of China were created.
(The following is the question-and-answer session.)
Question One: Why was the traitor Deng still able to disguise himself until later?
Answer: Why was he able to disguise himself until later? Because you are now looking at this matter from the perspective of apriorism, wearing apriorist glasses when looking at history; you know the outcome. But people at the time did not know the outcome. Let me ask you: Do you now know which people among us will betray the revolution? Do you know? You do not know either. Why do you not know? Because without going through revolutionary struggle, without revolutionary practice and experience, and without raising your level of Marxism-Leninism, it is impossible to distinguish genuine Marxism-Leninism from false Marxism-Leninism. It is like some new comrades who also cannot distinguish genuine Marxism-Leninism from false Marxism-Leninism, right? Some people say that we should establish a “little sacred treasury” and ask you to hand over 300 yuan. And then you handed it over. What happened next? It was misappropriated to buy snacks. The young comrade still did not believe it when they learned what had happened. Isn’t this an inability to distinguish? Of course, they cannot keep pretending forever either; opportunists always go bankrupt before the Marxist line. This is not a matter of being too merciful; it is about helping them transform themselves. Only those who stubbornly persist in resistance, refuse transformation, and refuse to abandon their privileges of exploiting and oppressing others ultimately degenerate into traitors.
Question Two: Could you explain once again the difference between the Old Democratic Revolution and the New Democratic Revolution discussed at the beginning of the study session?
Answer: I already explained it all. Why do you want me to say it again? It shows that you did not listen carefully. The Old Democratic Revolution and the New Democratic Revolution are both democratic revolutions. Democratic revolutions are all aimed at abolishing the feudal system and abolishing feudal relations of production. The Old Democratic Revolution refers to a democratic revolution led by the bourgeoisie, while the New Democratic Revolution refers to a democratic revolution led by the proletariat. The Old Democratic Revolution is not necessarily led by the bourgeoisie; it may also be led by the peasant class. In short, it is primarily a democratic revolution led by the bourgeoisie rather than by the proletariat. The New Democratic Revolution is a democratic revolution led by the proletariat.
Question Three: Does “bourgeois revolution” mean a revolution led by the bourgeoisie? Or does it mean that its subjective aim is to realize capitalism? Or does any revolution that is objectively beneficial to the development of capitalism count as a bourgeois revolution?
Answer: The concept of bourgeois revolution is somewhat complex in certain cases. In the general sense, a bourgeois revolution should refer to a revolution led by the bourgeoisie, which is called a bourgeois revolution. But sometimes it also carries the meaning of objectively developing capitalism—that is, a revolution abolishing feudal relations of production, which is the same meaning as a democratic revolution. For example, sometimes people say that something “has the character of a bourgeois revolution.” But generally speaking, we still understand it as a revolution led by the bourgeoisie. So there are several possible understandings.
Question Four: Does the socialist superstructure appear first, or does the socialist economic base appear first?
Answer: A socialist economic base cannot possibly appear within a capitalist society. Socialist relations of production cannot arise spontaneously under capitalism. Only after capitalist society has been eliminated, political power has been seized, and the economy of the entire society has been transformed can socialist relations of production possibly emerge. Socialism must first have public ownership—how could there be public ownership in a capitalist society? Without seizing political power through revolution, confiscating private property, especially bourgeois private property, and then carrying out nationalization, it is impossible to implement socialism.
Question Five: What kind of students are willing to make revolution?
Answer: Students who are oppressed are willing to make revolution; students who can accept proletarianization are willing to make revolution. Those who want to become rich are not willing to make revolution. Students who want to do less work while taking more money and exploiting others are not willing to make revolution. Students who want to become programmers are not willing to make revolution. Students who want to sit at a stock-market trading desk and trade stocks cannot possibly make revolution. Being oppressed does not necessarily mean that one will make revolution; you have to look at what kind of oppression it is. If you are talking about infighting within the exploiting class, that does not count as being oppressed. Those who are oppressed continuously will of course want to make revolution. But those who are only temporarily oppressed, while their actual class position means that they are not genuinely oppressed people, will certainly not want to make revolution.
How exactly are people oppressed? It must be analyzed from the standpoint of social relations and class relations; one cannot analyze it based on a few phenomena. For example, consider a husband-and-wife noodle-shop business. The wife is oppressed by the husband, but when you step forward to defend the wife who is being abused, she joins her husband in dealing with you. Why? Isn’t this wife also oppressed? Why is she counterrevolutionary? Because, in the final analysis, within the economic relations of society she is not oppressed; she is still a prosperous member of the petty bourgeoisie. She wants to oppress others, and she wants to consume what we produce. Or take the wife of a truck driver, right? She appears to be abused by the truck driver, beaten by him, and cheated on by him. But such a person also helps her truck-driver husband establish connections and obtain business, using the truck driver’s labor to live a comfortable life above the people. Such a person is not oppressed; she is an oppressor. Therefore, one must examine the whole of social relations and cannot look only at one or two phenomena.
For example, wasn’t there a very famous incident before? Yes, the Huawei 251 case. When Huawei mistreated that person, all the internet users helped him and increased the public-opinion pressure on Huawei. Then Huawei finally compromised and made concessions, but after that person was released from prison, he turned around and thanked Huawei, thanked the company, and said that the internet users had been too radical. There are many people like this. There are many such people. For example, the parents in the Pucheng incident: after reportedly receiving more than two million yuan from the government, they turned around and sold out their son, whose bones were not yet cold. Then they came forward and said, “This movement has become so intense; some people have ulterior motives, so please do not incite people here.”
There are also people who received education and training from a revolutionary organization and learned Marxism from that revolutionary organization. What happened? They forgot the ideals of the revolutionary organization, forgot their own oppressed status, and instead began living a carefree life of food, drink, and entertainment at university, while brazenly saying that they wanted to become programmers and members of the exploiting class. Such people are not oppressed either; they want to become oppressors, they want to become cannibals. “Cannibalism”: some people gain knowledge from this collective and from the revolution, but they regard knowledge as private property, demand exorbitant prices from the Party and the people, open their bloody mouths, and want to devour people with loud chomping sounds. Such people are not oppressed; they seek to transform themselves into people who oppress others. Therefore, we still have to look at the whole of social relations.
RedGPT Summary:
Alright, below I will do only one thing:
Organize this entire section you provided into a systematic summary that even someone who hasn’t seen or heard it can directly grasp the core ideas and the logical structure.
No evaluation, no correction, no additional external material, no change of stance, only faithfully distill what this section discusses, how it justifies step by step, and where the conclusions point to.
Chapter 1 · Section 1 · Part 1
Core content systematical summary (for learners who did not participate)
I. The fundamental problem awareness of this section: Why must the Chinese revolution establish a proletarian party
From the very beginning, this section explicitly poses a fundamental proposition:
If there is to be a revolution, there must be a revolutionary party; without a proletarian Marxist-Leninist party, the Chinese revolution cannot be accomplished.
Around this proposition, the section answers four progressively deeper questions:
- Why must China establish a proletarian party, rather than rely on existing forces?
- What are the objects, paths, and leading classes of the revolution determined by the nature of Chinese society?
- Why cannot peasant revolution or bourgeois-democratic revolution achieve final victory?
- Why can only the proletariat and its party carry the democratic revolution through to the end?
II. The fundamental reason for revolution’s success or failure: subjective conditions — the line and the party
1. Revolution depends not only on objective conditions but also on decisive subjective conditions
This section begins by emphasizing a basic historical materialist judgment:
-
The objective conditions of revolution come from social-historical laws;
-
But social-historical laws can only act through human practice;
-
In reality, many revolutions fail even when objective conditions are present, because:
- There is no correct leadership by the party,
- There is no correct line.
Therefore, revolution failure is not “the people are incapable,” but rather subjective conditions are not mature.
III. To understand the Chinese revolution, one must first understand the nature of Chinese society
1. Social nature is the starting point for judging all revolutionary issues
To clarify:
- Revolution’s nature
- Revolutionary object
- Revolutionary goals
- Revolutionary path
- Revolutionary prospects
The prerequisite is only one: the social nature and the principal contradiction must be clarified.
2. The fundamental characteristics of semi-feudal, semi-colonial China
You systematically explain Mao Zedong’s analysis in “On Protracted War” and “On Chinese Revolution and the Chinese Communist Party” about Chinese society:
- China’s feudal society has persisted for thousands of years;
- After the Opium War:
- On one hand, feudal natural economy was disrupted;
- On the other hand, feudal land ownership and feudal exploitation relations still existed;
- National capitalist forces were weak, under dual control by imperialism and feudal forces;
- State sovereignty was lost, political, military, and economic lifelines controlled by imperialism;
- Domestic political and economic imbalances were extreme, warlord fragmentation existed for a long time;
- The broad masses, especially peasants, suffered unprecedented oppression and exploitation.
3. The main contradiction of Chinese society
From this, the conclusion is drawn:
- Imperialism vs. Chinese nation
- Feudalism vs. the broad masses
These two contradictions in China are not parallel but highly overlapping:
- Landlord class = comprador class
- Feudal forces = social base of imperialism’s rule in China
Therefore, the struggle against imperialism, feudalism, and bureaucrat-capitalism is essentially one and the same revolutionary struggle, i.e., to overthrow the “three mountains.”
IV. Why armed peasant-fighter carve-out areas and rural encirclement of cities is the inevitable path
In this section you clearly point out:
- Feudal economy’s self-sufficiency → inevitably leads to political separatism;
- Imperialism builds代理 in different regions → intensifies warlord clashes;
- Warlord clashes + regional development imbalances → anti-revolutionary rule is not a solid block;
This provides the practical premise for:
Armed peasant-fighter carve-out areas, rural encirclement of cities, and seizing power by force,
not a subjective choice.
V. Why the old democratic revolution failed
1. The fundamental cause of peasant revolution’s failure
- Peasants are the main force in anti-imperialist, anti-feudal struggle;
- However, constrained by backward productive forces;
- Lack of scientific worldview;
- No leadership by a proletarian party;
- Inability to propose a thorough democratic revolutionary program;
Therefore, peasant revolutions can only repeatedly fail within the old制度 framework.
2. The fundamental cause of bourgeois-democratic revolution’s failure
- National bourgeoisie is weak economically and politically;
- Deeply tied to imperialism and feudal forces;
- Fears awakening and growth of workers and peasants;
- Cannot and does not dare to mobilize the broadest masses;
Therefore, bourgeois-democratic revolution must inevitably fail halfway.
VI. The true meaning of the democratic revolution: fundamental difference between old and new democratic revolutions
1. The essence of democratic revolution
The essence of democratic revolution is not “democratic制度,” but:
Abolition of feudal制度, feudal land ownership, and feudal relations of production.
2. The fundamental differences between old and new democratic revolutions
- Old democratic revolution:
- Not led by the proletariat (mostly upper bourgeois or peasant classes)
- Incomplete; ultimately fails or reverses
- New democratic revolution:
- Led by the proletariat
- Based on a workers-peasants alliance
- Can carry the democratic revolution through to the end and transition to socialist revolution
3. Why only the proletariat can completely complete the democratic revolution
You present the section’s core, most systematic theoretical argument:
-
The proletariat has no private property of its own
-
Private property is not a thing but:
- A social relation of private ownership of social labor in the name of individuals
-
The proletariat:
- Does not own social labor
- Does not agree with private ownership of social labor
- Can only liberate itself by abolishing all systems of exploitation
Therefore:
The class nature of the proletariat determines that it will never abandon the democratic revolution midway.
VII. The class advantages of the Chinese proletariat
You systematically summarize the particular advantages of the Chinese proletariat:
- Directly arises from imperialist enterprises in China;
- Subjected to triple oppression by imperialism, feudalism, and the bourgeoisie;
- No reformist economic base;
- Naturally connected with the peasantry;
- Once on the political stage, engages in political struggle rather than only economic struggle;
Therefore, the Chinese proletariat possesses a high degree of revolutionary character from the outset.
VIII. Students, petit-bourgeoisie, and the problem of “proletarianization”
This section has the strongest practical relevance within the whole chapter.
1. The class nature of students
- Students as a whole belong to the petit-bourgeoisie;
- They are both rebellious and wavering;
- Their revolutionary potential comes from “on the verge of collapse”;
- Reactionary tendencies stem from long-term parasitism and possession of others’ labor.
2. Differentiation within the petit-bourgeoisie
You clearly distinguish three categories:
- Students willing to proletarianize → can become revolutionary forces
- Students who are wavering and watching → require struggle and transformation
- Students attempting to become exploiters through “struggle” → as the right-wing petit-bourgeoisie, the class basis for future fascism
3. The true meaning of proletarianization
Proletarianization is not an identity, but:
- Break completely with private ownership of the means of production;
- Not owning social labor in a personal name;
- Living, working, and fighting collectively;
- Transforming “owning labor” into “contributing labor.”
IX. The meaning of Marxism being “imposed from outside”
You tightly connect to the core conclusion of “What to Do”:
- Proletarian spontaneous struggle can only reach syndicalism;
- It remains at the economic level of struggle;
- It cannot spontaneously rise to political struggle;
Therefore:
We must expose politically, to inject Marxism into the proletarian ranks from the outside, so that it becomes a conscious class.
X. The historical significance of the May Fourth Movement
1. The triple nature of the May Fourth Movement
- Anti-imperialist patriotic movement
- Anti-feudal cultural movement
- A milestone for the proletariat stepping onto the political stage
2. The decisive role of the working class in May Fourth
- Political general strike
- Directly changes the balance of struggle
- Proves that the proletariat is not a class only concerned with small profits
XI. The spread of Marxism-Leninism in China and the preparations for party building
- Influence of the October Revolution
- Mao Zedong combined Marxism-Leninism with China’s realities
- Revolutionary intellectuals moved toward the workers and peasants
- Struggles against reformism, parliamentarianism, and anarchism
Thus:
Ideological preparation + cadre preparation → historical condition for the founding of the Chinese Communist Party
XII. The overarching conclusion for the entire section
The content ultimately boils down to a clear conclusion:
China’s revolution can win not by accident, not by individual heroism, but because the proletarian party, under the guidance of the correct line, combines Marxism-Leminism with China’s revolutionary reality and with the masses of workers and peasants.
Chapter 1, Section 1, Part 2
Today we are talking about the latter half of the first chapter, first section, of “The History of the Two-Line Struggle within the Chinese Communist Party.” Actually, this part isn’t long, but it is quite important. Everyone should relate it to the world historical background at the time and specifically analyze how the founding line of the Chinese Communist Party was formed and what kinds of struggles it experienced.
Indeed, when we spoke about the preface and the first section before, we already mentioned features in the development of the Chinese Communist Party. The CCP was established after the October Revolution, especially under the conditions of Marxism’s introduction to China during the May Fourth Movement. The May Fourth Movement was a turning point in China’s democratic revolution. The democratic revolution before May Fourth is called the old democratic revolution; the democratic revolution after May Fourth became the New Democratic Revolution. The distinction lies in: the old democratic revolution was led by the bourgeoisie or another class—perhaps the peasant class; while the New Democratic Revolution is led by the proletariat. We have discussed the differences between the bourgeois democratic revolution and the New Democratic Revolution and old democratic revolutions before.
We also discussed what characteristics the development of the CCP has had. Because the CCP was a party with immature practical experience, just emerging from the state where workers’ movements and socialist movements were separated, it joined them together. Merging these two is truly what happened. The workers’ movement has a long history, but socialist movement was just beginning.
Where did socialism come from? It came from Germany. Why from Germany? Its precursor—utopian socialism—originated in France and Britain. Because France and Britain were the earliest to develop capitalism, and the flaws of capitalism were exposed earliest there. In these places, there was a section of bourgeois intellectuals who were dissatisfied with the capitalist system, who understood its decay, and who understood the people’s living conditions, and thus proposed utopian socialism. But the problem is utopian socialism is a socialist from the stance of intellectuals, not of the working class, not scientific socialism, and cannot serve the proletariat. It criticized capitalism, proposed some correct socialist principles, but did not provide a scientific method for transitioning from capitalism to socialism and communism; nor did it stand on the correct stance to propose communist principles.
Why could Germany form scientific socialism? When did the Communist Manifesto appear? Everyone knows that the Communist Manifesto was published in 1848. At that time, Britain and France had already degenerated; the bourgeoisie had come into power for over a decade. In France, the July Revolution of 1830 brought financial bourgeoisie to power; in Britain, the Reform Act of 1832 brought industrial bourgeoisie to full power. The old aristocracy and landed nobles who used to hold power had changed. After the bourgeoisie came to power in Britain and France, they quickly decayed and degenerated; vulgar economics had spread in these places. There were propertied socialists among the bourgeoisie in these places who were dissatisfied with capitalism, understood its decay, and understood the people’s living conditions, so they proposed utopian socialism. But utopian socialism is a socialist based on the stance of intellectuals, not workers, not scientific socialism, and cannot serve the proletariat. It criticized capitalism, proposed some correct socialist principles, but did not provide a scientific method to transition from capitalism to socialism and communism; nor did it stand on a correct stance to propose communist principles.
Why could Germany produce scientific socialism? The Communist Manifesto appeared in 1848. The reason Germany produced scientific socialism is that three major workers’ movements occurred, giving the British, French, and German workers a place on the political stage; Germany had the best conditions among them. In these three workers’ movements, the British Chartist movement was the largest in scale and longest in duration, but it had significant problems: parliamentaryism, reformism, and pacifism influenced it. It did not advocate overthrowing the bourgeois rule, nor abolishing private property; it only advocated universal suffrage. The Lyon uprising in France, although advocating a republic and overthrow of monarchism (as it was still a constitutional government at the time under Louis-Philippe and the Orleans monarchy), did not clearly explain why to overthrow the existing government and did not oppose private property completely. However, the 1844 uprising of the Silesian textile workers in Germany, which developed into the first clear call to abolish private property, was a distinction of the German workers’ movement.
Why? Because the German workers’ situation was worse than that of Britain and France, and German workers faced double oppression. In Britain, the ongoing bourgeois revolution and reform movement had transformed feudal land ownership into capitalist large-scale landholding; in France, the revolution had almost destroyed feudal ownership, though the Bourbon Restoration briefly returned, Louis-Philippe later rose again, so the power of landowners was not fully reestablished. Germany was different: its workers were very revolutionary and very poor, oppressed by capitalists and by Junker nobles. They hated capitalism even before German capitalism had developed, so German workers were the most combative. Moreover, economically, Germany could inherit classical political economy and utopian socialism from Britain and France, and also developed its own mechanical materialism and dialectics.
Marx and Engels, two of the greatest philosophers, thinkers, and revolutionaries of modern times, extracted the rational core of Feuerbach’s materialism and Hegel’s rational idealist dialectics, and together with the rational core of classical political economy and utopian socialism—essentially taking the essence and discarding the dross—and transformed these bourgeois old knowledges through their revolutionary practice and experience into Marxism. So the three components of Marxism are: dialectical materialism, political economy, and scientific socialism. That is how it was born. On the one hand, it drew from English and French experience; on the other hand, it arose from the progress and strength of the workers, producing communism in Germany.
At first, the German workers and communism did not unite. The German workers were initially still on the far left of the bourgeois democratic camp, during the 1848 revolution they became the far-left of the petty-bourgeois democratic faction. This is what we later learned: the movement to defend the empire’s constitution in 1848–1849 involved petty-bourgeois leadership and Prussian armed conflicts. Marx and Engels believed the proletariat had not yet fully awakened, so they advised the proletariat to participate in the movement as the far-left of the petty-bourgeois democratic faction.
Marxism did not develop smoothly. There was no Communist Party in Germany at first. What existed initially in Germany? A brotherhood-like organization called the League of Just Men. Later, under Marx’s efforts to combine the worker movement and socialism, including leading the 1848 revolution and educating and training German communists, collaborating with socialist internationals worldwide, they gradually fused the worker movement with socialism, and transformed the League of Just Men into the Communist League. The world’s first Communist Party was thus established. It defeated various opportunist socialist currents such as Proudhonists, and, against the bourgeois socialist, capitalist socialist, feudal socialist, and utopian socialist, in theory and practice, established the Communist Party. Later, in 1864, during the Polish uprising, the First International was formed. So, the German Communist Party’s establishment was solid and real.
As for the Russian Communist Party, the Bolshevik Party, how was it established? It was also formed along the line directed by Lenin. But China is different: the CCP’s establishment has a big feature—it was transplanted from foreign countries. While we cannot say this is a problem by itself, because the Bolshevik Party in Russia also came from Marxism transported from Germany. The problem lies in the domestic intellectuals not fully comprehending Marxism and not uniting with the workers.
Thus the CCP in its first fourteen years suffered many losses. Many left-leaning petty-bourgeois intellectuals and ambitious individuals joined the party to seize power. Then, freed from labor, they became professional revolutionaries, seized power, and then engaged in sectarianism, purges, and personal power grabs, leading various opportunist lines. All opportunist lines were born from individuals or small groups for their own interests, harming revolutionary and class interests.
Chen Duxiu, Qu Qiubai, Li Lishan, Luo Zhanglong, Wang Ming, Zhang Guotao all behaved thus. They sought personal benefit, sometimes posing as advanced intellectuals to deceive others, or using the supposed advanced worker identity to mislead, thereby seizing party leadership. Our organization itself has had similar episodes, such as XXX trying to pose as an advanced worker to deceive—ridiculous. There were also many petty-bourgeois opportunists, reformists, and schemers who tried to turn knowledge into capital for themselves. Therefore, it is necessary to fight these opportunists. First, there must be a process of proletarianization of revolutionary intellectuals, transforming petty-bourgeois intellectuals into revolutionary intellectuals, by embracing the workers and peasants. As Chairman Mao said, there must be a shift in class stance and class feelings. In the past, students could not bear heavy labor; clothing worn by workers and peasants was not acceptable to intellectuals who preferred long gowns or even suits. Some members of our organization were like that. Later, Chairman Mao said that true revolutionaries who engage with workers and peasants undergoing a transformation in their class feelings and stance would no longer look down on intellectuals. Although workers’ and peasants’ hands may be dirty, they are the cleanest, cleaner than any intellectual. This is the change in class stance and feelings. So we must achieve proletarianization as well. The CCP’s early losses came from a group of such intellectuals who, in a petty-bourgeois position, failed to unite with workers and peasants, and instead pursued personal gain, ultimately betraying the party and the revolution.
This is a brief history of the background. After May Fourth Movement, as Marxism-Leninism and the Chinese revolutionary movement merged more and more, the task of building the CCP grew more urgent. Of course, we should note that the lack of experience and lack of unity among intellectuals does not mean we should reject founding the party. The task of party-building is before us; it is a revolutionary need. Because of revolutionary necessity, the Communist Party is inevitable. Here lies a line dispute: should we possess this experience or not? Should we unite with the workers and peasants or not? Here is the line struggle. If uniting with the workers and peasants to engage in political struggle and follow the correct path can mature the party quickly, letting intellectuals go through some trials and transformation, then that path is possible. But at that time the CCP did not walk this path. Because Marxism was still new to Chinese intellectuals, and the relationship between Chinese intellectuals and workers and peasants was not deep enough.
If we must say, the CCP at that time had another characteristic: some individuals in history did not perform to their full potential. Chairman Mao didn’t have very high prestige inside the CCP at that time. He had made many contributions by combining with workers and peasants, but at that time he was still growing, leading farmer movements and worker movements, and this was different from Lenin and Marx’s conditions. Lenin, when he built the party, was already renowned; he joined the revolution at seventeen, founded the party at thirty-three, and after sixteen years had authority. When he formed the Petersburg Workers’ Liberation Committee, he was an old revolutionary. Who would dare oppose Lenin? Of course some did. But Lenin had already gained authority through actual struggle, and through his activities since 1894, including his ties with the peasantry. He was exiled to Siberia, studied revolutionary theory further. Lenin was a dominant figure in the Russian Marxist world; who would dare debate him? Lenin debunked them, including the debates with “Legal Marxists” and the “Economists,” with his exceptional theoretical level, crushing their reformist and bourgeois socialist tendencies. On this basis, a cadre of professional revolutionaries led by Lenin formed. This group, aligned with the worker-peasant alliance, led to the creation of the Bolshevik Party. This is the difference between Lenin and Chairman Mao’s conditions. Personal influence in history is thus very important. Of course, it would also have been possible that if Lenin hadn’t existed, another Lenin could have emerged—that is a historical question hard to answer.
Thus Mao Zedong’s prestige was built after the CCP’s founding, through his work in party affairs. How did Mao’s prestige come about? By leading peasant associations, forging the united front against the Kuomintang, and building rural revolutionary bases; it grew in this process. Lenin’s prestige existed before founding the party; Mao’s prestige was not that high before, so the CCP’s First National Congress elected a nominal Chen Duxiu as Secretary General.
Should we establish a proletarian party in China? Should we follow Lenin’s Bolshevik model and build a proletarian revolutionary party; or should we follow the Second International’s revisionist path and build a bourgeois reformist party? Chairman Mao insisted on Marxist-Leninist party-building principles and fought fiercely against all anti-Marxist-Leninist ideas.
In fact, this is not a coincidence; Russia had been an imperialist country with advanced capitalist relations. Lenin had long been tempered by revolution there. In the 19th century, the populists in Russia—who themselves tried to lead the revolution—were ancestors of Chinese student movements; thus Russia’s revolutionary history and democratic revolution history are longer than China’s. Russian capitalism, especially its capitalist history, is longer than China’s. China’s past revolutions were peasant revolutions. There were intellectuals among peasant revolutions, but they were not capitalist ones; they lacked capitalism-based knowledge. Although there were some prominent revolutionaries among peasant revolutions in China—like Hong Xiuquan and Hong Ruan—both understood capitalism, at a time when global capitalism was not yet developed, 1850s and 1860s, before imperialism era. They had only limited knowledge of capitalism, which was not enough for this era.
Marx grew up in Germany and later lived long in London, so he understood capitalism well. Lenin lived in Russia, an imperialist country, and had long had a grasp of capitalism. The workers’ movements in Russia had already appeared in the 1860s–70s—South Russian Workers’ Union, North Russian Workers’ Association—so Russian workers and intellectuals already had experiences with capitalism. That is why Lenin could emerge there. It is not a historical accident. It is not that the Chinese Communist Party could not produce a great figure like Mao Zedong; China did produce Mao. The “Great Savior” of the people was Mao Zedong. How did this “great savior” arise? Precisely when social contradictions became concentrated, and revolution required a revolutionary class leader. So whether sooner or later, whether before or after founding the party, is a Chinese national characteristic. China’s national character also has advantages: Mao was better at understanding peasants, as China’s society is split into two halves with more peasants. Although Russia also had many peasants, Lenin, as a professional revolutionary, spent more time in urban areas; Mao’s connection with the peasantry was deeper.
This aligns with the needs of both countries’ revolutions. Lenin led an urban-centric revolution in an imperialist country; Mao led a rural-centric revolution in a country with two social halves. Lenin understood the proletariat better, Mao understood the peasantry better; this is natural. Without understanding the peasantry, one could not argue with Qu Qiubai’s “one blaze to burn the peasant houses” theory; that would be a failure. Therefore, China’s revolution had its own characteristics. China’s revolution could persist for twenty-two years partly due to leaders like Mao who connected with peasants. Mao himself came from a peasant family, although—being a wealthy peasant—he knew the peasants’ lives well.
If there weren’t intellectuals like Mao among the peasantry, why would the CCP place such emphasis on workers and peasants union from the start? Our study of international revolutionary history shows that many worker movements failed due to not integrating with peasants. The CCP did not face this problem; from the beginning it organized peasant associations, and even before the National Revolutionary Movement expanded, peasant associations had already grown to 12 million members, wiping out warlords! If Chen Duxiu had not persisted in rightist opportunist capitulation, using the peasant associations plus the leadership of the workers, China’s revolution could have achieved success in the 1920s. However, immature revolutionary parties and lack of experience required more lessons, so we studied for more than a decade. What was gained was ultimately what fortified our revolutionary path.
Chairman Mao, in a letter to Cai Hesen and other members of the New People’s Study Society, clearly stated: the proletariat must establish its own party to carry out revolution. Because it is the organizer, propagandist, vanguard, and combat unit in the revolutionary movement.
The CCP’s immaturity was not just the problem of one party; it was a global issue. After the success of the October Revolution, communist parties around the world emerged like mushrooms after rain. Lenin promptly established the Communist International as a world Communist command center. So why after the CCP’s founding did there exist a choice between following Lenin’s path or Kautsky’s path? Because Lenin established the Comintern, and the Second International had become rotten. Why did the CCP follow Lenin’s path? Because the great October Socialist Revolution was a model. Who would listen to Kautsky when there was a new model? After the October Revolution, no country’s workers believed in Kautsky. Lenin wrote “Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism” and “What Is to Be Done?” With all the leftist immaturity within the new parties, they often took a leftist path, with anarchist tones, etc. So the CCP was established under this international influence, under Lenin’s vanguard party and the victory of the October Revolution. Its basic line was correct, following the Russian path. But in formulating and implementing policies, errors occurred; it did not continue along Lenin’s line but instead promoted Chen Duxiu to the position of general secretary.
In truth, the CCP’s founding process involved ongoing struggles. At the time, most intellectuals were not highly awakened, so it was impossible to elect Chairman Mao as general secretary outright; Chen Duxiu was elected. In this sense, comparing it to Paris Commune provides a nuance: the Paris Commune’s leadership was two-thirds Blanquists and New Jacobins, with one-third Proudhonists. Yet because the Commune was run by workers, the leadership, even if theoretically incorrect, was corrected by the workers’ actions. The CCP, however, was theoretically correct but its practice deviated from theory more and more. Thus, the greatest danger to the CCP was dogmatism, which we must guard against even today.
When socialism and the workers’ movement are not combined, subjectivism will inevitably arise, and there will be subjective forces that damage revolutionary development. There are two kinds of subjectivism: dogmatism and empiricism. But empiricists are always subservient to dogmatists. So Chairman Mao said: I urge you to read more to avoid being deceived by intellectuals. If you don’t read, you will be deceived.
Look at Qian Renling; wasn’t he deceived? The “China-Mao-Communist” people said: “Students can lead the revolution, go to factories to work and reform themselves, then return to school, study theory, and become professional revolutionaries.” Qian Renling liked this approach. He said, “I want this approach: go to the factory to metallicly gain capital, come back, continue to drink coffee and lead the revolution, continue to be a coffee revolutionary.” Right? Coffee revolutionaries, air-conditioner revolutionaries, sofa revolutionaries, computer revolutionaries.
There are many titles of revolutionaries, but not all truly revolutionary.
Chairman Mao firmly argued that in China we should establish a new-type proletarian revolutionary party guided by Marxist-Leninist principles, following the path of the Russian October Revolution. He pointed out that the party’s worldview must be grounded in dialectical materialism and historical materialism, that the party must follow the path of proletarian revolution and proletarian dictatorship, and that the principles of proletarian internationalism must be upheld. Chairman Mao defended the party-building principles of Marxism-Leninism, representing the correct direction of building the party.
I tell you, studying party history is to guide today’s revolution, which has significant real-world relevance. So don’t fall asleep at study sessions today; what we discuss today is a real problem, very similar to a hundred years ago. Today’s demons and spirits still shout under the banners of Marxism-Leninism: “I am Maoism! You are revisionist! I am Maoism!” It’s all loud. Who doesn’t support Maoism? Everyone supports Maoism. But who is the real Maoism? We are Maoists; they are revisionists. Why? Because we engage in practice, we engage in revolution and practice; they do not. They don’t engage in revolution, they don’t engage in practice. They don’t proletarianize, they do not give up personal interests, they do not give up their intellectual elite status. These people do not follow a practical revolutionary path, they do not give up personal status. In essence, they are not truly revolutionary as declared in The Communist Manifesto: “to rupture completely with all traditional relations of ownership… to rupture completely with all traditional ideas.” They won’t do genuine revolution.
That is the touchstone for true or fake Marxism. Will you rupture completely with traditional property relations? Will you rupture completely with traditional ideas? If you don’t rupture with private ideas, you won’t rupture with intellectuals who stand above the people and with capitalist ownership relations. Then what revolution are you going to undertake? You won’t revolutionize.
The Communist Manifesto states: “The communist revolution is to rupture completely with traditional ownership relations; naturally, in its own development, it must rupture completely with traditional ideas.” Therefore, in today’s situation with so many revisionist factions shouting Maoism, we must always uphold: oppose both empiricism and dogmatism; follow the path of the unity of theory and practice. What did Chairman Mao say? In “Rectification of the Party’s Style” and “Transform Our Learning,” he highlighted three tasks: one is to study history, one is to study Marxism-Leninism, and one is to study theory and the integration of theory and practice. Lenin’s tasks for the youth league also mentioned: what tasks should new revolutionary youth have? Three tasks: absorb the culture of the old humanity, learn to combine theory with practice, and learn communist morality.
Are these three taught equally? Essentially yes; one of them is especially important: the combination of theory with practice. Theory that does not connect to practice is a deceitful thing; it serves certain class interests as a lie.
Why not connect theory with practice? Because the proletariat must connect with practice; without practice there is no revolution. In other words, theory without practice is counterrevolutionary. From the very start, such theory does not serve revolution but serves personal interests.
This is not a question of knowledge but a question of stance. Theory without practice serves personal interests, serves opportunism, serves revisionism. Conversely, practice without theoretical guidance cannot succeed.
Without guidance from theory, practice will be led by dogmatism. People who do not unite practice with theory will follow those who do not unite theory with practice.
Chairman Mao, to build a new-type proletarian revolutionary party in China, did a great deal of propaganda and organization work. In August 1920, Mao founded the Cultural Book Society in Hunan, promoting Marxist-Leninist works and progressive publications nationwide, and, with the New Youth’s outstanding members as the backbone, formed the Russian Studies Society. Since then, the theoretical study and propaganda of Marxism-Leninism entered a more organized and planned stage. Mao not only led members to study Marxism-Leninism but also emphasized tying theory to practice, doing field research, and engaging deeply with workers and peasants. In late 1920, Mao personally conducted social investigations in Pingxiang and six other counties, visited textile factories, locomotive repair shops, flour mills, and other industries’ workers, opened night schools, spread Marxism-Leninism, organized unions, and led workers in strikes. In autumn 1920, Mao established a Communist group in Changsha, and soon established the party’s preparatory unit—the Socialist Youth League. Mao’s early party-building ideas and activities show Mao as an outstanding representative of combining Marxism-Leninism with China’s revolutionary movement, and one of our party’s great founders.
Thus, there are two lines of struggle in the Chinese Communist Party: one spontaneous, one conscious. Chairman Mao represents this conscious line, i.e., the two aspects of the contradiction. We say the CCP was juvenile in its early period in the sense that its main aspects had not fundamentally changed, but we cannot say the CCP had nothing good. Without good, it could not have built the Party. The CCP’s founding had mainly positive significance; its errors were secondary. Without the CCP, Chinese revolution could not have entered the New Democratic stage; without the Party’s leadership, the proletariat could not consciously fight as a class. It’s inevitable to have mistakes because it was immature; through struggle, Mao’s line gradually rose to leadership and gained control.
Before and after, Shanghai, Beijing, Wuhan, Guangzhou, Jinan, and overseas Chinese students in France and Japan also established Communist groups in succession. From then on, the conditions for building a proletarian revolutionary party in China matured. With active help from the Communist International led by Lenin, in July 1921, twelve representatives from local Communist groups, representing over fifty members, attended the First National Congress of the CCP in Shanghai. Great Leader Mao Zedong attended the congress. Also present were Dong Biwu, He Shuheng, Chen Tuanqiu, Wang Jinmei, Deng Enming, and others.
There is no Li Da here; perhaps because Li Da’s issue had not been fully studied at the time, and there were some complex struggles during the Cultural Revolution, so Li Da was not included.
The congress discussed current political tasks, the party’s fundamental tasks, organizational principles, and the leadership body’s issues. While discussing these, Mao opposed the view that the party should be reduced to an academic group merely propagating Marxism-Leninism and waging legal struggle, or the view of opening the door to socialist revolution and excluding revolutionary intellectuals from the party, i.e., “closed-doorism.” He adhered to Marxist-Leninist party-building principles. The congress established that the party must follow Lenin’s Bolshevik model. The congress passed the party constitution, elected the central leadership, and solemnly declared the CCP’s birth. The congress elected Chen Duxiu as general secretary.
Chen Duxiu was a professor at Peking University; he was not a Marxist-Leninist but a bourgeois radical democrat. Chen Duxiu did not truly believe in Marxism; there was always a copy of Karl Marx’s Capital on his desk, but he never read it. He was someone who used the party for personal gain. Chen Duxiu was absent from the First Congress but was still elected general secretary, indicating the intellectuals’ lack of understanding and unchanged stance at that time.
Chen Duxiu did not attend this congress, but because of his role in the May Fourth Movement, editing “New Youth,” and living through the party’s preparatory work, and given the party’s lack of experience in the early stage, he was elected to the central leadership. The CCP’s founding in China holds epoch-making significance in Chinese history. As Chairman Mao said: The founding of the CCP opened a new era in Chinese history. Since the CCP’s founding, the face of China’s revolution has been renewed. This began a new era in Chinese history.
Look at Li Da’s assessment of the situation at the time. In a collection analyzing Li Da’s issues, Li Da’s evaluation of Mao Zedong during Mao’s lifetime is discussed.
And so on, with Li Da’s views: that in the party’s early days, Mao’s leadership, Mao’s high academic achievements, and Mao’s practical leadership in combining with workers and peasants, and Mao’s critical role in guiding the party’s early development. Li Da described Mao’s learning, his constant study of Marxism-Leninism and its Chinese applications, and Mao’s ability to combine theory with China’s practice, turning theory into a practical path for Chinese revolution. Li Da’s remarks included quotes about Mao’s ability to analyze and critique, and his approach to reading and applying works to China’s realities. Li Da’s descriptions highlighted Mao’s distinctive leadership, his foresight, and the way he integrated theory with China’s revolutionary practice. Li Da’s praise for Mao reflects the situation at the time, showing that Mao was a genius in revolutionary leadership. It is thus necessary to recognize his role.
Even the Trotskyists, anarchists, and even liberal democratic flows attacked Lenin and the vanguard party. Their critique of the vanguard party’s leadership relied on the idea that Lenin’s vanguard party was a party of a few professional revolutionaries who commanded all others to follow a few leaders. In short, it was still the Kautsky faction; they argued for a democratic approach to and a dictatorship by the masses. The Communist Party’s organizational principle is democratic centralism: to unite democracy and centralization; to have free and vibrant democratic practices, but also strict revolutionary discipline. So in Lenin’s writings, in Left-Wing Childishness, the greatest problem is that it separates the connections among class, party, and leader. The masses are organized for the class; the party is the vanguard of the class; the leader is the most experienced and capable among party members. Thus, the concepts of the masses, class, leader, and party cannot be separated. Lenin mocked bourgeois democrats for their anti-socialist party dictatorship. They claimed that parliamentary elections in Germany, after many years, still produced the same Li Bachnov—be the same as replacing emperors. This demonstrates that the democratic-centralist organization led by the Communist Party and the discipline of the party is strict and inviolable.
The party’s Second Congress, Mao as the leader, the An-yuan Workers’ Movement
After the party’s founding, it concentrated its efforts on leading the workers’ movement, establishing the Chinese Labor Combination Secretariat, and conducting vigorous anti-imperialist and anti-feudal struggles. The revolutionary practice further required our party to present a clear and concrete revolutionary program and lead the people to fight. In July 1922, the party held its Second National Congress in Shanghai, formally proposing the highest program of establishing the dictatorship of the proletariat and achieving communism; the lowest program was anti-imperialist and anti-feudal democratic revolution. The congress drafted the party program and defeated bourgeois reformist ideas, which was of great significance for the Chinese revolution. However, the congress did not clearly propose that the Chinese democratic revolution should be led by the proletariat, nor did it clearly address armed struggle and the peasant land issue, which showed the CCP’s immaturity.
After the Second Congress, the party strengthened leadership over the workers’ movement further. Starting from the Hong Kong seafarers’ general strike in January 1922, up to the seventh of March 1923 strike at the Wuhan-Han railway, it sparked the first nationwide workers’ movement. More than 100 strikes occurred nationwide, with over 300,000 participants. In this wave, Mao’s leadership of the An-Yuan workers’ movement became a bright banner of the national workers’ movement. An-Yuan Lukuang was a bureaucrat capital enterprise controlled by imperialism; the workers, under imperialism, comprador capitalists, and feudal bosses, faced a miserable situation, and contained enormous revolutionary power. Mao arrived at An-Yuan in the autumn of 1921, went underground with workers, and engaged in heart-to-heart talks. Under Mao’s care, the An-Yuan Party branch was established in February 1922, and the An-Yuan Railway workers’ club was established in May; the workers organized themselves into conscious revolutionary struggles. Capitalists sought to extinguish the struggle by threatening workers and withholding wages; this further spurred workers’ will to fight, and a general strike was on the verge of breaking out.
In this context, there was a fierce struggle between Mao’s revolutionary workers’ movement and Chen Duxiu’s follower Liu Shaoqi’s right-wing surrenderist workers’ movement line.
It should be noted that the An-Yuan workers’ club was organized by Mao, and the An-Yuan general strike was of great historical significance. However, after the founding of the People’s Republic, Liu Shaoqi twisted history, shamelessly claiming that he led the An-Yuan workers’ strike, and even made a film called “Liao Yuan” about it. The protagonist in Liao Yuan is Lei Huanjue, whose name was originally Li Shaoli; this film merges Li Lisan and Liu Shaoqi, promoting Liu Shaoqi. This film is a genuine revisionist movie. Its main theme is to praise the absolute leadership of bourgeois intellectuals in revolution, and to present the Chinese Communist Party as being led by intellectuals detached from the people and workers; portray revolution and proletarian revolution as peaceful strikes; and present intellectuals as elites who stand above the people and lead peaceful strikes. This is an extremely reactionary form of white-collar bureaucratism and revisionism.
Thus today’s leftists are very fond of Liao Yuan. Why? Because the film’s plot features exactly the kind of detaching from the people, sipping coffee while making revolution, wearing long robes, and turning to the people to lift their fists for support. This is their ideal. In the film, An-Yuan railway workers are living in dire conditions; a gas leak and a mine explosion occur at the mine, causing many deaths. At this critical moment, Lei Huanjue—the Liu Shaoqi character—arrives. He first tells the workers to strike. The workers say they cannot, because the capitalists are too strong; they claim the word “gong” (labor) is too dangerous to utter. Then Liu Shaoqi—Lei Huanjue—explicitly argues that the word “gong” is big, reaching for the heavens, and that the two characters together form the character for “heaven.” One hundred years later, in that sleepy era, this depiction is used to mislead. This is a vicious depiction of attacking workers’ understanding of class struggle, and even their grasp of economic struggle; instead, intellectuals who do not labor are taught by them about exploitation.
In this film, what is Lei Huanjue’s image? He is a very clean-faced young man, with not a speck of dust, wearing robes, guiding workers. The first act features a chalkboard reading “Workers,” and when the two characters join, it forms the character for “heaven.” He tells the workers they are uneducated; he shows his high cultural level. In the second scene, when workers complain about low wages during meals, Lei Huanjue lectures that “you don’t understand; this is exploitation.” They even smear the workers as ignorant of exploitation, and require a cultured intellectual like Li Shaoyi to teach them.
In the book, the most reactionary scene is negotiating with capitalists peacefully, promoting a peaceful transition and class reconciliation. When the workers’ general strike was about to erupt, Liu Shaoqi claimed the movement was too radical, that “two fists cannot defeat four hands,” that the other side had guns and cannons, and that violent revolution could not succeed; thus he proposed peace strikes, civilized strikes. The film is like this as well: Lei Huanjue proposes civilized strikes and the creation of the An-Yuan railway workers’ club. The film credits Liu Shaoqi with establishing the workers’ club and shamelessly shows him advocating the slogan “Vent feelings, cultivate virtue” and the club’s purpose being to cultivate bias and virtue rather than to fight with capitalists. In other words, it teaches the workers to “build relations” and “cultivate virtue” so as not to oppose capitalists. This is an outright misrepresentation.
How does the film depict the strike’s victory? Lei Huanjue goes to the capitalists’ mansion alone to negotiate. The capitalists, under pressure from Lei Huanjue, finally agree to the strike conditions. After Lei Huanjue’s successful negotiation, the workers’ chorus resounds outside the mansion: “We are not beasts, we are humans, brothers, wake up.” Then a contrived scene appears in which workers rush out of the mine, singing, while Lei Huanjue stands with his back to the capitalists, looking pleased. Is this not the dream of leftists—a useless, coffee-drinking intellectual person who pretends to be revolutionary? If one actually follows that path, one would have long since lost one’s head, and not be revolutionary at all.
In September 1922, Mao returned to An-Yuan to investigate the workers’ struggles, carefully analyze the favorable revolutionary situation, and make decisive, wise decisions to lead a massive strike. He insisted that the strike’s aim was not only to increase wages or shorten working hours, but to raise workers’ political consciousness and advance toward the complete liberation of the entire class; to encourage workers to unite and fight. The An-Yuan workers began their large strike on September 14 with the slogan “From cattle and horses to people.” At this time, the traitor Liu Shaoqi disobeyed Mao’s revolutionary workers’ movement line and attempted to sabotage the large strike. Before the strike, he cursed the strike as reckless; after the strike broke out, he raised the banners of “civilized strike,” and demanded workers to be more civilized than usual, “return to their homes,” to suppress the massive strike. When he saw the strike could not be eliminated, he asked capitalists to negotiate. Initially, he was only seeking a reduction of working hours and improved benefits, and attempted to sell out workers for personal gain.
Why did Liu Shaoqi act this way? He had long been a betrayer and a traitor. Liu Shaoqi joined the party as a member of the exploiting class’s intellectuals who were strongly anti-people and who loathed labor; after joining the party, he refused to proletarianize (as Qian Renling preferred) and insisted on maintaining his separatist, comfortable status, living a parasitic exploiting life. To implement this life, he continued to order crowds as an intellectual figure, ruling over them, and, in order to preserve his own power and personal profit, suppressed strikes and used revolutionary interests to serve personal interests. He attempted to convert the workers’ struggle into his personal gains so that he could reap benefits when negotiating with capitalists, pleasing both sides, and prospering. Therefore, Liu Shaoqi betrayed early on. In the twenties, when he was captured by reactionaries, he betrayed the country and was a traitor; he secretly surrendered, becoming a shameful traitor, and jumped into the Chinese party and government high ranks after the revolution, where he collaborated with reactionary warlords and the Kuomintang. He publicly surrendered to the Nationalist Government. Liu Shaoqi’s traitorous history is long; as early as before the First National Congress, he betrayed. Later, he was responsible for white-area work. In reality, “white area work” did not require violent struggles or risking life. Of course, white areas also carry risk; his traitor status carried no risk. Thus, under Liu Shaoqi’s leadership, a large number of people all became traitors, signing confessions and pledging not to participate in communist movements again. Later, these people climbed to high positions in the Chinese Party and government and lived in the high life. They could endure this to be able to implement the Revolution in the 20s and to walk on Tiananmen Gate later, saying “I am pleased.”
Under Mao’s revolutionary line, An-Yuan workers did not fear the reactionaries’ crackdown, nor did they fall for worker traitors’ deception. They fought bravely and tenaciously, ultimately achieving the great victory of the strike. The victory at An-Yuan was the result of Mao’s leadership and the success of Mao’s revolutionary line. The traitor Liu Shaoqi, who boasted of leading the An-Yuan workers’ movement, attempted to distort history and deceive people. In February 1923, the京汉 Railway workers in Zhengzhou established a general union; on February 4, the entire 京汉 Railway workers went on strike after Wu Peifu’s illegal ban. On February 7, the strike was violently suppressed: over 40 dead, over 300 injured, dozens arrested, over 1,000 dismissed. The leaders Lin Xiangqian and Shi Yang sacrificed themselves honorably. Lin Xiangqian, when captured, refused to order a return to work under duress, shouting that “the head may be cut, but workers cannot be forced back!” He died with fury and heroism, showing the revolutionary spirit of communist cadres. Afterwards, the workers’ movement suffered a severe blow, and the national workers’ movement temporarily declined.
However, in the vigorous strike wave, the Chinese working class and its vanguard were tested and refined. Revolutionary practice showed that in semi-colonial, semi-feudal China, to achieve revolution, the proletariat alone cannot win; it must unite with all possible classes and strata and organize a broad revolutionary united front based on the worker-peasant alliance to seize the revolution.
Now, the Q&A segment: Why do the capitalists want to purge Li Da? The Cultural Revolution was a life-or-death class struggle. Shouldn’t these enemies purge their own enemies? If not, the proletariat will purge the bourgeois and the bourgeois purge the proletariat. The Cultural Revolution is to purge the capitalist class’s power and status that the running capitalists had seized. Would they be willing to purge? If they take such high positions and enjoy so much surplus value, they will kill you if you purge them. Why purge? Because as a capitalist running the country, they use capitalist law to serve personal interests and attempt to restore capitalism. If you oppose them, you prevent them from becoming officials; you prevent them from restoring capitalism; you prevent them from grabbing surplus value. So they will purge you. We don’t even have party-building yet, no revolutionary power yet; criticizing bourgeois law power will provoke resistance. We must purge people like Qian Renling who come with serious personal ambition to join our activities; aren’t we already against them? Another question: why wasn’t Liu Shaoqi unmasked before the founding of New China? How to unmask? Are you a prophet? Predicting Liu Shaoqi would betray would not help. Any line problem is only discovered and solved after the actual error is exposed. You can’t unmask in advance; you can’t know the contradiction before it reveals itself. It is a historical idealism question to say that a traitor could be foreseen. What about the question: “Why did the CCP’s First National Congress not propose that democratic revolution be led by the proletariat? It did not resolve armed struggle and peasant issues clearly.” The main reason is intellectuals did not understand. If they did not understand, how could they propose it? Democratic revolution led by the proletariat; if they had not united with the proletariat, how would they know? They thought the revolution would be led by intellectuals, and by Chen Duxiu; then Chen Duxiu pointed to Chiang Kai-shek’s leadership. Why didn’t it clearly resolve armed struggle and peasants’ land issues? They did not understand Marxism. Like Li Da said, many comrades appeared to understand surplus-value theory and historical materialism superficially, but could not apply them to China’s problems. They had no real revolutionary experience and did not understand China’s actual revolutionary conditions.
You all know that China’s dual social structure, feudal economic basis, warlord factional fighting, anti-revolutionary forces, unequal distribution, and unbalanced political economy made it possible to establish a rural revolutionary base areas. They did not know then. Today, isn’t what we know recorded in past books? Then you go back in time and you would know? You don’t know. We must solve the peasant land problem, must conduct armed struggle; all this was learned through revolution’s practice under the conditions of that era.
Why hold the first National Congress in Shanghai? First, Shanghai had the highest concentration of industrial workers. Shanghai was the place with the most concentrated industrial workers as well as the most developed capitalism; communism itself emerged from capitalism.
Why did only Chairman Mao achieve the combination of theory and practice? That’s because everyone’s world view differs. Mao’s life trajectory was forged in revolutionary struggles, shaping his revolutionary world view and refining it through practice. For Mao, there is the necessity for the party to have sacrifice spirit not for personal fame or wealth but for the revolution’s future and class interests; thus he is bound to connect theory with practice. Didn’t I just say this? I have already argued this from the opposite side. Theory detached from practice serves personal interests; otherwise it cannot be detached. Theory detached from practice becomes opportunism or revisionism. Why must theory detach from practice? For the proletariat, theory must connect to practice in order to make revolution succeed. In other words, theory without practice is anti-revolutionary. From the outset, such theory serves personal interests.
Was Qian Renling always present during lectures? He was there from the start? Then why didn’t he react? I denounce Qian Renling’s worship of “China-Mao-Communist” and his unwillingness to give up the bourgeois intellectuals’ status, wanting to depart from the people and serve personal interests. When the leftists were present, why didn’t you respond? Why not respond?
I advise Qian Renling not to pursue individualism or anarchism, to accept the leadership of the proletarian dictatorship, to accept the authority of the proletariat, and not to serve personal interests by constantly boasting. Do not become a reactionary, labor-averse intellectual detached from the people.
The “two-hearted” faction is also insane to become a “revolutionary” who benefits personally through wealth. They want to work less and get more money, exploiting others’ intellectuals. I urge Qian Renling and the “two-hearted group” to discard this kind of self-serving ambition for revolution, not dream of being a “coffee-revolutionary” who sips coffee and stirs revolution. If you want revolution, you must proletarianize and discard all capital, including knowledge and credentials. The old society’s knowledge existed to serve the bourgeoisie to divide surplus value. You must discard ownership of knowledge.
Qian Renling, stop touting that “China-Mao-Communist” nonsense, stop praising that group, thinking you have found a few good lines and can rise with their help. There is nothing useful here. Qian Renling loves “China-Mao-Communist” because that group is inherently like this.
Summary of RedGPT
“History of the Two-Line Struggle of the Chinese Communist Party”
Chapter One, Section One, Part Two — Analysis and Systematic Summary
I. The main theme of this section: The party-building route is not a formal issue, but a class route issue
The core point repeatedly emphasized in this section is:
How the Chinese Communist Party was founded from the very beginning was a struggle between two lines, not a technical, procedural, or experiential issue.
The fundamental disagreement between these two lines is:
- Whether it is the proletariat’s conscious party-building route
- Or the petty bourgeois intellectual spontaneous, opportunistic, parasitic party-building route
This section does not discuss “party-building historical materials,” but answers a more acute question:
Why did the Chinese Communist Party pay a huge price in the first 14 years? Where did these costs come from? Are they accidental?
II. The background of world history: Why did scientific socialism emerge in Germany, not in Britain or France
1. The class limitations of utopian socialism
You first clearly distinguish three things:
- Utopian socialism originated in Britain and France
- It has progressive content, but is not scientific socialism
- The fundamental reason lies in: the stance is that of intellectuals and petty bourgeoisie
The problem with utopian socialism is not about “kindness,” but about:
- Cannot stand on the proletarian stance
- Cannot propose a realistic path from capitalism to communism
- Can only “criticize,” but cannot “lead the revolution”
2. The rise of the bourgeoisie in Britain and France → Rapidly reactionary theory
You point out a key historical turning point:
- 1830, the French financial bourgeoisie comes to power
- 1832, the British industrial bourgeoisie completes its dominance
The result is:
- The bourgeoisie no longer revolutionizes
- Classical political economy quickly degenerates into vulgar economics
- The bourgeoisie shifts from “anti-feudal” to “anti-proletariat”
But at the same time:
- Workers, peasants, students still engage in revolution
- The revolutionary task shifts to the proletariat
3. The particularity of Germany: The soil for scientific socialism
You emphasize that Germany possesses three decisive conditions:
- The working class is under double oppression
- Capitalists
- Junker aristocrats
- The workers’ movement is more thorough
- The Silesian textile workers’ uprising initially called for abolition of private ownership
- Concentrated inheritance of theoretical resources
- British and French classical political economy
- The rational core of utopian socialism
- German dialectics and materialism
Under these conditions, Marx and Engels:
- Did not “create new theories”
- But revolutionarily transform old theories
- Unified philosophy, political economy, and socialism into Marxism
III. The Communist Party was not “naturally formed,” but established through struggle
1. The German Communist Party: Theoretical and practical struggles
You clearly state:
- The German Communist Party was not “formed in one moment”
- Instead, it was formed through:
- Repeated struggles against
- Proudhonism
- Petty bourgeois socialism
- Bourgeois socialism
- Utopian socialism
- The transformation from “League of Justice” to “Communist League” was not just a name change, but a line shift.
- Repeated struggles against
2. The conditions for the maturity of Lenin’s line in the Russian Bolsheviks
You especially compare the historical conditions of Lenin and Mao:
- Lenin:
- Long-term revolutionary practice
- Already had high prestige before founding the party
- Repeated victories in theoretical struggles
- Able to directly establish the vanguard principle at the founding of the party
- Russia:
- Early development of capitalism
- Long history of the workers’ movement
- Repeated struggles by populists and reformists
Therefore, the Bolsheviks’ success was not “accidental,” but the result of mature historical conditions.
IV. The fundamental characteristics and issues of the founding of the Chinese Communist Party
1. The “innate deficiencies” of China’s party-building
You clearly point out three practical features of China’s party-building:
- Marxism was mainly imported from abroad
- Intellectuals had not completed proletarianization
- The integration with workers and peasants was extremely insufficient
The problem is not “importing Marxism,” but:
After import, it was used as “capital” by petty bourgeois intellectuals.
2. The fundamental reason for the losses in the first 14 years
You state the issue very straightforwardly:
- A group of intellectuals and ambitious people:
- Detached from labor
- Detached from the masses
- Deceiving for power with “advanced,” “theoretical,” and “identity” claims
- They treat:
- The Party → as a stepping stone
- The revolution → as personal capital
- Theory → as a tool for power
Therefore, opportunism is not accidental but an inevitable expression of class stance.
V. Mao’s line vs opportunism: where is the fundamental difference?
1. Proletarianization is the watershed of the line
You repeatedly emphasize:
- Revolutionary intellectuals must proletarianize
- Proletarianization is not just a slogan but involves:
- Combining with workers and peasants
- Giving up intellectual privileges
- Abandoning a sense of superiority
Using examples of dressing, labor, and lifestyle, you illustrate:
Class stance is not spoken, but reflected in life.
2. Mao’s uniqueness is not “innate,” but a choice of line
You clearly state:
- Mao was not a “naturally great man”
- Instead:
- Long-term deep involvement with workers and peasants
- Investigation and research
- Connecting theory with practice
- Forging worldview in revolutionary practice
Therefore:
Mao’s prestige was built in struggle, not “elected.”
VI. Why was choosing Chen Duxiu at the First Congress of CCP a historical inevitability?
You do not explain with “morality,” but with line and conditions:
- At that time, most intellectuals:
- Worshiped fame
- Worshiped cultural capital
- Worshiped “new cultural leaders”
- Mao:
- Had more practice than fame
- Theories were still developing
- Prestige had not yet been established
Thus, choosing Chen Duxiu was not “accidental error,” but an inevitable result of unshifted class stance.
VII. Correct theory vs. practical errors: the early contradictions of the CCP
You present a very important judgment:
The Chinese Communist Party was not “theoretically wrong,” but “deviated from theory in practice.”
This leads to:
- Dogmatism becoming the greatest danger
- Theories detaching from practice
- The revolutionary line constantly drifting
You clearly state:
- Theories that do not connect with reality
→ Will serve personal or small group interests - This is a stance issue, not an epistemological one
VIII. The May 1st Work Movement: a positive confrontation of two lines of labor movement
1. Mao’s labor movement line
Core features:
- Insisting on strikes
- Raising political consciousness
- Elevating economic struggles to class struggle
- Organizing the masses, not negotiating on their behalf
2. The essence of Liu Shaoqi’s line
You sharply define Liu Shaoqi’s line:
- Opposes large-scale strikes
- Advocates “civilized strikes”
- Negotiates “peacefully” with capitalists
- Turns the achievements of mass struggle into personal capital
You point out:
This is a typical strikebreaker, capitulationist, and bureaucratic route.
3. The political essence of “Liao Yuan”
You characterize “Liao Yuan” as:
- Revisionist black film
- Glorifies intellectual leadership
- Demeans the consciousness of the working class
- Advocates class reconciliation and peaceful reform
And you note that it precisely caters to contemporary left petty bourgeois fantasies.
IX. From the peak of the labor movement to the united front: historical lessons
You point out:
- The labor movement peak was heroic
- But the proletariat fighting alone is insufficient for victory
- Must:
- Form worker-peasant alliances
- Build broad united fronts
- Engage in armed struggle
These insights are not a priori, but gained through bloody lessons.
X. Methodological summary: how to view history and the struggle of lines
1. Oppose apriorism and fatalism
You clearly oppose:
- The historical idealism of “if only we had caught the traitors earlier”
- The idea that line problems only expose themselves in practice and are solved in struggle
2. The only standard for theory and practice
You repeatedly emphasize one judgment criterion:
Whether willing to break completely with old ownership and old ideas.
This is the touchstone for:
- True Marxism
- Fake Marxism
- Revolutionaries
- Opportunists
XI. Practical orientation: today’s line struggle is not over
You finally connect history directly to reality:
- Today, there are still:
- “Coffee revolutionaries”
- “Air-conditioner revolutionaries”
- “Knowledge monetization leftists”
- They:
- Do not proletarianize
- Do not practice
- Do not give up personal interests
- But shout the most “revolutionary” slogans
Your conclusion is:
Line struggle is not a historical issue, but a current issue.
Final summary in one sentence
The core of this section is not “reviewing history,” but exposing an eternal law through the history of party-building:
As long as revolution exists, petty bourgeois opportunism will exist;
Only by insisting on proletarianization and linking theory with practice can the revolutionary party avoid degeneration.
This seems to have been put on hold for quite a while.
