Whose fault is it when someone vomits blood at the annual meeting banquet?

Recently, in Ningbo, Zhejiang, a 25-year-old new employee who had just started working at a certain unit was at the annual meeting’s banquet table. He was persuaded to drink by his unit’s leader and was forced to drink an entire bottle of red wine; it is reported that this employee usually does not drink alcohol. Shortly after being forced to drink a whole bottle of red wine that day, he felt unwell, vomited violently, and bled. Fortunately, he was rescued in time, so his life was not in danger.


In response, some netizens said that this employee was persuaded to drink by others and did so for face, but is that really the case?
In fact, “In bourgeois society, capital has independence and personality, while living individuals have neither independence nor personality.” 【1】 As an employee of the unit, the relationship between this worker and the persuading leader is a manifestation of the capitalist economic relationship acting on specific individuals, which is a relationship of dependence and subjugation, oppression and being oppressed. In reality, the employee has no real choice; it is the leaders and the bourgeoisie relying on their dominant social class position to select their subordinates—those who will not disturb their peace, who are obedient and willing to be exploited and manipulated by them. Persuading to drink is exactly like this: if the other party refuses, then in the eyes of these high-and-mighty masters, it is a matter of not giving face, not obeying them, not recognizing their authority as the rulers, and not following the social hierarchy. Only employees like the one in this news, even if they usually do not drink, must drink because the leaders and colleagues “offer” it—that is the most in line with the order of capitalist society.
Furthermore, in what era would it be the case that during gatherings, one cannot refuse to drink when offered? Of course, it is the capitalist era! The incident reflected in this news has already become a social custom in Chinese society—a culture of drinking tables. It is not just about refusing to drink when offered; even how to sit during gatherings depends on the social status and identity of the participants, with distinctions of upper and lower seats, creating a hierarchy of ranks.


What are these seat distinctions based on? Whom do they refer to? They refer to the ancient Chinese rules, to the old etiquette of the ancients; they refer to China’s past feudal society, to the exploitative classes of that society!

It is clear that this kind of culture is nothing more than feudal remnants of Confucian ritual culture! Why does it still appear in today’s Chinese capitalist society? Because the social foundation that maintains the exploitative class’s hierarchy—this old culture—is still present. The unequal relationships and statuses between people in capitalist society have not disappeared with the demise of feudalism. Therefore, some people’s belief that “since young people generally dislike drinking, the drinking culture will automatically fade away with the older generation’s passing” is fundamentally unfounded. “…One of my illusions has been shattered. I have always been optimistic, thinking that the oppression and killing of youth are mostly done by the elderly. But now I realize that it is not the elderly, but the youth who are killing the youth…” 【2】 Ultimately, as long as capitalism and exploitation persist, and the class society remains, the unequal relationships and statuses among people will continue, and the drinking table culture will not disappear!
This is the evil consequence of capitalism!

References:
【1】 “The Communist Manifesto” 1972 reprint edition, page 39, People’s Liberation Army Publishing House
【2】 “Selected Essays and Letters of Lu Xun,” 1972 edition, page 71

19 Likes

They completely do not treat workers as human beings

4 Likes

How have the recent mountain conditions been? It seems like I haven’t seen you come out much.

Just saw this. I won’t be online for the time being. It should be back to normal next month or so. I’ll post something about the mental struggle I’ve been going through during this period. A lot has happened over the past few months.

It sounds more like feudal social customs, but it indeed aligns with the need to uphold the oppressive position of the exploiting class under capitalist society. “In bourgeois society, capital possesses independence and individuality, while living individuals lack independence and individuality,” so even if it is a feudal social custom, as long as it conforms to the needs of modern capitalist society, it will naturally be used again to maintain the capitalist exploitation system, thereby taking on capitalist characteristics. Honestly, I often get confused about the terminology when criticizing, because many things look feudal at first glance, but now they are being labeled as capitalist. Comrades here should understand this, but outside of this context, I am again unsure how to use precise wording that can persuade everyone.

1 Like

Why are things from the feudal society “being classified as capitalist things” now? It is precisely because a social formation, once established, does not instantly eliminate all elements of the old system, but instead absorbs, transforms, and reuses the social relations and ideologies left over from the old era based on new production relations. “People create their own history, but not in arbitrary ways; they create it under given conditions inherited from the past.” (Marx, The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte) Any new social system inevitably inherits the historical materials of the old society, and these materials are given new social functions on the basis of the new economic foundation. Therefore, some concepts or forms that appear “feudal” may, if incorporated into capitalist production relations and serving the reproduction of capital, no longer belong to the feudal system in social nature, but become part of the structure of capitalist society. Capitalism is not produced under “pure conditions,” but develops on the residual soil of the old system and will long utilize these remnants to maintain its rule. Therefore, from a materialist historical perspective, the key to judging the social nature of a phenomenon is not its historical origin or superficial form, but its role in real production relations. Drinking culture objectively maintains the social structure of capitalism; even if its form originates from the feudal era, it is not a simple continuation of the feudal system but a “product of capitalism.” This is why feudal residuals can exist long-term within capitalist society and are part of the capitalist social structure.

13 Likes

I understand. Although the wine-drinking culture originates from feudal society, since today’s society is capitalist and has no remnants of feudal relations of production, after being transformed by capitalism, this thing no longer has feudal characteristics, but is entirely a capitalist thing.

What is the social basis for opinions like “Post-00s reform drinking culture,” “Post-00s reform workplace,” “Post-00s raising children,” which equate youth with anti-oppression and progress, and why do these views spread?

1 Like

这种“00后整顿XXXX”的言论,在哲学方面实际上是庸俗进化论。这种观点认为事物的发展没有质变、没有飞跃,只要随着时间的推移,一切都会好起来的。“00后整顿XXXX”就是经典的庸俗进化论,看起来很革命,“整顿”不合理现象,但实际上根本没有触及人压迫人的资本主义制度。个别人“整顿了”之后,这个社会并没有发生什么改变,资本主义还是依旧如故,甚至更加残酷了。归根结底,这种“整顿”只不过是一种个人主义的无政府主义的反抗。而指望这种东西能改变社会,那就是彻头彻尾的改良主义幻想。实际上,世道并不会因为年轻人代替了老一辈,就“好了”。意识形态是具有相对独立性的。在帝国主义日益腐朽的今天,我们看到的是年轻一代的分化和对立,是各个阶级的矛盾冲突激化了,是小资产阶级分化成了彻底反动的一派和决心走向革命的一派。现在,最喜欢进行残酷的压迫的,利用政权、父权、夫权迫害他人的,恰恰就是所谓的“年轻一代”。越是年轻,过去的历史对他的影响越小,现在的腐朽的帝国主义文化在他们身上表现得越多。 所以说,世道不仅没有因为年轻人代替了老一辈,就“好了”,而是越来越坏。过去鲁迅也曾经相信过庸俗进化论。但是,当他看见四一二和七一五反革命政变中,疯狂屠杀共产党人的都是年轻人之后,他就彻底抛弃了庸俗进化论,走上了马克思主义的道路。乱极则治,闇极则光,天之道也!但是,由乱到治,由闇到光,这个矛盾着的双方的地位转化,需要一个条件。那就是革命!革命是主观能动的行为,是千百万革命人民创造出来的,不是等来的。

13 Likes

In fact, most of the so-called “Post-00s rectifying the workplace” are actually acts of anarchistic rebellion against bosses or supervisors, such as insulting, smashing things, or playing manipulative tricks. Doing so will definitely cause oneself to lose their job, and it’s hard to say how effective it really is. Generally, it’s students who are just starting their careers who prefer this approach, because they used to enjoy “freedom” as students. Once they enter the workforce and are subjected to the discipline of money, they no longer feel “free,” which can lead to a petty bourgeois mentality of bankruptcy, evading wage labor, and using anarchistic methods to oppose work discipline. In the end, they are bound to be fired. However, most of the people making videos are wealthy and powerful, or even directly capitalists or bourgeois workers (if it’s a script). If in reality someone really dared to do this, and didn’t care about getting fired, it only shows that they are not proletarians and do not need to rely on wage labor to survive, which is why they don’t mind losing their job.

6 Likes

Why do many people prefer to believe that young people will change the world, but not believe that only revolution can change the world?
Because they do not understand the method of class analysis. They only see the age difference in the conflict between opposing sides, but do not see that what actually determines their different worldviews is the class difference, not the age difference.
The different lifestyles are determined by age; the elderly have their way of life, and the young have theirs. This is actually a super-class perspective.
What determines a person’s lifestyle is their class position.
Elderly capitalists and young capitalists may have different hobbies, but all their hobbies are based on exploiting others, so their hobbies are quite similar—nothing more than luxury waste and parasitic enjoyment.
Elderly workers and young workers may also have different hobbies, but their hobbies are based on relying on their own labor for survival, so they cannot indulge in luxury waste or parasitic enjoyment.
Ultimately, the reason why people believe in vulgar evolutionism and think that age determines different lifestyles is because of petty-bourgeois worldview.
Because petty-bourgeois life is very narrow; in their daily experience, they only see differences in age, gender, and region. They do not see the difference in production relations, nor do they see class opposition.
What Marxists need to do is to view all social phenomena from the perspective of historical materialism and analyze the relationships between different classes.
Therefore, studying theory is very important. Those who think that learning theory is unnecessary for everyday shopping and cooking should be careful. Those who belittle philosophy will become slaves to the worst philosophy.

13 Likes

Many shop managers at milk tea shops nowadays are even born after 2005. These managers are often more reactionary and more despicable. I previously worked at a milk tea shop and voluntarily resigned because I didn’t want to sign a contract like a slave contract. This post-2005 dog manager is very active in acting as a lackey; she was rewarded with 500 yuan by the capitalists for her proper handling of the “labor dispute” (referring to insisting on not paying me a single cent of wages), while I didn’t receive a single yuan in wages myself.

12 Likes