On the issue of “student proletarianization” in the “Forum of Liberation Struggle”

Recently, I learned that a considerable number of members in the „Liberation Struggle Forum“ have been inciting and encouraging students to abandon the „bourgeois academy“, that is, to give up their secular studies, including concrete acts such as dropping out of school and giving up the middle school entrance exam and the college entrance exam. In my view, this is extremely irresponsible and extremely childish.

Looking at modern history, we can see that revolutionary mentors such as Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin, and Mao all came out of the „bourgeois academy“. I want to make my position clear: I do not support bourgeois education. On the contrary, I have personally felt its deep pain and oppose it. I do not intend here to beautify or glorify the „bourgeois academy“; I am merely discussing it. (Strictly speaking, Stalin was educated in a feudal academy, and Mao was educated in a semi-bourgeois, semi-feudal academy.)

So why did revolutionary mentors emerge from the „bourgeois academy“? First, at that time the feudal and bourgeois forces monopolized education, and all advanced knowledge was controlled by feudal and bourgeois educational authorities. The petty bourgeoisie at that time, including the mentors, came into contact with and mastered this knowledge. Combined with the special historical environment and economic foundation of the time, under the impetus of history they united with workers and peasants, united with social practice, and became the vanguard of the proletariat. Looking at the present in light of this, it is reasonable to call current education bourgeois education, because the feudal and bourgeois classes have once again occupied the superstructure. Chinese revolutionaries are now facing a situation similar to that of the revolutionaries of the past, so our country’s revolutionaries must fully study the thought and spirit of revolutionary mentors, and, like the mentors of that era, arm themselves with knowledge rather than abandoning their studies to engage in that kind of reckless and blind „proletarianization“. That would only drive the proletariat deeper into a state of bondage and confinement, causing it to lose one group of its intellectuals and vanguards after another, which would harm the revolutionary cause rather than benefit it. As Stalin said, if the working class cannot free itself from a lack of culture, if it cannot cultivate its own intellectuals, if it does not master science and is not good at managing the economy according to scientific principles, then it cannot truly become the master of the country.

Second, in the old society, the contradictions between the old and new forces in the „bourgeois academy“ became increasingly obvious and intense. In this tearing apart and struggle, and with the mentors’ social practice added to it, they gradually groped out a road to human liberation. The present situation of revolutionaries is very similar to that time. Right now, the conflict in schools between reactionary and progressive teachers and students, and between reactionary and progressive ideas, is intensifying continuously. Those places are precisely the breeding ground for revolutionary ideas, and also a very important cultural front. Seizing the schools is an important link in persisting in continuing the revolution under the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie.

Through the above discussion, I have briefly explained why revolutionaries must not abandon education, and as for what should be done, I will also touch on it here, though not completely.

First, study hard. As mentioned earlier, learning and mastering those knowledge and skills in the „bourgeois academy“ is an important means of breaking the educational monopoly and achieving personal development. In particular, advanced knowledge and technology: the more knowledge that is monopolized and constrained by the feudal and bourgeois forces, the more it must be studied, and the more this state must be broken so that it becomes a sharp weapon for proletarian revolution. Of course, it is not only this; students must also study Marxism-Leninism, struggle through study, and use study as struggle, transforming old knowledge with Marxism.

Second, combine production with study. Here, „production“ refers to productive labor, and it can also be understood as social practice. Mao Zedong once said that book knowledge, if it is not combined with social practice, is incomplete knowledge. This statement precisely points out the importance of social practice: if students do not go deeply among workers and peasants, and do not engage with society, they are destined to be alienated within the „bourgeois academy“ into intellectuals serving the exploiting class. Therefore, this is an extremely important policy that must never be abandoned; it is an important means of ensuring the revolutionary nature of intellectuals.

Finally, I hope that revolutionaries can clearly recognize what exactly is petty-bourgeois wrong thinking, and what exactly is the correct path. Only by persisting in the Marxist-Leninist-Maoist revolutionary line can victory be achieved.

3 Likes

That claim does not match the actual facts.

Although Marx had a doctorate, when he was about to go to university to become a professor, he chose instead to join the editorial staff of the Rheinische Zeitung and criticize Prussia. After that, he never really made use of that degree to gain anything, and he lived in poverty and hardship until the First International was founded, when his situation finally improved.

Engels did not even finish middle school before his capitalist father dragged him off to work and exploited him mercilessly. He only had a primary school education.

Lenin dropped out of university midway to pursue the revolution. Later, after taking part in revolutionary activities, he obtained a qualification and worked as a trainee lawyer, helping workers and peasants carry out legal struggles against capitalists and landlords.

Stalin did not finish high school.

As for Chairman Mao, although he did go to university, he went to school in order to save the country (and at that time he was not yet a Marxist). Later, at school, he organized the New People’s Study Society, helped the working people fight through strikes, and organized the study of Marxism.

27 Likes

I have never thought that revolutionaries study at institutions of higher learning in order to gain some benefit through their class privileges, and I have also said in my article that schools are an important front, and revolutionaries should seize this front. I think this does not go against the original intention of the mentors when they went to school. The expression „come out“ is very imprecise; that is my mistake.

1 Like

Indeed, the school is an important battleground, but the real purpose of seizing this battleground should be to lead students within the school to fight against the capitalist school system and oppression, rather than to have the majority of students conform to the laws of capitalist education and pursue further schooling in order to become highly educated intellectuals.
In addition, you say that revolutionaries study in bourgeois schools not in order to obtain special status.
This point is also complete nonsense. Today’s bourgeois schools have already completely degenerated into an Inquisition that suppresses the children of the proletariat and a hotbed for cultivating countless parasitic intellectuals with privileges.
In such circumstances, what revolutionaries should truly do is unite the students who dare to struggle and fight against the bourgeois education system, and persuade students with petty-bourgeois tendencies to abandon the idea of conforming to the bourgeois education system in order to make a personal fortune. They should combine with the broad masses of working people and engage in revolutionary struggle.

2 Likes

You should first introduce yourself according to the forum rules and regulations
https://www.mlzyws.com/t/topic/178

11 Likes

Obviously, the bourgeoisie will not hand over the real stuff to us petty bourgeoisie; what they give us is all detached dogma. You should be able to relate, because these things are too dogmatic, which is why many people forget everything once they finish school

7 Likes

This post might be helpful to you

I agree with the points in the post, but I failed to point out in the article that this was my issue. It’s a very insightful point, and one must be cautious when learning and applying knowledge.

1 Like

So what you really mean is that I should take a look at the rebuttal to this post? I’ll go and read it, and I really appreciate you giving me this learning opportunity.

1 Like

Do you really understand what the schools of the bourgeoisie teach? When exposing the essence of bourgeois education, Lenin pointed out: „The whole old school was permeated with class spirit, and allowed only the children of the bourgeoisie to acquire knowledge. The young generation of workers and peasants in such schools was, rather than being educated, being bourgeoisified and enslaved. The purpose of educating these youths was to train servants useful to the bourgeoisie, people who could create profits for the bourgeoisie without disturbing its peace.“
And what kind of people are today’s university and graduate students? They spend all day eating, drinking, and having fun, with their heads full of filthy smut. Are these the intellectuals the proletariat needs?

15 Likes

Of course, revolution does not need these intellectuals, nor does it need dogmatic knowledge, but that does not mean knowledge should be completely abandoned. Lenin once pointed out: „If you try to draw the conclusion from (criticizing the old school) that one can become a Communist without mastering the knowledge accumulated by humanity, then you are making a very big mistake. The old school poured out a great deal of distorted, useless knowledge and carried out an education of servility, and this is something we must criticize; but we cannot therefore refuse to inherit all the achievements of human civilization.“

The quote you’re using doesn’t seem to be something Lenin said — it sounds like something AI came up with. Just a heads-up: the original passage is: “The old school is a school of rote learning; it forces people to learn a great mass of useless, cumbersome, dead knowledge. This kind of knowledge fills the minds of the younger generation and turns them into officials cast from the same mold. But if you try to draw the conclusion from this that one can become a communist without mastering the knowledge accumulated by mankind, then you are making a very grave mistake. If you think it is unnecessary to grasp all the knowledge through which communism itself came into being, and that it is enough merely to grasp the slogans of communism and the conclusions of communist science, then that is wrong. Communism emerged from the totality of human knowledge, and Marxism is the model in this respect.” It doesn’t seem to say that knowledge has to be learned in the old school, and isn’t this passage in fact a sharp critique of the old school? Trying to use this quote to defend the old school is honestly not very convincing.

4 Likes

The old school always claimed that it aimed to produce well-rounded people and that it taught general science. We know this is a complete lie, because the very foundation on which the whole of society used to survive and sustain itself was the division of people into classes, into exploiters and the exploited. Naturally, the old school, permeated throughout by class spirit, could only impart knowledge to the children of the bourgeoisie. Every word in such a school was fabricated according to bourgeois interests. In such a school, it would be more accurate to say that the young generation of workers and peasants were being trained in a way that served bourgeois interests than to say they were being educated. The purpose of educating these young people was to train servants useful to the bourgeoisie, servants who could create profits for the bourgeoisie without disturbing its peace and comfort. — Lenin: The Tasks of the Youth League
You, like the one Lenin criticized, insist on equating the old school with culture, and talk nonsense about going to the old school as learning culture and general science. This is a complete lie!
Bourgeois schools are used to cultivate the successors of the bourgeoisie. Learning culture and entering such schools to serve as the bourgeoisie’s successors, undergoing the baptism of bourgeois culture, are two entirely different things. You simply want to keep your diploma so you can get a better personal future; you just want to enjoy the kind of student life in school that is cut off from practice, from labor, and from the people, that purely parasitic student existence. And yet you brazenly claim that bourgeois schools and education can teach a supraclass general culture, and even say such things serve the revolution. How laughable!

24 Likes

I have never supported learning knowledge divorced from the masses and from practice; on the contrary, I am strongly opposed to it. When I proposed combining industry and education, I was precisely hoping to avoid such a situation. Lenin pointed out*“If you try to draw the conclusion from (criticizing the old school) that one can become a communist without mastering the knowledge accumulated by humanity, then you are making a huge mistake. The old school stuffed people with a mass of distorted, useless knowledge and carried out enslaving education; this we must criticize. But we cannot therefore refuse to inherit all the achievements of human civilization.”*

1 Like

At that time, perhaps only the old schools in Russia could spread this knowledge, so to a certain extent they had to be used; of course, I was still not clear about the situation in Russia at the time. But the «entire achievements of human civilization» are by no means something that can be learned in bourgeois institutions of learning nowadays, and bourgeois institutions of learning are also incapable of enabling people to learn

It was written incorrectly; it should be:
At that time, perhaps only the old schools in Russia could spread this knowledge, so they had to be used to a certain extent. Of course, I am still not clear about the situation in Russia at that time. But «the achievements of all human civilization» are, today, by no means something that can only be learned in bourgeois educational institutions, and bourgeois educational institutions also cannot make people learn

1 Like

We have never said that we want to reject all the achievements of human civilization. The point is that what we are clearly arguing is that bourgeois institutions of higher learning cannot provide people with much correct knowledge; they only enslave and corrupt people, which is why we must break away from bourgeois institutions of higher learning. To say that I am rejecting all knowledge—that is just sophistry, isn’t it?

You seem to be distorting one view: „learning knowledge = going to school.“ A lot of the knowledge you need does not have to be learned in school. In school, all you can do is turn out batch after batch of new wage slaves for the bourgeoisie and a newly emerging bourgeoisie. What you insist must be learned in the old school is in fact just a way to preserve your own path to getting rich and becoming part of the newly emerging bourgeoisie. Besides, what exactly are all the achievements of human civilization? The achievements of modern human civilization are not just so-called science and technology, but also a large number of repressive machines formed under exploitative systems, including the police, the army, and the bureaucracy. A society that claims all of these must be inherited is not a socialist society, but a capitalist society that oppresses workers and peasants. What you call inheriting all the achievements of human civilization is nothing more than looking for a ruling class regime that can pay you a high price and let you live by exploiting others. You hang Mao Zedong’s picture on the wall and use the banner of Marxism, but in reality you are defending your own path to promotion and wealth. Don’t you think that’s shameless?

1 Like

I can’t make sense of what sophistry you’re on about. Lenin was urging us to work hard to master the knowledge of humanity, but he never said we had to do it in the old school. Go to the old school to learn?

Is this something an AI wrote? Why does it have the classic AI asterisk formatting?

2 Likes