IV. The Path of Future Revolution
The Path of China’s Future Revolution, in brief, consists in achieving the unity of the Chinese communist movement both ideologically and organizationally through ideological struggle, and in cultivating a group of revolutionary intellectuals who possess both theoretical grounding and communist morality, so as to accomplish the task of building the revolutionary Communist Party. This path rests upon four foundations: (1) the philosophical-theoretical foundation; (2) the direct theoretical foundation; (3) the foundation of historical experience; and (4) the foundation of practical experience.
First of all, Chairman Mao Zedong once pointed out: “The absoluteness of contradiction has a twofold meaning. One is that contradiction exists in the process of development of all things, and the other is that in the process of development of each thing a movement of opposites exists from beginning to end.” In brief, contradictions exist at all times and everywhere—this is the principle of the universality of contradiction. The law of contradiction, or the law of the unity of opposites, is the core of the three fundamental laws and the essence of dialectics. It was fully expounded and developed by Chairman Mao, and constitutes the philosophical foundation of Marxism in its latest stage.
In the 1930s, there emerged in the Soviet Union the so-called Deborin school, which pursued a revisionist line in philosophy, attempting to negate the principle of the universality of contradiction and thereby to undermine this philosophical cornerstone of revolutionary Marxism. This school held that, in the initial stage of the development of a thing, there exist only differences within it but no contradictions, and that contradictions arise only in the intermediate stage of development. Dialectical materialism maintains that the fundamental driving force of the motion of all things lies in the struggle of their internal contradictions. The Deborin school, however, asserted that contradictions do not exist at certain stages, thereby inevitably leading people into the mire of metaphysics and the theory of external causes. In reality, this school represented, at that time, the interests of the kulak class within the Soviet Union. It claimed that there were only differences, but no contradictions, between the kulaks and the poor and lower-middle peasants; hence it denied the existence of class distinctions and class struggle within the Soviet Union—especially among the peasantry—and, on this basis, rejected the necessity of eliminating the kulaks and carrying out agricultural collectivization. In fact, the Deborin school failed to recognize—or refused to recognize—a fundamental point: difference itself is contradiction; what they called “difference” was merely contradiction that had not yet fully unfolded. Nor did they understand that the development of things proceeds through two states—relative rest and conspicuous change, that is, the states of quantitative change and qualitative change. These merely reflect two different forms of struggle within internal contradictions: the state in which the principal and secondary aspects of a contradiction have not yet undergone a change in their relative positions, and the state in which a fundamental change in their positions has taken place.
In the 1930s, the Deborin school was correctly criticized in the Soviet Union; however, its class basis continued to exist. Within Soviet society, the bourgeoisie “remained, with its heart
unchanged,” constantly preparing schemes for the restoration of capitalism. Prior to the passing of Joseph Stalin, owing to the fact that the Soviet Union was the first socialist country and lacked experience in socialist revolution and construction, and owing also to Stalin’s insufficiently systematic and clear understanding of the basis upon which the bourgeoisie within the country and within the Party depended for its existence—namely, bourgeois right—the Soviet Union did not thoroughly eradicate the philosophy of the Deborin school, which denies the universality of contradiction. After Stalin’s passing, bourgeois elements both inside and outside the Party made a comeback. They repackaged the theories of the Deborin school and elevated them as the philosophical foundation of revisionism, openly raising the reactionary banner of the “extinction of class struggle” and of the “Three Peaces and Two Wholes.” Under the revisionist baton vigorously wielded by Nikita Khrushchev, many communist parties in Eastern Europe, as well as those in countries such as Mongolia and Korea, failed to withstand the pressure. In these countries, serious instances of capitalist restoration occurred, and they successively degenerated into states under bourgeois dictatorship.
Chairman Mao on Class Struggle and Continuing the Revolution under Socialism
Just as this international tide of revisionism was reaching a fever pitch, revisionists within China also seized the opportunity to stir up trouble, putting forward the “theory of the extinction of class struggle” in an attempt to transform China into a capitalist country and bring about the restoration of capitalism. A marked expression of this was the speech delivered by Liu Shaoqi at the Eighth Congress of the Communist Party of China in 1956, in which he absurdly claimed that “the domestic enemy has in the main been eliminated,” that “the question of which will win, socialism or capitalism,” and “the contradiction between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie” had already been basically resolved, and that the principal contradiction within the country was now “the contradiction between the advanced socialist system and the backward social productive forces,” and that “the most important task of the state is to organize social life,” and so forth.
At this critical juncture—one bearing on the destiny of socialist China and the general direction of the world communist movement—it was the great leader Chairman Mao who stood forth and withstood the pressure from revisionists at home and abroad seeking to restore capitalism. He thoroughly refuted various revisionist theses on the theoretical plane, pronounced a death sentence on the “theory of the extinction of class struggle,” and provided a Marxist solution to the major question: “Do contradictions, classes, and class struggle still exist in socialist society?” He pointed out that socialist society constitutes a very long historical period, during which the fundamental contradictions remain those between the productive forces and the relations of production, and between the economic base and the superstructure. In socialist society, classes and class struggle still exist; class struggle under socialism is protracted and complex; and there exists the danger of capitalist restoration. The proletariat still has the task of continuing the revolution in struggle.
Chairman Mao Zedong’s teachings tell us that even after the victory of the proletarian revolution, after the establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat and the entry into socialist society, contradictions, classes, and class struggle still exist. If this is the case, then does the law of the universality of contradiction hold true before the victory of the revolution? Does it hold true during the preparatory period of the revolution? Do contradictions and struggles exist within the Communist Party in the course of the revolutionary process? The answer is in the affirmative. In capitalist society, the production of material means is in the hands of the bourgeoisie, and the production of intellectual means is likewise in the hands of the bourgeoisie. “The ruling ideas of each age have ever been the ideas of its ruling class.” Revolutionaries do not fall from the sky; they emerge out of the old society through struggle, and are all influenced by the ruling ideology of the capitalist epoch—bourgeois ideology. Even the working class must remould its thinking and raise its consciousness through Marxism, to say nothing of intellectuals who come out of the old society; they are more deeply connected with bourgeois culture and are more profoundly influenced by bourgeois ideology. From this it follows that, in the preparatory stage of the revolution, before the capitalist social system has been overthrown, bourgeois ideology still dominates the whole of society. The contradiction between bourgeois ideology and revolutionary Marxism, both within and outside revolutionary organizations, not only exists but is extremely acute. Where there is contradiction, there is struggle. In the process of building a revolutionary organization, if we do not struggle against the bourgeois ideological system, we are in effect waiting for it to defeat the socialist ideological system upon which we rely. If we do not build the Party through ideological struggle, then the Party **“would inevitably break up, first ideologically and then physically.” **
At present, the overwhelming majority of online organizations in China that fly the banner of Marxism refuse to recognize the necessity of ideological struggle. They prefer to maintain an appearance of “harmony,” addressing everyone indiscriminately as “comrade,” and, under the pretext of “freedom of speech,” recruiting people of all tendencies. They possess neither a central guiding thought nor a Marxist authority. Such organizations, while suffocating the atmosphere of struggle, at the same time suffocate the very possibility of revolutionary development.As for those ignorant and theoretically untrained “online leftists,” they prattle all day about how “the Right has already formed a monolithic bloc, while the Left is still busy expelling one another from its ranks.” They delight in gathering in so-called “Petőfi Clubs,” where they indulge together in idle chatter and vulgar, even corrupting amusements. That they can tolerate one another is due to nothing more than their shared low tastes. “Only short-sighted people can consider factional disputes and a strict differentiation between shades of opinion inopportune or superfluous.” The reason these people advocate a so-called “great unity of the leftist circles” is nothing other than to safeguard their own interests in peddling vulgar tastes under the signboard of Marxism.
To be a genuine Marxist, one must take Chairman Mao as one’s example and, at all times and under all conditions, uphold the principle of the universality of contradiction. To deny the existence of contradictions is to despise dialectics, and “dialectics cannot be despised with impunity.”
Secondly, the insistence on ideological struggle as the means to build, consolidate, and develop the Party also has its direct theoretical foundation.
As early as the first programme of struggle of the international communist movement—the Manifesto of the Communist Party—Marx and Engels already emphasized the importance of ideological struggle. They set the theoretical system of scientific socialism in opposition to the bourgeois ideological system as well as to various spurious socialist doctrines, thereby demonstrating the thoroughgoing scientific character and revolutionary nature of scientific socialism. In Chapter II of the Manifesto, Marx and Engels, with sharp and incisive strokes and in a satirical form, refuted the slanders and calumnies directed by the bourgeoisie against communism and the Communist Party, and elucidated the nature, characteristics, programme, and line of the Communist Party. In Chapter III, they carried out the most penetrating analysis of the ideological essence, as well as the social and class foundations, of utopian socialism and the various forms of spurious socialism, exposing their true features, educating the Communists and the broad masses of workers, and raising their ability to distinguish genuine socialism from false. In the Manifesto, Marx and Engels openly declared that “the Communist revolution is the most radical rupture with traditional property relations; no wonder that its development involved the most radical rupture with traditional ideas.” The birth of new ideas signifies the demise of old ones. In the process of the Party’s emergence and growth, conflict between “traditional ideas” and revolutionary ideas is inevitable. Marxists, who shoulder the great task of burying the old world and creating a new one, cannot become qualified Marxists unless they act in accordance with the teachings of the founders and make a decisive break with the traditional ideas of capitalism. A communist party that fails in this respect cannot, in the final analysis, become a qualified communist party.
Lenin once said: “We must train people who will devote the whole of their lives, not only their spare evenings, to the revolution.” The Communist Party needs precisely such people—especially in times of difficulty, especially in times when its cause is just beginning. But where are such people to come from? Certainly not from among those who, intoxicated by the empty self-satisfaction of incessantly addressing one another as “comrade,” while remaining ignorant and devoid of theoretical training; nor from those who spend their days dreaming of “doing less work, taking more pay, and exploiting others,” or “making revolution over coffee”; still less from those steeped in the capitalist vulgar tastes that fill the so-called “Petőfi Clubs.” These groups, in particular, are fond of narrowing the content and scope of politics; they “think it fit and proper to treat the workers to ‘politics’ only at exceptional moments in their lives, only on festive occasions.” Thus they complacently don the outward guise of Marxists, while in their daily lives presenting a thoroughly vulgar countenance—eagerly pursuing fame and gain, craving wealth and status, and indulging in spiritual opium and vulgar tastes.
However, we Marxists maintain that genuine revolutionaries emerge from among those who have been tempered in the three major forms of social practice, who have acquired “the sum total of human knowledge”,and who have cultivated a communist morality of “entirely subordinated to the interests of the proletariat’s class struggle.”
Chairman Mao attached particular importance to ideological struggle within the Communist Party. He stated: “The opposition and struggle between different ideas within the Party occur constantly; this is a reflection within the Party of contradictions between classes in society and of contradictions between the new and the old. If there were no contradictions in the Party and no ideological struggle to resolve them, the Party’s life would come to an end.” Yet this is precisely what the pseudo-Marxists fail to understand. They invariably take refuge in the excuse that “objective conditions are not yet ripe,” waiting for some indeterminate “sudden event” to produce a revolutionary situation, while never reflecting upon the subjective conditions required for revolution—thus closely resembling the Economists of more than a century ago.
In reality, among the so-called “Marxists” who make up the much-touted “leftward turn,” ninety-nine hundred and ninety-nine out of ten thousand do not grasp even the most elementary principles of Marxism. They do not understand even such basic truths as “practice determines knowledge” and that “one’s world outlook is the point of departure for understanding and transforming the world.” Pseudo-Marxists imagine that it suffices to speak of revolution in everyday life, and that when “the situation becomes ripe,” they will “automatically” embark upon the revolutionary road and, like great heroes, “arouse a mighty response with a single call” to “launch the revolution.” These people not only invariably regard themselves as “revolutionary leaders” standing above the masses, but also cling to an idealist conception of freedom akin to that of Eugen Dühring, naively misconstruing the relation between practice and knowledge. They treat “freedom” as something purely subjective, entirely disconnected from necessity, imagining that their minds possess the freedom to detach themselves from the world outlook formed over time and to direct their bodies at will to engage in practices wholly inconsistent with their prior thinking. In this respect, they are strikingly akin to the thought of the reactionary Ming-dynasty philosopher Wang Yangming, who held that “the moment a thought arises, action is already accomplished.”
Engels stated that “freedom is the recognition of necessity,” and that “freedom of the will therefore means nothing but the capacity to make decisions with knowledge of the subject” Our consciousness cannot attain a freedom that runs counter to objective laws; it can only attain the freedom to transform the world on the basis of a correct understanding of those laws. A person cannot act in a way that fundamentally contradicts his own world outlook—this is an objective law. Therefore, one who habitually indulges in pleasure, whose thinking is degenerate and whose spirit is empty, cannot suddenly embark upon the path of revolution. Only by recognizing the objective law that “the world outlook determines practical activity,” by continuously engaging in ideological struggle, gradually transforming our mode of life, casting off valgar tastes, and remoulding our world outlook, can we set out on the path of continuous revolution.
“We have many comrades who are still not very clear on the difference between the proletariat and the petty bourgeoisie. There are many Party members who have joined the Communist Party organizationally but have not yet joined the Party wholly or at all ideologically. Those who have not joined the Party ideologically still carry a great deal of the muck of the exploiting classes in their heads, and have no idea at all of what proletarian ideology, or communism, or the Party is. ‘Proletarian ideology?’ they think. ‘The same old stuff!’ Little do they know that it is no easy matter to acquire this stuff. Some will never have the slightest Communist flavour about them as long as they live and can only end up by leaving the Party. Therefore, though the majority in our Party and in our ranks are clean and honest, we must in all seriousness put things in order both ideologically and organizationally if we are to develop the revolutionary movement more effectively and bring it to speedier success. To put things in order organizationally requires our first doing so ideologically, our launching a struggle of proletarian ideology against non-proletarian ideology.”
Chairman Mao’s teachings stand vividly before us and must never be forgotten.
Thirdly, building the Party first on the ideological plane and then on the organizational plane is the only correct path of proletarian revolution, as demonstrated by the historical experience of the Bolsheviks and of the Communist Party of China.
At the end of the nineteenth century, the international revisionist ideological current was running rampant. Within the French Socialist Party there broke out the notorious Millerand Affair; within the German Social-Democratic Party there emerged a Right wing, represented by Eduard Bernstein, which openly clamoured for the adoption of a revisionist line, and a Centre, represented by Karl Kautsky, which covertly shielded that same line. Within the parties of Italy, Belgium, Britain and other countries as well, revisionist forces for a time became exceedingly clamorous. Under the influence of this international environment, within the first Marxist organization in Russia that united socialism with the workers’ movement—the “League of Struggle for the Emancipation of the Working Class,” founded by Lenin—there arose a revisionist faction, namely the Economists. Within the League, certain young intellectuals deeply imbued with bourgeois ideas, taking advantage of the arrest and exile of Lenin and other revolutionaries by the tsarist government, and exploiting the ideological and organizational disintegration within the Party after the First Congress, spread far and wide revisionist views of the Bernstein type. They absurdly asserted that Russia did not possess the “objective” conditions for revolution (a pretext exactly the same as that of today’s ignorant and unlearned elements at home), that political struggle was the affair of the liberal bourgeoisie, that the workers’ movement should follow “the line of least resistance” and that “a kopek added to a ruble was worth more than any socialism or politics.” This faction did its utmost to drag the workers’ movement backward, incessantly propagating the line of seeking reforms within the framework of the tsarist regime, while vigorously opposing the infusion of Marxism into the working class so as to arouse its political consciousness.
Member of the editorial board of The Martian
During his exile, Lenin had already worked out a plan for Party building. However, as he was still in exile at the time of the First Congress and was unable to attend it, the Party established at the Congress in fact possessed no proper programme, rules, or line of action; under the influence of the Economists, the Russian Party became like a heap of loose sand. Faced with this situation, Lenin resolved to build the Party first in the ideological sphere, that is, to defeat the Economists through polemics and thereby achieve ideological unity. To this end, at the end of 1900, Lenin, together with Plekhanov and others, founded abroad the revolutionary clandestine all-Russian political newspaper Iskra (The Spark). Taking Iskra as a stronghold in the struggle against revisionism, Lenin published article after article sharply criticizing the Economists’ views, rallied the various Marxist groups around himself, and, through the work of the newspaper, established a nationwide organizational network. In this way, he completed both the ideological and organizational preparations for Party building. Through a series of articles in Iskra, and above all in his most celebrated work, What Is to Be Done?, Lenin thoroughly criticized the fallacies of the Economists and expounded the fundamental principles of a Marxist revolutionary party, thereby safeguarding the newly emerging Party from the encroachment of revisionism.
In the year following the publication of What Is to Be Done?—that is, in 1903—the Second Congress of the Russian Social-Democratic Labour Party was convened under the leadership of Lenin and others. This Congress adopted the Party Programme and Rules, and elected the Party’s leading bodies. At this Congress, the Leninist faction, having won the support of the delegates, secured a majority in the Party’s leading bodies and was therefore called the “Bolsheviks,” that is, the majority. From that point on, a new type of Marxist party, fundamentally different in style from those of the Second International, came into being. Thus Lenin said: “Bolshevism arose in 1903 on a very firm foundation of Marxist theory.” This newly born Party rapidly integrated revolutionary activities throughout the country, and two years later led the world-renowned Revolution of 1905, thereby bringing to an end the period of ebb in the international communist movement, sweeping away the decadent atmosphere of the revisionist parties of the Second International, and opening up a new epoch in the international communist movement. Although the Revolution of 1905 failed, it enabled the young Bolshevik Party to gain experience, inspired the morale of the revolutionary Left wings of Marxist parties throughout the world, and laid the foundation for the victory of the Great October Socialist Revolution.
Within two years of its founding, the Bolshevik Party assumed the task of leading the revolution throughout the country; in the fifteenth year of its existence, it overthrew the largest imperialist state in the world and established the first socialist state in human history—an achievement of truly extraordinary magnitude. Through its glorious history, Lenin’s Party has proved to us that ideological struggle constitutes the foundation for the existence, development, and success of a Marxist party. As Lenin stated, “****without ideological unity, organisational unity would be meaningless.” (Literal translation from the Chinese, owing to grammatical and syntactic differences. — Tr.)
The history of the Communist Party of China likewise fully demonstrates the importance of ideological struggle. In the first fourteen years following its founding, as the supreme leadership of the Party was in the hands of opportunist elements, the Party committed numerous errors of principle in its general line and policies; only in those periods and regions where Chairman Mao’s line was implemented were great achievements made. At the time of its founding, as the Party was not yet politically mature, there existed within it quite a number of intellectuals imbued with bourgeois ideas, and they mistakenly elected Chen Duxiu— a bourgeois democrat who had gained prominence during the New Culture Movement— as General Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China.
During the period of the National Revolution, under the advocacy of Chairman Mao, the Communist Party of China pursued the path of a new-democratic revolution—mobilizing the workers and peasants and uniting with the Left wing of the Kuomintang. At the initiative of the Communist Party, the Guangdong government was reorganized into the National Government, and the Whampoa cadet corps was reorganized into the National Revolutionary Army. Within these forces, Party representatives and political departments were generally established, and political work was placed under the responsibility of Communists. From the army headquarters down to the company level, the Kuomintang Party representatives were in fact Communists. By April 1927, the Northern Expeditionary Army under Communist leadership had won successive victories, and the southern provinces were liberated one after another. Meanwhile, the peasant revolutionary movement personally initiated and led by Chairman Mao entered a period of upsurge nationwide; the revolutionary situation swept across Hunan, Hubei, Jiangxi, Guangdong, Fujian, Zhejiang and other provinces, and the membership of peasant associations throughout the country reached approximately 9.5 million. The revolutionary situation was exceedingly favorable, and nationwide victory appeared to be within sight. However, because the Right-opportunist line represented by Chen Duxiu held sway over the central leadership and adopted a wholly conciliatory attitude toward the increasingly rampant counter-revolutionary activities of the Chiang Kai-shek clique, an irretrievable situation was ultimately brought about. After the failure of the National Revolution, the Central Committee settled accounts with Chen Duxiu’s Right-opportunist line; yet thereafter the leading authority of the Party successively fell into the hands of opportunist elements such as Qu Qiubai, Li Lisan, Luo Zhanglong, Wang Ming, and Zhang Guotao. Under the conditions in which the Central Committee pursued opportunist lines, Chairman Mao was subjected to exclusion and attacks by these opportunists, and the revolutionary forces, which had with great difficulty been restored through the path of armed independent regime of workers and peasants, were once again destroyed overnight, forcing the Red Army to undertake a strategic shift.
In the course of these fourteen years of struggle, after repeated cycles of victories and defeats, advances and setbacks, the broad masses of Party members and the people finally came to recognize that only Chairman Mao was their great leader, and that only Chairman Mao’s revolutionary line was the sole correct line. The Zunyi Conference of January 1935 established Chairman Mao’s leading position within the whole Party and, at the most critical juncture of the revolution, saved the future of the Chinese revolution, marking the transition of the Communist Party of China from its early stage to maturity. As Chairman Mao pointed out, “The correctness or incorrectness of the ideological and political line decides everything.” Since the establishment of the correct revolutionary line under the leadership of Chairman Mao, the Chinese revolution turned from danger to safety and from defeat to victory, and the Communist Party of China went on to win one victory after another. However, struggle does not cease because the correct line has come to occupy the dominant position. On the contrary, Chairman Mao repeatedly stressed the importance of ideological struggle; to this end, he himself initiated and led revolutions in the ideological sphere on many occasions, in order to raise the Marxist-Leninist level and ideological consciousness of Party members, cadres, and the broad masses, and to establish a socialist world outlook. From the Rectification Movement beginning in 1941, to the Anti-Rightist Movement of 1958, the Socialist Education Movement beginning in 1962, and finally to the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution, the Communist Party of China and the Chinese revolution have advanced through storms and waves and renewed themselves in the course of continuous ideological and political struggle.
For Marxists, it is impossible to do without ideological struggle, and impossible to do without continuing the revolution. We must always bear in mind the revolutionary experience of the Bolsheviks and of the Communist Party of China, follow the path opened up by our predecessors, persist in ideological struggle and continue the revolution, so that Marxism shall forever retain its vitality.
Finally, the history of the development of our League likewise fully demonstrates the importance of ideological struggle in the establishment and development of a revolutionary organization. This constitutes the practical basis of the theory of Party-building through ideological struggle.
At the time of its founding, the vast majority of the League’s members possessed only a limited command of Marxism and had not been tempered through social practice. There was no clearly defined organizational discipline within the League, nor had any systematic programme of theoretical study yet been carried out. Consequently, the composition of the League was still rather heterogeneous. Nevertheless, from the very beginning, the League adhered to the following revolutionary principles: in all words and deeds, truth and falsehood are to be judged by the truth of Marxism as the sole criterion; all activities are to be directed toward the propagation and exposition of Marxism; and no interests of any sectarian faction are to be represented. Guided by these revolutionary principles, the League launched, from the very moment of its establishment, a movement of ideological struggle within the organization characterized by speaking out freely, airing views fully, holding great debates and writing big-character posters, using the truth of Marxism to criticize the various reactionary ideologies represented by anarchism, Trotskyism, Western Marxism, and modern revisionism. In order to expand its influence and disseminate the truth of Marxism, the League also engaged in extensive friendly exchanges with other organizations active on online platforms that claimed to study Marxism (although, despite this claim, they generally did not in fact study Marxism). In the course of these exchanges, the League carried out vigorous ideological struggle with these organizations, refuted the various opportunist currents prevalent among them, expanded the front of ideological struggle, and strengthened the influence of Marxism.
As the contradiction between Marxist ideas and anti-Marxist ideas, both within and outside the League, became increasingly acute, the problems that had previously existed among the majority of the members—a lack of theoretical attainment, lax organizational discipline, and the serious influence of liberalism—were brought clearly to light. In order to raise the members’ theoretical attainment and ideological consciousness, and thereby to wage ideological struggle against non-Marxist currents more effectively, the League strengthened organizational discipline, formulated rules governing activities within the organization, and inaugurated a systematic programme of Marxist theoretical study through the regular convening of study sessions. In the course of this process, practice gradually pointed out the path before us. A lack of enthusiasm for study, weak discipline, and an unstable class stand—all these problems pointed to one single underlying cause: the petty-bourgeois intellectual’s inherent weaknesses. The lack of enthusiasm for study stemmed from an indulgence in vulgar tastes; weak discipline arose from the habits of “freedom” and laxity cultivated through an individualistic way of life; and an unstable class stand resulted from estrangement from practice and from productive labour. As stated earlier, “the petty bourgeoisie is a class that survives in the cracks of capitalist society, a class that wavers between the two major opposing classes.”; "the petty bourgeoisie must transform itself in order to become a class that serves the revolution. "
“Necessity will ultimately carve out its own path.” Once we came to recognize that the petty-bourgeois world outlook prevailing among the overwhelming majority of the League’s members constituted a stumbling block hindering the advance of the revolution, we raised ideological struggle to a new stage in order to continue advancing the revolutionary movement and transform the League into a genuine Marxist organization. The objective was no longer merely to raise the members’ theoretical attainment, but to remould their world outlook and foster communist morality while at the same time raising their theoretical attainment. Thereafter, a vigorous rectification movement arose within the League. While remoulding their individualistic way of life and casting off vulgar tastes, the members also launched a sweeping criticism of such contemporary reactionary culture as nijigen culture, pornography, crude absurdist internet culture, and vulgar pseudo-science, all of which exert a profound influence upon petty-bourgeois intellectuals. Through this prolonged ideological struggle, the liberal atmosphere within the organization was brought under control; the proportion of members actively participating in various activities of the organization steadily increased; exchanges on theoretical and academic questions, critiques of reactionary culture, and commentary on current affairs became increasingly active; large numbers of members came forward to participate in social labour and establish ties with the working masses; and the organizational spirit, discipline, and theoretical attainment of the membership were greatly enhanced.
On this basis, the League launched, at the appropriate moment, a programme of group activities. Each group specialized in a different field of work, so that several groups advanced simultaneously, thereby narrowing the gap in theoretical attainment among the members. The smaller organizational units also made it easier to carry out exchanges concerning members’ daily lives, ideological conditions, and studies, deepened the bonds among the members, established a new type of proletarian comradely relations, and promoted the development of ideological struggle. At the same time, these group activities trained a large number of advanced members in organizational work, stimulated their revolutionary initiative, and provided a cadre foundation for the establishment of revolutionary bases.
After being tempered through a prolonged period of ideological struggle, the League expelled a large number of vacillating elements addicted to the pursuit of pleasure, together with a handful of careerists harbouring ulterior motives. It raised the theoretical attainment and ideological consciousness of the broad membership, consolidated its ranks, and established the ideological, organizational, and cadre foundations for the construction of revolutionary bases. Thereupon, within a short period, the League established revolutionary bases both at home and abroad, and our cause achieved tremendous successes. Following the establishment of these bases, we fully implemented the Shengku (Sacred Treasury) System. In accordance with the principle of “from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs,” every member turned over all his private property to the Shengku and entered employment, contributing all income earned—apart from a small amount retained for necessary personal expenses—to the Shengku. Thereafter, each person’s necessities, including food, clothing, and other daily expenses, were met directly by the Shengku. Comrades lived together according to the communist principle of distribution according to need, enjoying a life in which “those who have food share it with all; those who have clothes share them with all; those who have money use it for all; nowhere is there inequality, and no one suffers from hunger or cold.” The implementation of the Shengku System in the revolutionary bases constituted a thorough negation of the capitalist system of private property, as well as a thorough repudiation of the bourgeois reactionary theory of human nature based on the so-called proposition that man is by nature selfish. The Shengku System met the needs arising from the concentrated conduct of revolutionary activities, providing everyone with secure and free places in which to carry out revolutionary work, guaranteeing the necessities of life for revolutionary members, and raising their material standard of living. Most importantly, it fostered among revolutionaries the spirit of unity, mutual assistance, and standing together through storm and stress, while instilling in them the communist ideals of self-sacrifice and wholehearted devotion to the public interest.
Through these efforts, the League gradually developed into a revolutionary organization guided by Marxism, organized in accordance with the principle of democratic centralism, and supported by an increasingly solid material foundation.
As the foregoing discussion has shown, ideological struggle is, at present, both the indispensable means and the only path to building a revolutionary organization in China.
The purpose of carrying out ideological struggle within a revolutionary organization is, first, to enable the Party to master the advanced theory of the working-class movement—Marxism; next, to awaken the political consciousness of the working class; and finally, to awaken the political consciousness of the broad masses. Before the emergence of Marxism, the exploited and oppressed working people attempted thousands of times to overthrow their oppressors, “scores and indeed hundreds of times in the course of the centuries the labouring people have striven to throw off the oppressors from their backs and to become the masters of their own destiny. But each time, defeated and disgraced, they have been forced to retreat, harbouring in their breasts resentment and humiliation, anger and despair, and lifting up their eyes to an inscrutable heaven where they hoped to find deliverance. The chains of slavery remained intact, or the old chains were replaced by new ones, equally burdensome and degrading.” Only in countries such as the Soviet Union and China during their socialist periods did “the oppressed and downtrodden labouring masses have succeeded in throwing off the rule of the landlords and capitalists and replacing it by the rule of the workers and peasants.” “The greatness of Lenin lies above all in this, that by creating the Republic of Soviets he gave a practical demonstration to the oppressed masses of the whole world that hope of deliverance is not lost, that the rule of the landlords and capitalists is short-lived, that the kingdom of labour can be created by the efforts of the labouring people themselves, and that the kingdom of labour must be created not in heaven, but on earth. He thus fired the hearts of the workers and peasants of the whole world with the hope of liberation. That explains why Lenin’s name has become the name most beloved of the labouring and exploited masses.” Before coming into contact with Marxism, we, the great majority of workers, peasants, and petty intellectuals lived lives of material deprivation and spiritual emptiness. In order to maintain our livelihood, we were compelled to labour for the bourgeoisie; outside of work, the leisure time left to us was likewise dominated by the spiritual products created by the bourgeoisie, causing us to squander our energies on every kind of low taste and spiritual opiate. “In bourgeois society capital is independent and has individuality, while the living person is dependent and has no individuality.” Unawakened people could only become puppets manipulated by the bourgeoisie. Only after the first group of intellectuals embraced Marxism did our League come into being. It was precisely because we had the guidance of Marxism that our revolutionary organization exists today. Taking Marxism as our guide, we shall continue to blaze the revolutionary trail forward. We are confident that, before long, still more people will awaken to political consciousness, embark upon the path of revolution, transform their barren lives, become independent and integrated human beings in the course of the emancipation of society, and bring the same happiness to millions upon millions of others. “The Marxist doctrine is omnipotent because it is true.”
Secondly, the purpose of carrying out ideological struggle within a revolutionary organization is to remould the world outlook of its members, above all by resisting the non-proletarian ideas brought into the revolutionary ranks by the petty bourgeoisie, so as to overcome the petty bourgeoisie’s “diffuseness and instability…incapacity for sustained effort, unity and organised action”. Without a firm class stand and sufficient political consciousness, even the finest theory can amount to no more than empty talk. If the line is wrong, the more knowledge one possesses, the more reactionary one becomes.
Thirdly, because the ideological foundation of the petty bourgeoisie is extreme individualism, they are prone to vacillation and may even betray the revolution. This poses an immense danger to both the revolution and the revolutionary party. It is therefore necessary to eliminate unreliable elements through ideological struggle. “Opportunism in our midst is like an ulcer in a healthy organism, and must not be tolerated…If, while it is carrying on a life and death fight against the bourgeoisie, there are capitulators and traitors on its own staff, within its own fortress, the working class will be caught between two fires, from the front and the rear. Clearly, such a struggle can only end in defeat. The easiest way to capture a fortress is from within.” No technical means can eliminate the risk of betrayal by traitors; only ideological unity and organisational unity can guarantee genuine security. This is a point to which underground revolutionary organizations, already aware of the necessity of conducting clandestine work, must pay even greater attention. Throughout history, revolutions that failed because of betrayal from within have outnumbered those crushed by external forces by far more than ten to one. We must never forget this lesson.
Chairman Mao working with the people
Finally, the purpose of ideological struggle is to broaden our horizons and strengthen our ties with the masses. Ideological struggle is not carried out through the mere “arousal of a single thought”; that is Wang Yangming’s doctrine. Marxists wage ideological struggle through practice. Genuine ideological struggle begins with transforming one’s way of life, participating in the three major forms of social practice, and uprooting bourgeois and petty-bourgeois ideas. No social movement that divorces itself from reality and from the masses can succeed. The utopian socialists, the academic doctrinaires, the reformists, and the conspiratorialists of history never achieved success. As Marxists, we must read more books and newspapers and concern ourselves with the affairs of the country; we must also engage more extensively in practice and labour and maintain close ties with the masses. In this way, we acquire both rational knowledge and perceptual knowledge, enabling us to perceive the real world, while the narrow, unrealistic bourgeois and petty-bourgeois ideas are gradually remoulded. Maintaining close ties with the masses is not merely a means of broadening our horizons and gaining a correct understanding of reality; more importantly, it transforms our class feelings, enabling us to become revolutionaries in the fullest sense. Chairman Mao himself once spoke of his own experience: “If you want the masses to understand you, if you want to be one with the masses, you must make up your mind to undergo a long and even painful process of tempering. Here I might mention the experience of how my own feelings changed. I began life as a student and at school acquired the ways of a student; I then used to feel it undignified to do even a little manual labour, such as carrying my own luggage in the presence of my fellow students, who were incapable of carrying anything, either on their shoulders or in their hands. At that time I felt that intellectuals were the only clean people in the world, while in comparison workers and peasants were dirty. I did not mind wearing the clothes of other intellectuals, believing them clean, but I would not put on clothes belonging to a worker or peasant, believing them dirty. But after I became a revolutionary and lived with workers and peasants and with soldiers of the revolutionary army, I gradually came to know them well, and they gradually came to know me well too. It was then, and only then, that I fundamentally changed the bourgeois and petty-bourgeois feelings implanted in me in the bourgeois schools. I came to feel that compared with the workers and peasants the unremoulded intellectuals were not clean and that, in the last analysis, the workers and peasants were the cleanest people and, even though their hands were soiled and their feet smeared with cow-dung, they were really cleaner than the bourgeois and petty-bourgeois intellectuals. That is what is meant by a change in feelings, a change from one class to another.” Revolution has always relied upon the masses and existed for the masses. One who loves bourgeois culture cannot genuinely love the culture of the working people. To become a thoroughgoing revolutionary, it is indispensable to sweep away, through ideological struggle, those old ideas that stand in the way of drawing close to the masses.
Furthermore, ideological struggle among the people is often carried out through criticism and self-criticism, involving both self-discipline and mutual assistance. Therefore, in order to engage in ideological struggle, one must have a certain understanding of both one’s own ideological outlook and that of others, so as to achieve the principle that “if you know yourself and know your enemy, you can win every battle.” Truth is often grasped by only a minority at first; then, through struggle, it gradually opens its own path through practice and is ultimately accepted by the majority. Marxism developed in the same way. As Lenin stated, “the working class, exclusively by its own effort, is able to develop only trade union consciousness”, while “the theory of socialism, however, grew out of the philosophic, historical, and economic theories elaborated by educated representatives of the propertied classes.” Thus, the earliest revolutionary organizations consisted largely of intellectuals from the propertied classes, and ideological struggle was carried out among them. Among intellectuals from the propertied classes, those inclined toward revolution were for the most part petty bourgeois. The characteristics of the petty bourgeoisie have already been discussed above, but in order to clarify the strategy by which revolutionary organizations remould the petty bourgeoisie, we must further analyze this class.
First of all, one point must be made clear: the petty bourgeoisie refers to the class engaged in small-scale production, or employing a small number of wage labourers whom they exploit, but whose principal income consists of the returns from their own labour. This class mainly includes “ the owner-peasants, the master handicraftsmen, the lower levels of the intellectuals—students, primary and secondary school teachers, lower government functionaries, office clerks, small lawyers—and the small traders” and so forth. These petty bourgeois are divided into three sections according to their economic position and political outlook. Those whose economic circumstances are relatively comfortable, and who, after covering their expenditures on the necessities and other means of life, are able to accumulate their annual income as capital for future exploitation, are steadily approaching the bourgeoisie in their social position and are also strongly attached to the bourgeois outlook—that is, the extreme egoist philosophy that “if a man does not look out for himself, Heaven and Earth will destroy him.” These people constitute the right wing of the petty bourgeoisie. They are the smallest in number and the most hostile to the revolution; even when they participate in the revolution, they often do so with an opportunistic mentality. Though small in number, they are the most harmful. They maintain close ties with the other sections of the petty bourgeoisie and continually spread among them that foul and rotten bourgeois world outlook. Should they infiltrate the revolutionary ranks, they become a dangerous time bomb, exerting a considerable negative political influence both within and outside revolutionary organizations among the petty bourgeoisie. However, with the increasingly frequent occurrence of economic crises in capitalist society and the growing concentration of monopoly, the number and influence of such people will gradually decline. Once revolutionary activity gets underway, their influence among the petty bourgeoisie will gradually disappear if sufficient political exposé is carried out, their influence among the petty bourgeoisie will gradually disappear. The largest section of the petty bourgeoisie consists of the middle stratum, who have no prospect of becoming wealthy but are, for the time being, spared bankruptcy. Economically, they are basically self-sufficient, but owing to the inevitable trend of capitalist development, maintaining their livelihood will inevitably become increasingly difficult. Politically, this section harbours considerable resentment toward the capitalist system and the bourgeoisie. Although they take a wait-and-see attitude toward the revolution, they will not rashly oppose it. This section constitutes the centre of the petty bourgeoisie. Although they currently constitute the majority, they have little influence and generally drift with the tide, muddling through life from day to day. This situation, however, cannot last. Polarisation is an inevitable tendency in the development of exploitative-class society, and this process proceeds with particular rapidity in capitalist society. A very small number of the petty-bourgeois middle section may rise to a prosperous economic position and even become bourgeois, but the overwhelming majority will inevitably descend into a precarious existence, and may even go bankrupt and become proletarians. Thus, the political outlook of this section may in the future turn in a more revolutionary direction, but whether this possibility becomes a reality will depend upon the efforts of the revolutionary party. Finally, there is the left wing of the petty bourgeoisie. Their economic position is on the verge of bankruptcy and continues to deteriorate, and they are highly likely eventually to fall into the ranks of the proletariat. Having suffered materially and spiritually from the hardships brought about by the capitalist system, they are politically strongly opposed to the capitalist system and bourgeois rule. They are the most revolutionary and, of the three sections of the petty bourgeoisie, the most important to the revolution. There is, however, one point to which great attention must be paid. Because they have fallen from a formerly self-sufficient way of life, they may easily lapse into fantasies about a pastoral life of self-sufficiency or into an endless philosophy of death born of brooding over the sorrows of life. This tendency must be prevented from developing, and the corrosive influence of spiritual opiates on their thinking must be guarded against. The left wing of the petty bourgeoisie, lacking economic strength and political standing, attracts the least attention. But as the revolution develops, these people will play a considerable role and may transform themselves in the direction of the revolutionary proletariat, in which case their future will be boundless.
Among the petty bourgeoisie, the student population is a group that deserves particular attention, for it is enormous in number. According to statistics from the education authorities, China has a total of 518,500 schools of all types and at all levels, with 293 million students enrolled in all forms and at all levels of formal education! Such a vast student population is, in reality, the bitter fruit of the reactionary bourgeois educational system imposed by the Chinese government. Since the restoration of capitalism, the reactionary Chinese government has completely abolished the educational reform movement, gravely violating Chairman Mao’s instruction that “The period of schooling should be shortened. Education should be revolutionized”. It has desperately prolonged the length of schooling, vigorously commercialized education, hastily and shoddily turned out a large number of educational institutions of all kinds, and even whipped up a craze for “expanding university enrolment.” The number of students with a university degree or higher alone has reached 46.55 million, equivalent to approximately 158.3% of the number of senior high school students!
Although the student population is enormous and constitutes a large part of the petty bourgeoisie, its ideological outlook is far from encouraging. “One of the greatest evils and misfortunes left to us by the old, capitalist society is the complete rift between books and practical life; we have had books explaining everything in the best possible manner, yet in most cases these books contained the most pernicious and hypocritical lies, a false description of capitalist society.” The first and foremost evil brought about by the bourgeois educational system is that it divorces students from practice and from reality, subjects them to the inculcation of bourgeois ideas, and prevents them from seeing the real world at all, so that they actually come to believe that they are living in an age of peace and prosperity. In bourgeois schools, “Every word was falsified in the interests of the bourgeoisie. In these schools the younger generation of workers and peasants were not so much educated as drilled in the interests of that bourgeoisie. They were trained in such a way as to be useful servants of the bourgeoisie, able to create profits for it without disturbing its peace and leisure.” In China, generally speaking, a student enters primary school at the age of six or seven and has already reached twenty-two or twenty-three by the time of university graduation. These precious years of youth, which ought to be devoted to participating in the three major forms of social practice and developing one’s abilities, are instead squandered in the life of a study-bound ivory tower, devoted to the dead memorization of stereotyped texts. What this produces is not a capable person, but an utterly useless individual who is incapable of physical labour, knows nothing of the basic realities of agricultural production, despises labour, and keeps away from the people. Moreover, the long years of student life keep them divorced from labour and force them to live for prolonged periods as parasites sustained by others, making them especially susceptible to the corrupting influence of bourgeois ideas. Campus life under capitalism is monotonous, tedious, and repulsive to begin with. Every day, students are indoctrinated by books, schools, teachers, and parents with the extreme individualist ideas that “study in order to become an official; study in order to make money” and “the weak are prey to the strong; survival belongs to the fittest.” At the same time, they bear an enormous burden of homework, mechanically and relentlessly studying until they are crushed beneath the pressure and can scarcely breathe. It is only natural, then, that their thinking becomes rotten and their spirits empty, leaving them no choice but to seek amusement in the spiritual opiates manufactured by the bourgeoisie. Through the prolonged process of being indoctrinated with reactionary ideas, consuming spiritual opiates, and pursuing vulgar tastes, students become saturated with bourgeois low culture characterized by the grotesque, the listless, the decadent, the hooliganistic, the pornographic, and the violent. Thus, the younger generation of our great Chinese nation has fallen into the abyss of moral degeneration. If this continues, where in Chinese society will there remain a single uncontaminated place? Across the land of China, demons and ghosts will run rampant, and in the end there will be nothing left but the destruction of the country and the extinction of the nation.
Different Opiates, Same Effect
Nevertheless, there remains in the students the latent hope of transformation, the hope of revolution. As the polarization of Chinese society becomes increasingly severe, competition among the petty bourgeoisie becomes ever more acute, and the oppression imposed on students by their parents and schools grows ever heavier. This will inevitably arouse among students dissatisfaction with the bourgeois educational system and dissatisfaction with the capitalist political system, prompting them to reflect. Although students have long lived a parasitic life sustained by others, the capitalist social system will inevitably cast the majority of them into the ranks of enslaved wage-labourers. Faced with the only path open to the petty bourgeoisie as it moves toward decline, are they to rack their brains scheming and maneuvering in order to become obedient bourgeois lapdogs, winning a few scraps from the bourgeoisie’s table; or are they to accept the transformation of their class identity into that of the proletariat, rise up in revolt against this unjust old society, and join the mighty torrent of proletarian revolution? This is the choice that history will inevitably place before these students.
The students are all of the younger generation. Although they have been influenced by bourgeois education and poisoned by spiritual opiates and vulgar tastes, they are, after all, less ideologically hardened than those who have spent their entire lives steeped in the icy waters of individualism. Their world outlook is still in a process of constant development and growth, and there remains room for revolutionary remoulding. As long as they have perseverance and determination, and can withstand the long and painful process of ideological remoulding, stripping these decayed elements of bourgeois culture from their minds, China’s young students can still accomplish great things. China’s students should recognize the historical law that capitalism is bound to perish and socialism is bound to triumph, join the great ranks of the proletariat, and take part in the just cause of the emancipation of all humanity. All Marxists and revolutionary organizations in China should attach importance to this special force within the petty-bourgeois ranks represented by the students, and actively encourage, support, and guide them, so that they may embark upon the bright path of proletarian revolution. The revolution in China will sweep away the air of decay that has settled over our Chinese youth, and make them once again “the sun at eight or nine in the morning” !
In short, revolutionary organizations must adopt different strategies toward different classes and different class elements, according to the actual circumstances. The proletariat is the core force on which we rely, while the bourgeoisie is our irreconcilable enemy; this is self-evident. As for the petty bourgeoisie, we must likewise differentiate among its different elements and treat them accordingly: develop and absorb the Left; unite with and remould the Centre; isolate and strike at the Right. So long as we adopt the correct strategy, the petty bourgeoisie will become a revolutionary force that cannot be underestimated. Another point that must be noted is that different attitudes and policies must be adopted toward members of revolutionary organizations and petty-bourgeois elements outside the Party. Revolutionary organizations must establish a broad-based auxiliary organization that extensively recruits petty-bourgeois elements, taking “gentle breeze and mild rain”, that is, gentle persuasion and patient guidance, together with “curing the sickness to save the patient” as its guiding principle, and adopting “speaking out freely, airing views fully, holding great debates and writing big-character posters” as the forms through which to communicate with them and remould their world outlook. Toward petty-bourgeois elements outside the Party, we should adopt flexible, accommodating, and compromising strategies. We should not demand that they observe the organizational discipline of the revolutionary organizations, but we must insist, in the realm of public opinion, on clarifying right and wrong, rather than allowing ourselves to be led by the nose by them. Chairman Mao pointed out that the united front is one of the Communist Party’s three magic weapons. A clear-sighted revolutionary could never believe that the vanguard alone can engage the bourgeoisie in a decisive battle. In the course of revolution, a proletarian revolutionary party cannot avoid dealing with the various strata of the petty bourgeoisie, nor can it avoid recruiting “fellow travellers” of various political hues. “There is nothing abnormal or terrible in this, if the proletarian party is able thoroughly to absorb these foreign bodies, to control and not be controlled by them”.
The path of China’s future revolution has now been made clear. However, it is necessary to point out that Marxism is not a dogma, but a guide to action. The application of any general law must take into account the concrete circumstances and specific characteristics of the movement.
In this epoch of imperialism, the peoples of different countries, subjected to different forms of suffering in countries at war or at peace, are increasingly seeing the truth clearly: the “permanent prosperity” of capitalist society and the “permanent peace” of the capitalist world are nothing but lies. The masses of the people are increasingly being aroused by the tyranny and brutality of the Chinese imperialist government and stirred by the various ugly phenomena of Chinese capitalist society. Our revolutionary cause “would become part of an enormous pair of smith’s bellows that would fan every spark of the class struggle and of popular indignation into a general conflagration.”
“The Communists disdain to conceal their views and aims. They openly declare that their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions. Let the ruling classes tremble at a Communistic revolution. The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win.”
Workers and Oppressed Peoples
of all countries,
Unite!!!